Everything posted by roy11
-
2025 Smithy's VFL Team of the Year
afl.com.au2025 Smithy’s VFL Team of the Year squadThe 2025 Smithy's VFL Team of the Year squad has been announcedA squad of 40 players in contention for selection for the 2025 Smithy’s VFL Team of the Year has been selected. The final team of 24 players will be named on Monday, September 15 at the 2025 VFL and VFLW Awards. A captain and coach will also be selected. Coburg and Frankston have the equal most representatives in the 2025 Smithy’s VFL Team of the Year squad, with five players each. The full list of club representation was: Box Hill Hawks (four), Brisbane Lions (two), Carlton (two, including Liam McMahon), Casey Demons (three), Coburg (five), Collingwood (two), Essendon (two, including Liam McMahon), Footscray Bulldogs (three), Frankston (five), Geelong Cats (one), GWS GIANTS (one), North Melbourne (one), Port Melbourne (one), Richmond (one), Southport Sharks (three), Werribee (three) and Williamstown (two). Gold Coast Suns, Northern Bullants, Sandringham and Sydney Swans did not have a representative selected. The Three Casey players; Riley Bonner, Casey Demons 18 matches this season, 3 goals Averages 31.6 disposals, 6.4 rebound 50s, 4.4 inside 50s Tom Campbell, Casey Demons 15 matches this season, 7 goals Averages 17.5 disposals, 26.5 hitouts, 7.9 hitouts to advantage Mitch Hardie, Casey Demons 16 matches this season, 26 goals Averages 25.8 disposals, 8.7 score involvements, 4.2 inside 50s Former Dees: Declase/Tomlinson Is it worth sniffing around any of the names on this list?
-
Farewell Judd McVee
Given what our track watchers have said, it's a confusing situation (not doubting the intel) Pick 11 in a weak draft which is heavily compromised, not sure I like that. IF he was to be traded, what would a fair trade for us be?
-
Who Will Be Our Next Coach?
do you think we'd get better sponsorship offers with Bucks at the helms as opposed to Kelly or one of the others from a personal pov (excluding results)
-
Who Will Be Our Next Coach?
The joys of divorce
-
Shane McAdam v Jack Martin
The last injury really unfortunate based on all reports - any idea how his rehab is going?
-
Who Will Be Our Next Coach?
Assume Tassie will get some soft cap concessions, maybe being able to build his own team from scratch AND the extra pay an incentive for Bucks to be a little on the fence right now.
-
Trade Targets
consistent with the last few years at least aha
-
Farewell Charlie Spargo
On his day he was a good cog player, sadly injuries have cruelled him. Long live Spargoat. North a bit of interesting for mine though, i know they need experience but not sure about this one for them
-
2025 Membership Ladder
Diabolical, i know some of the figures are disingenuous (like I myself am 3 members) but so many club records and we're floundering.
-
Rumours
What are his main flaws? in his last 3 seasons he's averaging 36 goals a season and he's not the main man.
-
Marcus Windhager
I love football (soccer) transfer news, cos its full of agent fake leaks to try get other teams to do something. Suspect we may well be a pawn here - BUT also interesting juggling act at Saints with some of these deals.
-
Delistings 2025
Sestan was an interesting pick up, we kept talking about another AFL Pre-Season for him around this time each year, maybe you're right?
-
Rumours
One of those changes surrounds a 22-year-old key forward who struggled to find his feet in 2025 after promising 2023 and 2024 campaigns. “I think they could get aggressive with Jye Amiss,” King told SEN Fireball. “If they’re looking to put one up, I think he’s superfluous to needs. If they could trade that player for another line-breaking mid, that’d be a sound investment I would say.”
-
Rule changes proposed for 2026
i'm definitely in the "wait and see" camp on this change
-
Pushing and Shoving
The group chat turned on me when I said i didn't mind the fact the second Rayner free kick was given. Yes he went down softly, but as others have said hate the fake macho tough guy thing that is in our game. Also if you're an AFL player and your teammate has just given away a silly soft/free kick leading to a goal, maybe don't come in from distance and unnecessarily bump into a opposition player in front of the umpire who gave away the initial free kick.
-
Hypocritical Collingwood supporters calling out booing of Quaynor
Adelaide’s statement re the booing last night: “We want members and footy fans to be barracking and passionate however, they should do so respectfully and any behaviour contrary to that is disappointing and not appropriate.” Very weak statement.
-
Hypocritical Collingwood supporters calling out booing of Quaynor
The booing last night was disappointing. Football tribalism at its worst, and it brought to mind the time Liverpool fans booed Patrice Evra after he reported being racially abused by one of their players.
-
Luke Jackson back to Victoria?
Yeh we do not have the collateral as far as i see it (at present)
-
AFLW and Casey Fields - what's the plan?
I do feel a little bad about it, as i try to live by the one club mentality (support all teams) as much as i can
-
AFLW and Casey Fields - what's the plan?
Yeh honestly I would not travel to Casey to watch the team. Would go to Punt, Vic Park or Ikon though.
-
AFLW and Casey Fields - what's the plan?
Once Punt Road is redeveloped, is that an avenue we could explore? I know Richmond would probably be reluctant but at present its not that many games we'd be playing there.
-
Rumours
If lever is on the way out, can someone tell me the closest dump to his house, wouldn’t mind some free merch
-
Farewell Charlie Spargo
I like Spargo but know he needs to improve aspects of his game, Imagine the compensation won't be too flash, and we're in a diluted draft anyway. At least he's ticked off the 100 Game father/son option. Matter is complicated by the lack of coach at the moment.
-
2025 MRO & Tribunal
Was sad when we lost BBB as i admired his moral compass, but glad we have another good egg with TC
-
Who Will Be Our Next Coach?
But it would be box office seeing Tom Morris v Bevo as a Melb coach if we keep having leaks