SPC

It is unfortunately hard to argue against. We have ingrained habits, that for years, couldn’t be coached out. I’d be keen to see coach and coaching staff sacked. I’d be keen to see 2 of our highest paid mids and an overpaid backman traded. We still have some talent, but it will be lost to poor development and poor system

Not controversial. All facts.

Goodwin can go as can all the assistants

I’m over the same [censored] every week, every year. Cleaning out of coach and players. None have brain cells

Tracc is the worst kick in the comp. He is trade bait.

Show of strength. If May was a forward, it would be ok

We are [censored]

Koltyn is a strange one. I really like him, but leave every match he plays feeling underwhelmed. I think he is an excellent team mate and does play team first footy, but also makes simple mistakes and does go missing. He is my new Tom Sparrow. Really hope he makes it!

A good re-signing. I’m not sure he is a backman. Would like to see him off a wing or forward. Got huge scope.

Agree to all points.

Turner needs to be settled as a key back.. not to be played forward again.. I’d move Petty back and keep him there. He is a backman first, not forward. We should play May forward if needed. Need to build the backline and get this locked down.

Petty was outmuscled by Howe plenty of time yesterday which should never happen. He is a run and jump player, we really need a strong body who can contest hard and commands the best backman.

One thing that stands out since 2021 is we cannot win close games. We seem to panic and cannot close out games

Max was [censored] today.

AFL audit themselves. Revenue is king.. so today was a great result for all involved.

Surprised to see Melky not on the injury list. Shoulder looked stuffed

The role he plays requires agility. If he was a key back playing on Gorillas- he might be okay. But he has no chance on agile forwards, which the 3rd tall generally is.. I would say that Blake Howes is a better 3rd tall option. He panics, similar to Lever, but has a much better athletic profile. I would like to see Howes, Kentfield or Adam’s play after the bye, along with Sestan.

Hipwood is an absolute dud!

Laurie should be as close to like for like. Not overly quick, a good tackler and smart ball user. Average above head.

Wow, is that a thing? I might be naive, but didn’t realise that they called from studios (only in Covid times)

Only 1 game in Melbourne, but was never in doubt it would be Collingwood.

I’m doing my bit.. coming up from Ballarat for my 3rd games this year. Bringing the wife (who hates football) 2 kids (who hate football) and my wife’s best friend from Sydney who has never seen football… should be a good day. Best thing about birthdays is people have to say yes….

This is why it shouldn’t be outcome based. Koz got weeks for a bump on Moore who was subbed off with Concussion, but was fine 5 minutes after the game.

Turner on current form is better than Lever in that role. Will depend on how they play Turner and where. Lever is still valuable, but his ankles have crippled his footy.

Pretty funny man Bobby Hill