In Harmes Way

They’re clearly not reasonable people

Maybe they’re reading DL getting the various feedback on the possible outcomes they might hit us with

It’s the vibe of the thing

Given the chook lotto of the tribunal, any outcome from 6 weeks to a fine is a possibility

And we were 10-0 last year before the wheels semi-spectacularly fell off and we bowed out meekly from the finals despite being in the top 4. I don't have a problem with posters looking at those areas of our game and team structure that need to improve, because we're not going to win a flag playing like we are at the moment. That said, I'm delighted we are giving some new faces a good run as well as playing our personnel in different positions and seeing some reward, some learning opportunities and some "didn't quite work" instances. But we very soon need to take those learnings and refine the team/game plan so that the core 14-16 of the 22 can better rely on each other from the consistency of playing in the same roles week in, week out.

After last year’s practice of playing the same 22 regardless of injury status, and then bowing out of finals in straight sets, I’m really pleased to see Goody playing with variations on team setup and players from Casey getting a go. Petty looked really good playing forward in that final last yr vs Brisbane. We’ve had a good look at him as a forward now and I think we’ve learned he’s better in defence, but it didn’t cost us games to find this out.

Who else but demonstone

Mayne Nickless

No drama with this, on the basis that Collingwood pick up the slack and take on GWS’s visits to QLD, SA and WA that they’d no longer do.

I’m more inclined to agree with Clarko’s assessment that we have 8-10 All Australians at the moment

Tom Scully retiring must have given the No T$ thread a happy ending? That thread started when we were still carving in stone.

Brisbane in round 2. See how that worked out for us?

It was pretty much this video https://fb.watch/keZKxbUKxO/

Goodwin confirmed in the post match presser that Petty would be in on the basis he passes concussion protocols. Petty effectively had a rest not playing in the North game. Goodwin also confirmed Spargs was available for selection, so don't be surprised if he gets the nod as well. Hasn't been dropped since I don't know when.

Seriously, Tim Lamb should get an OBE for his services to MFC list management.

RIP

Absolutely soft free kick to Collingwood in front of goal for their first, halfway through the 2nd qtr

Are you sitting in the next bay to their cheer squad of 10?

I’m with Ivan

11 scoring shots to 6 at half time to be behind by 5 points is a disgrace

IIRC, wasn’t Jackson out of contract vs JHF having another year to run on his? We got trade capital on Jackson because Freo didn’t want to lose him to the draft and WCE.

I’m not sure how the contract duration fixes the current issue of players under contract “demanding” a trade and clubs effectively trying to get trade capital while they can.

And I agree that the team managed their health and the result of the game beautifully off a 5 day break, but it’s also fair for the posters lamenting we didn’t get a 100 point win when the replay commentary highlighted we have only had 2 100+ wins in the last 29 years, and we were in the position to make it three.

I’m loving how JVR is playing up the ground a bit, as a link player for offensive transition. I can’t see a forward line with both JVR and T Mac in it as I think they’re too similar. I’d like to see more of BBB, JVR and Fritta as I think this is the best blend of differing offensive skills.