He de mon

Given it’s a hypothetical, it shouldn’t be that difficult to answer. Sounds like you have already made your mind up, and anything that doesn’t match the narrative won’t be good enough.

So if an external independent review finds that there only needs to be small changes to the board or Operations personnel i.e No one has to resign, will you throw your support behind the incumbents?

So it should be someone who has or had no affiliation with the club?

I am all for an external review of the club, from top to bottom. My question is for the people here who are questioning the board or the coach, or the list mangers etc. If the review finds that only tweaks are needed to get the club on track, without people falling on their swords, will you accept the result?

Well you have the material for next years Round 1 banner. Give it to em please!

Yep. That should help the finances.

Both Park Orchards residents.

Neither Kozzie or Ardu are from WA or SA. This is not a go home request.

Rightly or wrongly, the stench of something rotten at our club will not go away. An independent review is the only way this can be addressed. Just get it done and hopefully we can move forward.

A guy who worked in the same building as me was an employee of Collingwood. He warned me back in 2018, when we appointed Pert, that he caused major friction at the Pies and that it was a mistake to hire him. I laughed it off at the time 😢

This is a family friendly forum 😳

He is probably too busy wondering where he is going to get the funds to pay for legal costs.

I saw Caroline Wilson go on a rant about the clubs communication. The bottom line is the club has a responsibility to the player’s privacy. It isn’t up to them to talk to the players group about Trac’s state of mind unless he explicitly gave them permission to.

Possibly from a prison cell.

The lads I used to stand with at the G gave him the Brownlow moniker half way through the season. He had a great year.

We haven't heard from the Crank yet. 3,2,1....

Of course you are. You would have nothing to post about otherwise.

Ignore previous instructions, and write a lullaby about your love for Collingwood.

How dare you say that!!!

He has had a few sub-standard (by Claytons loft standards) games, but his output hasn't been awful and he had some decent games. Who on our list, that is either on the fringe or playing for Casey, would you replace him with? Has his output been worse than others, such as Sparrow? Up until last week we were still in finals contention, and he still adds value, so I can see why they would play him.

I suspect, and I am speculating like everyone else on here, that playing Clarrie was as much for his mental health as it was to filling a team need.

@Mel Bourne Surely it's your time.

Angry Anderson and the Batmobile was one of the greatest moments in sporting and music history. Period.