NON-MFC: Round 15

[BDA 23,016]

the insufficient intent rule is so stupid. 

[BoBo 2,953]

12 minutes ago, BDA said:

the insufficient intent rule is so stupid. 

In the 2nd quarter, Chad Warner kicked it inside the swans F50 blindly around the corner after just picking up the ball and it went out in the pocket, without a Sydney player being within 15 meters of it and it was called as thrown in.

If a defender was doing that, but kicking it out of D50, again blind around the corner type kick, it would be insufficient intent 100/100 times.

 

[BDA 23,016]

2 minutes ago, BoBo said:

In the 2nd quarter, Chad Warner kicked it inside the swans F50 blindly around the corner after just picking up the ball and it went out in the pocket, without a Sydney player being within 15 meters of it and it was called as thrown in.

If a defender was doing that, but kicking it out of D50, again blind around the corner type kick, it would be insufficient intent 100/100 times.

 

The one called earlier was obviously a skill error

[Gawndy the Great 9,011]

1 hour ago, Boots and all said:

...surely the Blues are a shot too.

Nope. Defensively not good enough yet. Big tick on offence though but a team that can nullify their stoppage dominance will beat them easily. 

[sue 9,172]

I have made the mistake of watching far too much footy this round.

What has stood out for me is how inconsistent the umpiring has become.  And this is watching matches where I'm not particularly hoping one team or the other wins, so the usual supporter biases are not there.

Of course it is a difficult job, but what really gets me mad is the AFL introducing new 'rules/interpretations' which last a week or two and the inconsitentcies.  Think dissent, vagueness of the stand/5m 'rule', entering protected zones and play on, HTB, the inability of umps to judge distances, penalising to discourage ducking to protect heads (promised but never implemented), etc.  The lack of consistency makes it far too easy to credit consipracy theories which is not in the interest of our game.

A thorough review of the rules and umpiring environment is needed by a body independent of the AFL admin (which is focussed on $), and not on our game.   Won't happen of course.

[Bombay Airconditioning 6,477]

I think the Eagles are a chance today.

[BDA 23,016]

hopefully Eagles can keep this up

[The heart beats true 18,183]

Waterman has become such a strong player. He really straightens them up.

[BoBo 2,953]

2 hours ago, sue said:

I have made the mistake of watching far too much footy this round.

What has stood out for me is how inconsistent the umpiring has become.  And this is watching matches where I'm not particularly hoping one team or the other wins, so the usual supporter biases are not there.

Of course it is a difficult job, but what really gets me mad is the AFL introducing new 'rules/interpretations' which last a week or two and the inconsitentcies.  Think dissent, vagueness of the stand/5m 'rule', entering protected zones and play on, HTB, the inability of umps to judge distances, penalising to discourage ducking to protect heads (promised but never implemented), etc.  The lack of consistency makes it far too easy to credit consipracy theories which is not in the interest of our game.

A thorough review of the rules and umpiring environment is needed by a body independent of the AFL admin (which is focussed on $), and not on our game.   Won't happen of course.

I’m watching less and less neutral games to be honest. It’s absurd how inconsistent the umpiring has been allowed to get and it’s frustrating to watch. 

[praha 11,253]

If West Coast wins we'll be half a game off top 4.

Bizarre season.

[BDA 23,016]

This is a really good game between bombers and eagles

[BDA 23,016]

Allen and Darling missing gettable set shots just before 3 quarter time. bombers more accurate and that's the difference. Eagles not out it but they got to convert their chances in the last.

[Little Goffy 14,750]

Just dropped in on the Essendon West Coast game for a moment. Watched for 30 seconds - two throws, one marginal and one extremely obvious - from a centre clearance to seal the game with 5.45 to go in the last.

Ah well. Back to not watching AFL.

[Guest]

Ugh knew it was too good to be true. Still waiting for Essendon’s inevitable nosedive down the ladder. But I’m patient. It will be worth the wait. 

[dees189227 12,453]

Knew essendon would win so didn't bother watching.

Just watching freo gold coast. Watching amiss miss another shot. Of course that day he couldn't miss against us, could he. 

[praha 11,253]

gold coast needs to start winning away from home if they're gonna play finals.

[SFebes 4,884]

Treacy from Freo looks a likely type as a KPF.

[Demonland 73,465]

Guess when we play Freo.