Demonland 74,454 Posted August 1, 2024 Posted August 1, 2024 MELBOURNE Kysaiah Pickett (gen forward), Christian Petracca (midfielder), Alex Neal-Bullen (mid-forward), Max Gawn (ruck) A very good soldier, Neal-Bullen is a surprise on this list. But that speaks to the lack of depth in that position. The players who didn’t quite make the cut as mid-forwards were Jy Simpkin, Pat Lipinski and Ollie Dempsey. Neal-Bullen does his job each week but averages just 18.7 disposals and 0.4 goals per game. Petracca hit the games threshold to make it here before his injury, while Gawn is clear as the top ruck according to player ratings. ADELAIDE Mitch Hinge (general defender), Izak Rankine (gen forward) BRISBANE LIONS Dayne Zorko (gen defender), Cam Rayner (gen forward) CARLTON Charlie Curnow (key forward), Harry McKay (key forward), Patrick Cripps (midfielder) COLLINGWOOD Nick Daicos (midfielder) ESSENDON Nil FREMANTLE Caleb Serong (midfielder) GEELONG Max Holmes (gen defender), Gryan Miers (gen forward), Tyson Stengle (gen forward), Jeremy Cameron (key forward) GOLD COAST Sam Flanders (gen defender), Sam Collins (key defender), Matt Rowell (midfielder) GWS GIANTS Brent Daniels (gen forward), Toby Greene (gen forward), Jesse Hogan (key forward), Callan Ward (wing) HAWTHORN Dylan Moore (gen forward), James Sicily (key defender), Massimo D’Ambrosio (wing) MELBOURNE Kysaiah Pickett (gen forward), Christian Petracca (midfielder), Alex Neal-Bullen (mid-forward), Max Gawn (ruck) NORTH MELBOURNE Harry Sheezel (gen defender), Tristan Xerri (ruck) PORT ADELAIDE Dan Houston (gen defender), Zak Butters (midfielder) RICHMOND Liam Baker (mid-forward), Shai Bolton (mid-forward) ST KILDA Jack Sinclair (gen defender), Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera (gen defender) SYDNEY Nick Blakey (gen defender), Tom Papley (gen forward), Isaac Heeney (midfielder), Errol Gulden (wing), Justin McInerney (wing) WEST COAST Tom Barrass (key defender), Jeremy McGovern (key defender), Jake Waterman (key forward) WESTERN BULLDOGS Bailey Dale (gen defender), Aaron Naughton (key forward), Marcus Bontempelli (midfielder), Adam Treloar (midfielder) 1 1 Quote
DubDee 26,682 Posted August 1, 2024 Posted August 1, 2024 Bombers lol Surprised Lever or may didn’t make the key def 1 Quote
ChaserJ 5,192 Posted August 1, 2024 Posted August 1, 2024 Key defenders seem under represented! Houston’s ratings (particularly kick related) have been lights out for 18 months, so no surprise to see him there for Port. Quote
Engorged Onion 10,226 Posted August 1, 2024 Posted August 1, 2024 Whilst we do bag Champion Data, when it doesn't suit our narrative, I am very very pleased for ANB. If you looked in the dictionary for quiet achiever...etc etc. 4 Quote
Gawndy the Great 9,011 Posted August 1, 2024 Posted August 1, 2024 3 hours ago, DubDee said: Bombers lol Surprised Lever or may didn’t make the key def I’m not. Both have been below their best by a fair way. Quote
Jaded No More 68,976 Posted August 1, 2024 Posted August 1, 2024 43 minutes ago, Engorged Onion said: Whilst we do bag Champion Data, when it doesn't suit our narrative, I am very very pleased for ANB. If you looked in the dictionary for quiet achiever...etc etc. His haters on Demonland have gone very quiet. Quote
binman 44,848 Posted August 1, 2024 Posted August 1, 2024 2 minutes ago, Jaded No More said: His haters on Demonland have gone very quiet. And his long term fans are nodding their heads sagely and saying I told you so. 2 1 Quote
Dr. Mubutu 867 Posted August 1, 2024 Posted August 1, 2024 1 hour ago, ChaserJ said: Key defenders seem under represented! Houston’s ratings (particularly kick related) have been lights out for 18 months, so no surprise to see him there for Port. Barrass and Govern for WC, which makes sense 1 Quote
BillyBeane 254 Posted August 1, 2024 Posted August 1, 2024 Good for Nibbler, a real club stalwart. Any chance he could win the B&F? Quote
Demon17 5,262 Posted August 1, 2024 Posted August 1, 2024 No Brodie Grundy either. So much for the hye this year Quote
ANG13 2,110 Posted August 1, 2024 Posted August 1, 2024 Judd McVee surely couldn’t have been far off the list. I was a critic of ANB and at the end of 2020 would have been happy to see him move on. But now I love the guy, his work rate and commitment to the team is outstanding. We lack a bit of what he brings to the team and he is now one of our more important players. Very happy to see him get any recognition that comes his way. 2 Quote
rjay 25,424 Posted August 1, 2024 Posted August 1, 2024 47 minutes ago, BillyBeane said: Good for Nibbler, a real club stalwart. Any chance he could win the B&F? He will be up there I would think...not sure if he could win it but he's been consistent. Quote
seventyfour 1,248 Posted August 1, 2024 Posted August 1, 2024 How does ANB make the list and not Merrett? Richmond have 2 on the list and both look like they'll head back to WA next season... tough times coming for them. Quote
WheeloRatings 1,190 Posted August 1, 2024 Posted August 1, 2024 1 hour ago, seventyfour said: How does ANB make the list and not Merrett? Merrett is rated significantly higher than ANB, but Merrett is classified as a midfielder and ANB a mid-forward. Merrett is the 15th highest rated player in the competition but most players above him are too. It's based on the Player Ratings which you can access here: https://www.wheeloratings.com/afl_stats.html?year=2024 The player classifications may differ slightly and wings aren't differentiated from other midfielders on my site. 2 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.