Demon_JB

How did Ben Holland compare to Nick Holland?

Pederson to come in and rotate ruck with Frost and Watts. Plain and simple.

Whoops, forgot about Lewis lol

Out: Spencer, Smith, JKH In: Pederson, Bugg, Kennedy

OUT: Weeds, Hannan IN: Hogan, Hibberd.

Lmao, apart from the obvious sarcasm of this post he was well on the money. Catch ya never Stuie. GOLF.

Why in the world are people suggesting ANB to be dropped? Apart from a couple of brain-fades, he has been one of our best players over the first 3 rounds. Honestly, there are some people on here that have absolutely no clue. A player turns the ball over once or twice which results in a goal and they want them immediately out of the squad. Wouldn't surprise me if you're the type of people that has a go at a cashier because you've been waiting in the line for your soy latte's for too long. Give us a spell.

Just had a chat with Dr Turf. Reckons we're a huge chance to get up even without Lewis and Hogan. Very optimistic. Go Dees.

Start believing this is the year. To go in against Geelong without important players like Lewis, Hogan, Hibberd and winning would be more than enough to prove that we are capable of playing finals.

It makes sense he hasn't put pen to paper yet. If he continues the season as he did on the weekend, he could potentially almost double his salary. Will be a great tactic of motivation of wanting to end the season strong and make himself an in demand player. Smart move.

Brayshaw for Lever. Get it done.

Does anyone else think that with our new game plan under Goodwin it actually suits Etihad more than the G'? Watching the way we played against the Saints, playing on at every opportunity, just running up the narrow ground and kicking it long really suited our style. Interesting to see how we fair against the Cats.

Absolutely raging...

As a team, we really need to back ourselves in and look for the first option. We seem to overuse our handballs and look to walk our goals through as opposed to just backing yourself in and having a ping for goal. We always look to dish it off when instead the players should be kicking for goal...

That dropped mark by Brayshaw in the last quarter right in front of the sticks from Garletts kick was nothing short of amateur. [censored] like that needs to be stamped out of the game.

Probably the most obvious statement on demonland

Last week we were playing on at every opportunity. We look like we are caught in mid every time we take possession...

OUT: J Smith, Vince IN: Harmes, Tyson Can Harmes be a good addition to a floater across half back? Pretty good closing speed and has a great leap?

Round 1, St Kilda vs Melbourne... Melbourne...M Gawn... one vote Melbourne...N Jones...two votes Melbourne.........C....Oliver....three votes.

Oliver has been my favourite player before he even played, and time and time again he proves it. Not sure if many of you watch the way he goes about his footy, but players of his ilk and skill do not come around often. The way he grabs the ball mid air and fires off a handball before landing is nothing short of art. The way he picks up a ball and instantly throws his hands in the air and handballs over his head to a player running into space is mouth watering. He runs from content to contest bullocking his way through. Honestly, Clayton Oliver is the perfect mixture between grunt and sublime skill. He will be our become our most elite mid and one of the best players in the AFL. Watch this space.

We really need to stop handballing too high for our players. There's nothing more frustrating where a hand ball shoots out and one of our players has to jump for it and completely halts the momentum, which then starts a chain of tackles and a massive struggle to get it out...

Sorry mate, but there is no way Tyson, Kent and Jetta all miss.

Gawn struggles against athletic ruckman like Hickey. Playing Spencer will allow us to throw Gawn deep in the Forward which will allow Hogan to press up. Will cause headaches for the defenders.

As soon as I first saw Oliver, I knew we had an absolute star. The poise, the way he handballs in traffic, dips and side steps and waits for a team mate to be free before releasing the handball is something you don't see every day. Will reach higher achievements than Petracca and most other young stars. Watch this space.

I honestly believe anyone can make it onto an AFL list with the application, desire and heart. This is why Jack Viney is one of my favourite players. He isn't blessed with speed, height, or silky smooth skills but he makes up for the lack of things he can't control with the things he can. If Tim Smith wants to be best 22, he can. Just like any other player on our list. It just boils down to how BADLY you want that.