Redleg

Our first 9 entries gave us no score at all and Cats had at the same time 2 entries for 2 goals. Coachless.

That is true. It looks like we don’t know what to do. We don’t man the goal line on a shot and we keep the ball in, when we are standing on the boundary line near their point post. Then we don’t man up in defence allowing short passes to guys on their own. That is the result of a poorly coached, poorly selected and poorly organised team. This bomb it in game is a disaster.

His 50 metre penalty with a minute or so to go was pathetic. Melksham and Hannan were in the goal square and only one defender anywhere near them and he walks forward, then ignores them and kicks to Melksham one out against 3. Can we be more unaware or have less urgency when the game unbelievably was still there to win.

Obviously front on contact isn’t a free if it is to a Melbourne player. Melksham in goal square and Tom MAC .

Poorly selected. Poorly coached. No skill. Dumb. Don’t touch balls on goal line. Don’t put ball over the boundary. No game plan.

I have held out for a while but we have no coach. This is garbage. They are one down and beating us and we have kicked 3 goals in 3/4. Picked a team of flankers and most have hardly touched it. Worst skills of any team in the AFL by a mile. Can’t handball to advantage and can’t kick the footy to a team mate. No game plan or system at all.

Dumbest football team ever. Keep the ball in play and give another goal. Actually making me sick being beaten by an ordinary side one man down.

Tom MAC hasn’t taken a mark but is playing well, bringing the ball to ground, but our crumbing is terrible. Needed to play another key forward, too many flankers doing nothing.

Couldn’t hurt.

He has half a game to keep his place.

Has cost us 4 times. Pathetic so far.

The game is not about punching players in the back, hard enough to crack their ribs and bruise their lung. All done deliberately to a guy who can’t see you coming. That ain’t a love tap. Rules say straight to the tribunal and minimum 3 weeks. BTW Carlton played one short as a result the whole game. Nice tactic for a GF to a star of the opposition if it was legal. AFL would love that.

Might be worth having a chat to Mitch Lewis at Hawthorn, seems on the outer and might be unhappy.

Even low grade hammies need about 21 days. Can't see them risking him in 14 days.

What new rule? I have watched it a few times and can't work out what he did, other than try to get to the full back who had played on. He actually was blocked by another player and fell over. Bizarre.

We know he isn’t match fit. He played 50% of the first game he has played since leaving Freo and seemingly heading to retirement. They have got him back and we have to trust they know how to get the most out of him and keep his career going.

Looks like Jon Ralph is trying to stir up trouble. Has written that despite Goodwin saying Harley was not picked on a minutes on ground basis, that Harley believes he was dropped for poor form. Unless he has spoken to Harley that is pretty ordinary.

Don't be upset, it is probably due to that polluted water he ingests in his lilypond.

Just as we don't have a vaccine for the virus, we also don't have one for stupidity, bigotry and violence.

They won't cut lists too dramatically, maybe only a couple and Petty is absolutely safe.

While Lethal is my number 1 player over the last 50 years, he was a thug, who would king hit from behind, when he went after a player probably because he wasn't having a great day. No, the rules did not allow him to do that. My favourite player in the same period and also most talented was the great Robbie. Top footballer and top bloke. Sadly missed.

Well for what it is worth, I really like Petty and think he will be very good for us. He is big and a great mark and just needs to improve his set shot kicking. I was desperate to get Rivers with our last pick and that is looking ok atm. The other kid I have been a big wrap on since we got him is Jordon and I am following his progress with great interest.

JeremyFinlayson Redleg posted a topic in Melbourne Demons This bloke was gettable last trade period and I was pushing him hard on DL, with not a lot of support from other posters. Given our current position with key forwards and his form, he would have been invaluable. GWS was looking to make salary cap room and he would not have cost a lot in s... May 27, 2019 49 replies JeremyFinlayson Redleg posted a topic in Melbourne Demons 196 cm key back at the Giants is apparently available, though contracted until 2020. He has pace, good disposal skills and can take a grab. He could play back or forward and gives us further options. He would be far cheaper than May and is 4-5 years younger. IMO should be looked... September 21, 2018 19 replies

I see that we haven't been put back on the footy board, even though we are the most popular footy thread ever on DL.