58er

If the selection policy is fair dinkum Nibbler will have to play his 2021 form in '23 to stay in the team. Love his team first attitude and gut running but his decision making and finishing let him self down this season. Faces a serious challenge from Kade Chandler and possibly JJ for his AFL spot which hopefully brings out his best including 20 goals or more this season.

Yes but his best is about 2/3?years ago and injury can be an issue after a layoff. My point is that the role we may prefer Brodie to play could well be a bit different from CFC and more midfield centric. Has he the skills straight away to hit the ground running no matter what his ability has shown as a ruckman? The jury is out also in this Demonstrative !! PS sometimes even juries can get things wrong. FWIW I think by the end of the season flag or no flag Brodie will be classed as a great pick up fir us and a team improvement on Jacko but not necessarily in the earlier rounds.

Give them a go Tiers Remenber when Trac was starting off ? Till 2020 there were many D/Lers who wanted to clear him. They have gone to ground like turtles never to be seen again! Key positions are there low point esp. in defence but they have lost too many 2016 Flag players and each season some others ie Schache and Hunter are leaving for cultural reasons. Coaching an issue I wonder?? It's different from Weid Hunty and Toby who are seeking greater games and growth but not culture IMO.

Good reply LVDC That could well be your favoured topic on Hard Quiz though!!

Carltons total of 81 is the second lowest of the total shots for the season. IMO they are the biggest underperforming team in the AFLW In the last 4 years since their 2029 GF debacle at the Crows hands. And they keep reappointing their Coach Daniel Hartford who has another year to run in his contract. Plus the media on TV want them so biasedly to win games and pump up their players. Even Darcy Vesio has lost her glamour and footy smarts since being banished to defence even though she is playing solid footy. In AFLW they are about as relevant as GWS.

Why not a winger?

Really KM stop looking for scapegoats over 2 games of footy! in your other post you have blamed even the Board! MFC I presume who would have no say ( vote or similar) on this timing. Actually the timing is probably making Casey Fields available for start of VFL next season. Who exactly are disorganised? And it's not even disrespectful as its a plus for the girls for the next 20 years of our AFLW home games. PS Hope Mach 5 doesn't blame Perty for this!!!

Because of their next superstars youth. Naughton Bailey Smith Jamarra UH Sam Darcy Cody Weightman and their first ruck star! LDVC You ought to read more widely.

Yes we are awaiting 5/6 hial MCG Kissie epic. Make it in 2023 Kossie and sign on for some more highlights and flags!!

DZ Maybe you have never heard of him because his name is Taylor WhitFORD not Whitfield!!!

DJR You have a right in querying my question about Brodie and saying that I don't think he will be an embarrassment in our midfield. Yes he has a great CV but we I believe will try and get a more midfield role in his game to than at the Pies. My point is that he has some good mid field skills more than most rucks and should be able to learn/ adapt to suit our on the ball style of recent years. I also think he may take a month or so to hit top form after his injury and length of time omissions in 2022. But the jury may still be out about his role and suitability for a part of the year irrespective of your glowing AA etc CV.

Binns not Buns sorry.

Buns Might be more that we want than Szybkowski as he is a runner and mid. !

Is he an elite footballer or just a good pick up for no 37? Sounds like a good chance at 37 if he gets that far.

What's "Chonky" a new age term for chunky? Or a misspelling? Clearly most recruiters can separate unfit/ overweight to well built physically. If they can't shouldn't be in those positions of Trust!

I would have thought we addressed quite simply and efficiently on losing Jacko this year. Or have you forgotten the name Brodie Grundy. Yes thats the new 2nd ruck with some mid field skills better than most his size. And I haven't closed the door of him developing forward craft to say get 15/20 goals if he is rested up front. Maxy's only done this really once and he was a waste in the last 10/12 games banged up ( thanks to that disgracefully deliberate jump by the American Pie into his back on QB afternoon starting his demise). Maxy was purely up front to test the oppo defence and stop it's marking of our pretty impotent forays forward or to the LH pocket and prevent our hopefully Gawn mark and goal as well which did not eventuate. We can address specifically the KPF next draft with one of our four picks along with a future ruck prodigy and Jacko May be a mostly distant memory, (except our bang bang bang 3Rd Quarter unforgettable highlight Flag junkies like me) hopefully replaced with the 2023 version of Flag memories of equal jubilation. If of course Pick 37 still has a tall timber prospect of high skill and Hope available then that's a bonus really.

Common sense Poita it's not rocket science.

Agree completely Kent. This obsession with the 2021 heroes even with injuries proves that even they are not superhuman. Lessons must be collectively learned from Goody down ( or up to the medics)

Congratulations Sarah 50 great and reliable games. And some big ones to follow over the next month. Showing the Demon Spirit each day on the field for us. All the best.

The greatest player or bet would be for Harry Petty to lock down a key forward post all season. He is good and big enough to be a match winner with Tmac JVR BBB and Fritta at their best. His growth on the forward line would far outway any marginal improvement down back. Disco Tommo Smithy and Tmac can go there even JVR if needed as cameos. Disco also as a great improvement snd Riv to get over his injury and have his best season plus Bowser is ready to fire after another preseason and stronger body. I also believe Chandler if given the opportunity will surprise and deliver .

Please outline what improvements Clarry can make to improve himself and us . If you are mocking this question as I suspect you are not really funny!

Depends if you feel that is a benefit for some players as a step to AFL. Brodie has enough base on his AFL learnings to be at a consistently greater level than Jacko in tapping marking shepherding and match awareness along with a tandem operation with Maxy. He should provide a further step in our midfield with our mids and embrace the opportunity of playing up forward or down back as our system demands or needs. Jacko has such mobility clever ball play and movement and is cool under pressure and while Brodie has not starred in those categories I don't think he will be an embarrassment in our midfield. He is a cool customer and he is ready for a new start in our team which can assist us in starting to control the game with both big ruckman playing a vital role all over the ground.

A USA mum!!!

Yes Mac I think it's JJ not playing aggressively and our flow game plan and lack of movement that combines and completely destroys momentum. Thats Goody's and the coaches job to solve that. Pretty simple really. JJ is good enough to carry out this new plan of speed.

Agree Ollie not just think but play on from a mark if possible