TeamPlayedFine39

Surely they’d sack everyone from the president to the boot-studder before losing Bont..?

Not matching the pick 5 bid on Mac Andrew allowed us to bring in JVR and Blake Howes; a solid win so far. K White is 100% nominating the Dees.

I’ve always preferred Petty as a defender where, I believe, he had a very high ceiling. It’s also why Adelaide wanted him. At the moment, he’s not completely fit and, for the first time in his career, he’s very out of form. Whether it’s lacking touch or just isn’t quite trusting his body yet, this will soon pass. At the moment, with TMac playing out of his skin, he’s not needed down back. But my hopes were and still are that Petty and Disco are ready made replacements when McDonald and (heaven forbid) May call it a day. May’s retirement is more daunting to our list management than Gawn’s imho.

Some people jumped the gun with their criticism of the kid. I thought for a debut against a-grade opposition on a night where very few teammates turned up, he showed plenty. Got some kicks, a shot on goal, laid some tackles and showed some endeavour. Have seen far worse debuts from players who went on to have great careers. He is a victim of his own marketability in that more eyes were on him since draft night than most other draftees at his level. Bank the experience and move on!

Listed at 190cm and turns 18 tomorrow. I wonder if he’s gone one more growth spurt in him… 4 or 5 more cm would be perfect.

High pressure environment to make a debut! Hopefully he thrives on the atmosphere and makes the most of it! Very keen to see what he can do.

Genuinely shocked we even bothered; was never any chance of getting off. We can argue until we're blue in the face, but the very simple checklist of feet leaving the ground, contact to the head and it being 'avoidable' meant that he was always going to get at leat a week. I was just relieved that it was only the week after being rubbed out twice last year. Times have changed.

Time to rename . . . the thread…

Really?! I didn’t r realise that. That is much more informative and interesting than the OP!

Bontempelli is the best player in the league by a long, long way. Favourite non-demon to watch.

I would have thought he’s playing better this season than the second half of ‘22 through to the end of 23.

A week was expected. Could be considered lucky to just be the one given his record. Needs to get this part of his game right; he’s too valuable to be missing games.

You gotta wonder how a player of such undeniable talent can come so close to missing out on being drafted! Would love to know what the issues were with his game because he is playing with skill, poise and an IQ that puts him amongst the best young players in the league.

Fair question! Slip of the finger - have amended now.

Fantastic team performance against a genuinely good opposition at a hostile home ground! In particular, I’m so happy for Benny Brown, Tom McDonald and Marty Hore. Three guys who have been completely written off, playing pivotal roles in the team. All three are thriving and supporting their younger teammates. Didn’t see them being capable of this level of football!

Agreed. Early in the season, selectors reward stats over impact. He, along with Howes will get one if they play most of the season. Both have been fantastic!

Legend has it, that spray was after his first game, Round 1 vs Port Adelaide. That debut is my go-to memory of Jack Viney. A kid standing tall when all around him were wilting under pressure. 22 disposals and a goal whilst on the receiving end of a flogging. Deserved the flag as much as anyone.

There’s definitely something there… Seems to be a confidence player and can get a little fun shy on the big stage. This may hopefully give him the belief that clearly the football department have in him. Yet to see it at senior level, but I trust the judgement of the people who signed off this, so go get ‘em Bill!!

Thought he played well, without dominating. Good to see him getting a bit more involved in contests whilst rucking. If he’s to continue to be used in the role, the next step in his development is to get more involved around the ground. Pick up some link up positions and provide more of an option for hit-ups around the ground. A few more possessions around the ground will make him a more damaging player and not just a quick chop-out. Even if they’re cheapies, it’s reward for his effort and good for the confidence.

May be top of the iceberg. Taylor called a beauty and wore a lot of criticism for it. Don't think we need to clap for Jackson this year.

He’s a freak; but, sadly, we knew that. When he starts to run with the ball a bit and kick more he’ll tear matches apart.

Wardlaw is going to be a real player. Great to watch some of these Nth kids.

I’ve been a big fan of Adelaide’s list build but they are looking a mile off at the moment. Maybe this is the one step back before the big jump next year; but from this two game sample, they have some big application issues.

Was buying some guest passes for the Hawthorn match this Saturday when I saw this donation link for their new facility. There must be a massive amount of casual money being donated to their club through this method, yet I have never been asked for a single dollar from the MFC to fund, or find our new home base (wherever and whenever that may be). When I see almost every club in the league forging ahead with their new training bases, some of which are now on their second training bases, I fear we are a long, long way off anything concrete. Why are we not rattling some tins and generating some buzz and excitement?

Went to a few games out there and graced the turf in a VicKick game or two. Attended the Lighting Premiership there in '96. Traffic, parking and relative isolation gave it an almost lonely feel. My major issue was the seating arrangement and the huge space between the boundary line and the fence, made you feel too far away from the action. This is something that Marvel does quite well, most likely in direct response.