In Harmes Way
Life Member
-
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Currently
Viewing Topic: NON-MFC: Finals Week 01
Everything posted by In Harmes Way
- GAMEDAY: Rd 05 vs Brisbane
-
TRAINING: Wednesday 10th April 2024
Cranky suits you mate!!
-
Judd and Johno 9
Alan Johnson. Good times*. Just a ripper player with the ball. Loving the comparisons. *(except 87 prelim and 88 granny)
-
Kolt to debut vs Brisbane
As long as it’s a football action and not head high, all good
-
PREGAME: Rd 05 vs Brisbane
Injury report update from Selwyn Griffiths. Lachie Hunter played match sim v Carlton 2's last week with no issues. Marty Hore looking to be back for Richmond game. I presume Smacca the same given the same expected return timing listed and previous advice from trackwatchers at training. Clarry not listed. Presume he plays.
-
PREGAME: Rd 05 vs Brisbane
This is the latest free kick count after Round 4 below. Interesting to see if the umpires this week (a) reward Melbourne given it's a home game, with the noise of affirmation from our noisy supporters or (b) try to square up the ledger with Brisbane being rock bottom. We obviously took a hiding from last week's free kick differential count (-12).
- Kozzy bump on Soligo
-
Parenting
It's up there with "go number 4" Except he smashes it with his "Jakeyyy Leverrr"
-
Um
SMH. Keep up the great work guys. Love the podcast. um’s included.
-
What they are saying up in Vulture Street
I was hoping they’d give us some to img about last year’s come from behind win. I’m sure they’d be as gutted as I was delighted 😁
-
Kozzy bump on Soligo
I agree dc. The AFL don’t want to include an escalation category for potential on “ugly” looking incidents, as they’d have to explain their thinking and it’s easier to hide behind a classification of medium impact. Medium, despite the fact the Adelaide player showed no ill effects. Let’s sort this out once and for all. Trying to retrofit potential into a results based classification system is a joke.
- PREGAME: Rd 05 vs Brisbane
-
TRAINING: Sunday 7th April, 2024
Thanks for the heads up kev
-
Special Edition: What They are saying at 'The Edge'!
Good luck with the new house hambo- any luck you’ll get it and not have to fix the wall
-
Kozzy bump on Soligo
Don’t disagree PSD, however the medium impact finding is based on the potential to inflict a higher level of injury than that actually sustained. For last years Bailey Smith bump, and Maynards hit on Brayshaw, these were more likely occurrences to inflict higher levels of damage due to the two trajectories of the two players involved. I don’t think this example could have incurred a higher level of injury to the Adelaide player. But yes, I’m arguing a nuance when we want to eradicate the action, so he’ll go.
- POSTGAME: Rd 04 vs Adelaide
- POSTGAME: Rd 04 vs Adelaide
-
PREGAME: Rd 05 vs Brisbane
I think BBB keeps his spot, and I can see Harris Andrews, Payne and Gardiner going to JVR, BBB and Petty. Hopefully Fritta, Chin and (Woey 2.0/Kossie) > Wilmot, Starcevich and Lester. They play quite tall as a back 6, having good crumbers is key. Hope Kossie isn't rubbed out. Backline I think Maysie and TMac to Hipwood/Daniher with Rick intercepting. Four mediums/smalls with Rayner, McCluggage, Cameron and Zorko -> Judd, Howes, Rivers and Salo/Nibbler/wingers chipping in. For me, just the forced change on Kossie if he's rubbed out. I'd bring in Woey 2.0 and have Laurie as sub.
- Kozzy bump on Soligo
-
POSTGAME: Rd 04 vs Adelaide
Loved: The improvement of our second tier/new draftee players. Chin played a blinder last night. Love Juddy McVee; Blake Howes and Caleb Windsor have only played how many games? Trac seems to always get a kick away with 2-3 opponents hanging off him. So strong, always holds his feet. Spaz's smother in the forward line Roo's one handed contested mark holding off his opponent. Bloke turns 21 the week after next. Ridiculous. Fritta and Roo's kicking for goal. Put the glasses down, they just don't miss. TMac reborn in the backline, and fit and firing. Maysie's/Ricky's interface marking. I've got to stop yelling "punch it" at the telly. Clarry's turnover and hit up kick to Fritta in the 2nd. Liked: Trac's goal after Spaz's smother Hated The umpiring. The booing. What a bunch of morons.
- Kozzy bump on Soligo
-
My 3 word player analysis V Adelaide, the dumb crowd and the dumber umpires
Best summary yet joeboy, nice work. Completely agree.
- GAMEDAY: Rd 04 vs Adelaide
-
Appalling Umpire Error
Umpire appreciation round.
-
Eagles Draft Assistance?
This was the AFL's conclusion summarising why Melbourne didn't get a priority pick in 2014 (4 win season after 2 wins in 2013): "The AFL concluded that while Melbourne has a poor on field record in recent times, this does not of itself constitute “exceptional circumstances” or a justification for awarding priority draft selections." Given the WCE are the richest club in the country, and are led by a flag winning coach, they'll struggle to demonstrate "exceptional circumstances" beyond poor performances onfield. This is assuming the AFL follow it's own precedences, which I know is laughable.