58er

FT Duryea was announced this week a one year extension with Dogs.

Ted I have updated and corrected your figures re Simons record. Uou have conveniently forgotten 2017,18,19 and 20. When he was about 48%. See my post about 2 pages on with what I believe are correct 2021 to 24 and overall record.We have lost more than 29games plus finals. since 2021. Including Finals. It’s 34 or 35 I think.

Simpson or younger coach.

You do realise that the major role of forwards is TO KiCK GOALS. It’s Goody’s and therefore some Dees fans over fascination with defence that means you say no to recruits thst may be worthwhile or don’t average 10 tackles per game it’s a NO. BTW you forgot Chandler and ANB. Who are tackling mad. It’s a cautionary YES but no big coinage. Swap Tommo with Tim.

I am saying our strategy needs to change as per our success previously. We targeted players through Simon and Max interviewing prospects.

We can’t afford another lack lustre style of play and although injuries occurred we can’t risk another contest/ defence season of booting footy. We will get less crowds and fans if we do. Good time for change and refresh our Club and be a destination Club again.

Was Ginnivan there in Bucks time at Pies?

I think it’s P 99 W 63 L 35 D. 1. which overall would be about 63/64 % in other seasons the figures are 2017. W. 12. L. 10 2018. W. 16. L. 9 2019. W. 5. L. 17 2020. W. 9. L. 8 TOT P 86 W 42 L 44 Simon’s career record so far is Overall total is P 185 W 105 L 79 D 1 Thsts about 56. 5%

Nothing we can do unfortunately.

But they had 45 injuries don’t you know?

Waste of paper you wrote on DD not even funny or sensible or quirky. Please don’t try again.

Really DD you take Brocks opinion ? He has no right to any opinions IMO after he did what he did as whistleblower. If the haters are still unchanged re Trac they should absolutely disregard a stupid comment like this. What do players on other Clubs get to training Free Ubers? Even other Clubs have some transport issues. BTW it didn’t harm us in 2021 when the same size MCG oval was prioritised and the other facilities. let’s be more grown up and sensible on this issue. Caulfield hopefully will prevail asap.

Well that’s the very reason Simon needs to go or change his philosophy. You have seen a power Club self destruct with a lame administration in front of your own eyes. With an equally out of his use by date by at least 1,year. We need drastically a change of style and attitude to footy with some fun back in the game. If not our fans will leave as we are unattractive and not entertaining. It pains me to say that with 3 or more of our champions playing still and individually are still great. But the team needs a refresher from the coaches.

We weren’t 1/2 years ago and it’s only your opinion. Simon has wooed some of our best recruits Maysie and Lingers I believe so Maybe with Maxy get started again.

Dr you are living in rut if you think that Simon can’t do what a Senior Coach is paid for. we hat about his Assistants they are responsible aren’t they under a Simon’s influence and direction. Yhankfully we have a new forward coach we hen he is chosen who I hope can understand how a forward line should operate. Dimon this last season is still caught up with contest/defence and the offensive play of the forward line is vastly overlooked. What should have happened is that MJ could have net given a trial in the G coast game. AMW should have played looking to 2025 but Don says nothing changes. And that’s it. Look at Sam Mitchell I can imagine how different he would have our list. Uf you can’t see changes are necessary then we will make but during the year it st end of 2025’if Simon doesn’t see the light.

Sorry but we need a change of philosophy and style to get the younger players having fun etc. and not as if their life is at stake.

Simpson perhaps there are some over here Just not in WA.

Why Fritta? You will say he doesn’t tackle.? Really we can’t have any more bulls we need finishers like Fritta and other skilled and pacy players. 40 goals plus every year is irreplaceable for us. It’s all about a balance and it’s easier eogg try k on an existing player mostly than get a new one when that type is not necessarily available.

Possibly turn him into a tagger? oh Simon doesn’t do ragging. well Simon doesn’t do what ply he wants and needs to be more expansive and aggressive or he will fall on his own sword. And he hasn’t got Kate for chief supporter now.

Ben is best placed in AFLW at present and Melk has impressed it seems. Who knows where and when for him?

Would rather risk a high pick on Jack Lukosious than give Kent field an extension . Risk and reward and instant player is crucial to us in our window now. Highly skilled and change a bonus for him should be our Mantra.

Do you actuall know that.? At least you said seemed! Did you ever speak with him? Same as Jack Watt but that is not fair to JW really. Some people you could shake and scream at and Shacky was thst. But I draw the line and say that he probably was dedicated but just didn’t ooze it. Good Luck JS A talent wasted at AFL level.

Sestan one more year with fitness very important. Same with McAdam please.

Who is nearly past his use by date. Some of the footy this year was disgraceful and he is not teaching our youngsters the proper balance of the game. Contest/ defence is not the only way and outdated ( possibly more useful in Finals) but you must aim to kick goals not just save them. )

Look at his record. Doesn’t seem too slow. another idi..ic and typical comment without any sense from yourself. Why contribute and not support the Dees.