Tom VS Time

24 minutes ago, layzie said:

Tom VS Time

Tom is still winning this one.

Tom will play Game 240 v eagles this weekend.

He should reach 250 games by later this season. He was gone by end of 2023 but has been rejuvenated as a key defender role once again. His form in 2025 has been excellent.

37 minutes ago, La Dee-vina Comedia said:

Tom is still winning this one.

It's the fight of the century.

Father time is undefeated but here comes a worthy challenger!

TMac was 7th in the Bluey last year.

I reckon would be top ten currently, possibly top 7.

Tommy has had an absolute rollercoaster career with us.

From the depths of our slump in the early 2010's, to the false start in 2018, to a premiership player. From backman, to forward, to swingman, to forward to backman.

Honestly just a great servant of the club who at 32 is in as good of form as he has ever been. An absolute credit to his work ethic and ability to get and keep his body right.

Hope he makes it to 300, he certainly deserves it.

21 hours ago, M_9 said:

TMac was 7th in the Bluey last year.

I reckon would be top ten currently, possibly top 7.

i reckon way higher

he's been more consistent than gawn, and other than plugger the backline star has been bowey, while chandler and - gulp - sparrow have been the best of the forwards

i'd go current top 3 of:
1. bowey
2. plugger mac
3. chandler

4 minutes ago, Vandenberger With The Lot said:

Tommy has had an absolute rollercoaster career with us.

From the depths of our slump in the early 2010's, to the false start in 2018, to a premiership player. From backman, to forward, to swingman, to forward to backman.

Honestly just a great servant of the club who at 32 is in as good of form as he has ever been. An absolute credit to his work ethic and ability to get and keep his body right.

Hope he makes it to 300, he certainly deserves it.

His effort in the 2021 Premiership to shepherd Spaz's long bomb through for a goal continued our momentum and was invaluable. I was lucky to be there and see it live from a perfect angle - unforgettable.

Also, let's not forget his 5 goals vs WCE with the final one having several players trying to stop him. It was a crucial win.

Does any job asked of him and does it well. Few signs of him slowing him up just yet. Seems fastidious in his preparation. Pity Oscar didn't match his achievements!

1 hour ago, whatwhat say what said:

i reckon way higher

he's been more consistent than gawn, and other than plugger the backline star has been bowey, while chandler and - gulp - sparrow have been the best of the forwards

i'd go current top 3 of:
1. bowey
2. plugger mac
3. chandler

Pretty confident it'll be closer to:

1. Max (by a fair margin)

2. Clarry (strange I know)

3. Salem

4. TMac

5. Chandler

6. Bowey

Just now, M_9 said:

Pretty confident it'll be closer to:

1. Max (by a fair margin)

2. Clarry (strange I know)

3. Salem

4. TMac

5. Chandler

6. Bowey

i reckon max has had two standout games, and a couple of ones where his colours have been lowered

bowey and plugger mac have been very consistent, while chandler does all the little things that get votes from the coaches

Edited May 2May 2 by whatwhat say what

23 hours ago, M_9 said:

TMac was 7th in the Bluey last year.

I reckon would be top ten currently, possibly top 7.

Definitely top 5 this year, probably top 3. Bowey, TMac, Chandler have been brilliant from Round 1. Max has entered the conversation the last few weeks, but started the year slowly.

29 minutes ago, M_9 said:

Pretty confident it'll be closer to:

1. Max (by a fair margin)

2. Clarry (strange I know)

3. Salem

4. TMac

5. Chandler

6. Bowey

does ed not exist anymore?

On 30/04/2025 at 18:51, Cranky Franky said:

Where do you dream this stuff up ??? This is completely untrue.

TMac has generally been well liked by Demonlanders & one of the most popular players.

Short memory 🤨

37 minutes ago, Adam The God said:

... Max has entered the conversation the last few weeks, but started the year slowly.

Our best in rounds 1 and 5:

127 AF points (highest) v Giants: 24 disposals, 46 hitouts.

118, 22 and 49 v Bombres.

Poor rounds 2 and 3. OK round 4.

Also best last two weeks as you have said.

Bluey voting a bit difference - there can be large margins between 1st and 2nd in a game.

On 01/05/2025 at 12:43, Rodney (Balls) Grinter said:

That's my recollection also. T Mac was and still is to an extent an awsome athlete. One of the few that could keep up with Reiwolt athletically and often kept him from impacting in games against us. T Mac was viewed as one of the elite defenders in the competition at that time, with his kicking being perhaps his only real weakness. Around that time, when we were struggling as a team on the feild, he could have walked into so many other teams, but chose to stick fat with the MFC and I have alot of respect for him for that (and I think Max and Vines would also, amoung many other things). He probably still finishes top 10 in preseason endurance time trials.

In the years since, I only think he has added more strings to his bow as a footballer. While he might have lost a bit of agility, I think he has significantly increased his physical strength from his younger years and become an excellent contested mark an, even better reader of the play and enhanced leadership presance. Although he may lack the agility to play as a full time forward, I feel he could still impact down their by pinch hitting and giving us a marking option deep if we needed a circuit breaker as he did a few times late last year.

Persoally, I have soo much love for Tommy as a MFC footballer and he'll go down as one of my all time favourites.

Also worth remembering the amazing year he had last season as well came off the back of his personal family tragedy of loosing a baby - would take amazing inner strength and resilience.

Give him a contract as long as he wants to be at the club.

I thought he was cooked after 2023. The way he's been able to turn himself around at his age is actually remarkable considering where his body was at.

I have no intel at all but I expect a contract extension very soon.

On 01/05/2025 at 11:42, Young Angus said:

We are lucky to have Tmac, he's been great for us this year and last.

God send mate, he’s such a hard worker.

8 hours ago, TassieDevil said:

His effort in the 2021 Premiership to shepherd Spaz's long bomb through for a goal continued our momentum and was invaluable.

And of course he topped it off with the sealer after the final siren 🤗