The correct decision.

Campbell Brown is a complete [censored] and I actually wish Judd had poked him eyeballs clean out of the sockets but thats another issue.

It was utter stupidity that he was charged.

harsh on cambell brown!! he is as tough as nails... wish he was at the dees

good that judd got off.... DREAM TEAM!!

good to see judd got off....

lucky IMO

Agree that you are a bit harsh on Campbell Brown given that he backed up Juddy during the hearing. All those years playing juinor footy together must have paid off now!

Judd being cleared is a F$#%ing disgrace. AFL has just lost me completely. How much more do they want to give the eagles. he eye gouged and you know when your fingers are in an eye socket, it should have been penalised, was cited, found guilty and now he plays.

I give up on the sh1te competition ever since te Barry Hall reversal beforethe 2005 grand final. its manipulated and thats that.

harsh on cambell brown!! he is as tough as nails... wish he was at the dees

good that judd got off.... DREAM TEAM!!

QFT! Herald Sun team. Average like 300+ points per game as captain.

yeah as much as i like judd i think he should of gone. i dont think he deliberately eye gouged the player. but there is no doubt his actions were reckless at best, and considering that ben holland got a reprimand after first being head butted shows that the tribunal is a joke.

he would of hynotised the tribunal with his premiership n brownlow medal to get cleared ,

Lucky to get off IMO, his squeeky clean record did the job nicely. I think all dream teamers a taking a collective sigh off relief tonight.

Hutchy, Carro, Stevens and Sheahan are gonna be rather pressed for articles this week...

Boo what about what happened to Holland!

is he still eligable for the brownlow

yup

Judd is God

Even if he did tear out Browns eyeball, I would still want him cleared

what do chris judd and john hopoate have in common

both have stuck their finger in a brown eye

:D:D

make you question whether any unbiased Juddstice exists ? One very lucky boy !!

Judd is above the law, there is no doubt about it. He is protected by the umpires, the media, and the entire AFL community. That is the benefit of being the best player in the AFL.

But lets face it, he is hardly a dirty snipper, and to sit through a Brownlow night where, in all likelihood, the top 2 vote-getters are ineligible to win the medal will be farcical.

Judd is above the law, there is no doubt about it. He is protected by the umpires, the media, and the entire AFL community. That is the benefit of being the best player in the AFL.

But lets face it, he is hardly a dirty snipper, and to sit through a Brownlow night where, in all likelihood, the top 2 vote-getters are ineligible to win the medal will be farcical.

Let's be honest, the last scenario would have ruined the AFL's biggest night. A lot of people wouldn't have bothered to turn on their telly. Think of all that ad revenue down the gurgler. It would have taken a lot of interest out of the betting too (although the agencies would have been happy). Rather than "beyond reasonable doubt" it's "benefit of the doubt" and ad hoc. The Tribunal have absolutely no credibilty; they're a bunch of Muppets really.

Let's be honest, the last scenario would have ruined the AFL's biggest night. A lot of people wouldn't have bothered to turn on their telly. Think of all that ad revenue down the gurgler. It would have taken a lot of interest out of the betting too (although the agencies would have been happy). Rather than "beyond reasonable doubt" it's "benefit of the doubt" and ad hoc. The Tribunal have absolutely no credibilty; they're a bunch of Muppets really.

What an absolute joke. Anyone who thinks Judd should have got off is a joke.

I love Judd but like Holland, both should be spending 6 weeks off.

Eye Gouging is just as bad as head on tackles and deserves 6-8 weeks.

Tribunal. You are a joke.

How is it common sense Sleeve? Just wondering. To me it seemed to be a pretty blatantly obvious eye gouge. I can't see how the tribunal got this one right.

Rub him out