Everything posted by Deeoldfart
- PODCAST: SEASON 2023 PREVIEW
- Second worst week in football
-
Your Top 5 Demons Players of All Time
In my long lifetime, and after (perhaps) one too many glasses of Shiraz: 1. Robbie (RIP) - for those who didn’t see him play, you (sadly) missed something very, very special! He was pure magic on the field, and revered by all footy fans, regardless of their allegiances. Deserves a ‘stand alone’ chapter in the history books of our sport. It’s an absolute travesty that he didn’t win a Charlie! 2. RDB - inspirational player and leader of our great Club, in (perhaps) the most dominant era of any VFL / AFL team. Shared the title of ‘Mr Football’ with the great Ted Whitten. Say no more! 3. Clarrie - only part way through an outstanding career that we’ve all witnessed first hand. The envy of every other team in the AFL …….. the type of player who makes a good team great! No need to elaborate further, I’m sure! 4. Shwarta - There have been plenty of great CHFs in my time (Hart, Walls, Brereton & Carey to mention a few) but none of them could hold a candle to ‘the Ox’ pre multiple knee recos. He could have been anything! 5. Jimmy (RIP) - an icon of our Club and our game, based on where he came from, what he achieved on the field, and who he was off the field (RIP).
- PODCAST: SEASON 2023 PREVIEW
- PODCAST: Brodie Grundy Interview
- PODCAST: Brodie Grundy Interview
-
Welcome to Demonland Josh Schache
IIRC, when Weid (who was contacted at the time) sought to be traded out for more opportunities, we agreed to let him go, subject to getting a ‘like for like’ replacement. We recruited Schache as that replacement, and imo he adds more to our squad, and has more ‘senior level upside’, than Weid. Only time will tell, I guess.
-
AFL Captains Vote
Those two would be Geelong and Brisbane …….. wishing and hoping, but not thinking! 😊
-
1958 Grand final
Bugger you David. I was still trying to erase 1958 from my memory.
- PODCAST: Practice Match vs Richmond
-
PODCAST: Brodie Grundy Interview
…….. and aligned to Moe’s question, how does Brodie rate the ‘culture’ at Melbourne. No need to ask him how it compares with C’wood (I think we probably know the answer to that!) but I’d every interested to hear his views on our culture, and any insights as to how he was ‘inducted’ to the Melbourne ‘way’.
- PODCAST: Practice Match vs Richmond
- PODCAST: Practice Match vs Richmond
-
PODCAST: Practice Match vs Richmond
As an ‘interstater’ I could only watch the game on TV. While there were some standout players (for me they were Tracc, Max, Maysie, Nibbler, Hunter and Bowser) the aspects that impressed me most were how well our boys seemed to be ’on the same page’; how ‘even’ we appeared across the field; and how fit we seemed to be compared to the Tigs. Are these reasonable observations(?) and if so, how well does it place us for what is a very tough draw in the early part of the season proper? IMO, with the draw we have, it would be a great indicator of how far we can go in 2023 (barring significant injuries), if we are 3 zip after 3 games.
-
Playing injured
Thanks Luci. Nice ‘balanced’ assessment and summary.
- GAMEDAY: Practice Match vs Richmond
-
Farewell Luke Jackson
Exactly bin. Jackson even stated in an interview shortly after being recruited by Freo, that he had decided mid-season to ‘return home’ at season’s end.
-
PODCAST: Match SIM vs St. Kilda
'Training the house down' as usual! Great season opener. Thanks Andy & Bin!
- POSTGAME: Match SIM vs St. Kilda
-
PODCAST: Match SIM vs St. Kilda
PS. I’m also interested in the panel’s views on Kade Chandler as a small crumbing forward. I love Kade’s attack on the contest, and the defensive pressure that he brings, but I don’t see the ‘spark’ that separates the good crumbing forwards from the rest. IMO it’s important for us to have a 25+ a season small forward to fill this role, given the likelihood of us having a tall forward half, and Kozzie spending a fair portion of his time on ball.
-
PODCAST: Match SIM vs St. Kilda
Based on reports from our track watchers, and vision of the Sim on Friday, Judd McVee has emerged from a ‘long way back’ as being a genuine prospect in the space of one pre season. (What a bonus that would be!). I’d be interested in the panel’s ‘gut feel’ on how readily his pre-season form might translate to the real thing (?); is he a genuine chance for R1(?); and do you see him becoming a regular best 23 during the season, and if so whose spot is vulnerable (?)
-
GAMEDAY: Match SIM Melbourne vs St. Kilda
I wonder how much we will be able to gauge from today’s hit out? I’ll be mostly looking for some hints and insights into tactical / game plan changes that we might take into the ‘23 season, and some clues as to the possible ‘pecking order’ where there seems to be strong competition for spots in our best 23.
-
TRAINING: Wednesday 22nd February 2023
Thanks BBP. Great news if reliable. This would indicate that he’s been cleared of any significant structural damage.
-
TRAINING: Wednesday 22nd February 2023
BBB presumably being ‘managed’. How are TMac and JVR looking?
- Training and Trackwatching