Christian Petracca a chance to win the 2023 Brownlow Medal?

[YearOfTheDees 3,266]

9 minutes ago, DubDee said:

No other Lions player in the top 25. i wonder who was next. crazy bias. 

he won’t even win the Lions BnF. Cameron had the more impactful year for me

Name	Votes
Lachie Neale	31
Joe Daniher	12
Will Ashcroft	10
Harris Andrews	8
Charlie Cameron	8
Zac Bailey	5
Josh Dunkley	4
Hugh McCluggage	3
Jack Gunston	3
Keidean Coleman	3
Cam Rayner	2
Daniel Rich	1
Eric Hipwood	1
Jarrod Berry	1

[brendan 3,439]

How did Neale get 3 votes in round 6 with 20 possessions while Cameron kicks 7.2 and gets 2 votes, Josh Kelly had 41 touches and coniglio 38, a certain ump must have had cash on Neale a fair way out how else do you explain that 

[Fork 'em 7,010]

15 minutes ago, Demon Disciple said:

Especially when it comes to goal kicking and delivery into the forward line

Clean quick hands through traffic and fast ball movement.
I've been impressed.
Skills and confidence have jumped with last years flag.
Stay fit and they'll romp in another one I reckon.

Should swap their coaching dept with the mens.
Love the way they play.

[YearOfTheDees 3,266]

Oliver only 6 from his ten games he was Fav before he was injured,

Melbourne Brownlow Medal club votes

Name	Votes
Christian Petracca	26
Jack Viney	24
Max Gawn	7
Clayton Oliver	6
Bailey Fritsch	4
Angus Brayshaw	4
Steven May	3
Lachie Hunter	3
Kysaiah Pickett	2
Jacob van Rooyen	2
Kade Chandler	2
Harrison Petty	2
Jake Melksham	2
Ben Brown	1
Christian Salem	1

[napster 191]

Would have been Nicky D but for his dicky knee.

[Rodney (Balls) Grinter 10,936]

23 minutes ago, Lord Travis said:

Seems Trac and Bont are destined to never win one despite being the best players every year and influencing games more than their peers. Both got robbed of clear votes tonight. 

Trac getting no votes in the final game was stupid. Getting 1 vote for his game against the Saints was stupid.

The umpires are stupid. I’m [censored] sick of them. The umpires have determined the outcome of games this year and illegitimately shaped the entire finals series. It’s beyond pathetic and as someone who’s attending 100s of live games since the 1980s, I’m thiiiiiiis close to giving up on the sport because of their [censored] incompetence and the rules being so vague etc. Stuff this

I had to check that Bont actually hadn't won a Brownlow, because I'd sworn he had.

You can add Max and Clarry to that list that should have won one.

[Stiff Arm 4,419]

26 minutes ago, rpfc said:

Viney with 24 votes. Should have been AA.

And Neale didn't make the AA!

[Rodney (Balls) Grinter 10,936]

1 minute ago, YearOfTheDees said:

Oliver only 6 from his ten games he was Fav before he was injured,

Melbourne Brownlow Medal club votes

Name	Votes
Christian Petracca	26
Jack Viney	24
Max Gawn	7
Clayton Oliver	6
Bailey Fritsch	4
Angus Brayshaw	4
Steven May	3
Lachie Hunter	3
Kysaiah Pickett	2
Jacob van Rooyen	2
Kade Chandler	2
Harrison Petty	2
Jake Melksham	2
Ben Brown	1
Christian Salem	1

Umpires hate him, what can you say.

[Stiff Arm 4,419]

Wouldn't it just be better if the umpires only have one task to do? They do a [censored] house job of umpiring, what makes anyone think they deserve to decide the brownlow?

Edited September 25, 2023 by Stiff Arm

[YearOfTheDees 3,266]

uess coaches don't know what their doing.

 

 

[Fork 'em 7,010]

And FWIW.
Reckon the girls should have a spot on the main board instead of getting shuffled off to the back board.

[Rodney (Balls) Grinter 10,936]

3 minutes ago, YearOfTheDees said:

Oliver only 6 from his ten games he was Fav before he was injured,

Melbourne Brownlow Medal club votes

Name	Votes
Christian Petracca	26
Jack Viney	24
Max Gawn	7
Clayton Oliver	6
Bailey Fritsch	4
Angus Brayshaw	4
Steven May	3
Lachie Hunter	3
Kysaiah Pickett	2
Jacob van Rooyen	2
Kade Chandler	2
Harrison Petty	2
Jake Melksham	2
Ben Brown	1
Christian Salem	1

So the other anomalies here:

We have the best backline in the league and they only get 4 votes between them (8 at the very generous end if any of Gus's backline work counts).  Out of a total of around 90 votes.

Jake Lever gets 0 votes?

Jake Bowey 0 votes?

 

Seriously please take the voting off the umps.

[david_neitz_is_my_dad 4,084]

That could have been Petraccas only real shot to win, Oliver missing, Daicos missed several games, Gulden and Butters will be a force next year.

[YearOfTheDees 3,266]

2 minutes ago, Rodney (Balls) Grinter said:

So the other anomalies here:

We have the best backline in the league and they only get 4 votes between them (8 at the very generous end if any of Gus's backline work counts).  Out of a total of around 90 votes.

Jake Lever gets 0 votes?

Jake Bowey 0 votes?

 

Seriously please take the voting off the umps.

You can understand one Ump getting it wrong but we have four talking together about the game.

[Lexinator 1,752]

Rivers real stiff not to get any votes.

[Rodney (Balls) Grinter 10,936]

3 minutes ago, david_neitz_is_my_dad said:

That could have been Petraccas only real shot to win, Oliver missing, Daicos missed several games, Gulden and Butters will be a force next year.

The player that hid his Norm Smith looked embarrassed and didn't want to be there tonight.

I think he and everyone here would be much happier with another premiership medal around his neck.  Locky and Daicos can have all the Brownlows they want.

Edited September 25, 2023 by Rodney (Balls) Grinter

[Guest]

35 minutes ago, Timothy Reddan-A'Blew said:

And - the new normal - THE WOMEN!

 

29 minutes ago, Fork 'em said:

And for any-one who doesn't know.
The girls are flying and playing some ripping footy.
The men should watch them.

 

Off-topic I know, but honestly it would be so awesome and so appreciated if more Dees fans could come onboard for the girls. Even if you’ve never paid much attention to the W comp you should consider it. Now’s the best time, too. This team is an absolute joy to watch. They’re in scintillating form and the vibe at matches is always good. There’s six H&A rounds remaining, even if you just attend only one, that’d be great. And for those who don’t have W membership, a ticket is only $10.

[YearOfTheDees 3,266]

2 minutes ago, WalkingCivilWar said:

 

Off-topic I know, but honestly it would be so awesome and so appreciated if more Dees fans could come onboard for the girls. Even if you’ve never paid much attention to the W comp you should consider it. Now’s the best time, too. This team is an absolute joy to watch. They’re in scintillating form and the vibe at matches is always good. There’s six H&A rounds remaining, even if you just attend only one, that’d be great. And for those who don’t have W membership, a ticket is only $10.

Watch every week. The standard has improved out of sight this season.

[Fork 'em 7,010]

3 minutes ago, YearOfTheDees said:

Watch every week. The standard has improved out of sight this season.

It has.
Like 2 levels.

[Fanatique Demon 2,660]

We’re a biased lot, aren’t we? 😀

We criticise the votes on the one hand, saying umpires don’t know what they’re doing. Then we use the votes as evidence that Viney should have been AA and that he’s better than Parish. (Of course he is, but our arguments would fail year 11 critical thinking - if there’s still such a thing.)

[Fork 'em 7,010]

I'm off again.
Bruce is about to fight.

[Guest]

1 minute ago, YearOfTheDees said:

Watch every week. The standard has improved out of sight this season.

Right???? Since its inception in 2017 the standard has improved with each and every season. But from last season to this current season the improvement is off the charts.

It’s great that people watch our matches on TV. Attending them (if possible) would be AMAZING! The girls truly appreciate the support. 

[Harvey Wallbanger 1,081]

15 minutes ago, WalkingCivilWar said:

 

Off-topic I know, but honestly it would be so awesome and so appreciated if more Dees fans could come onboard for the girls. Even if you’ve never paid much attention to the W comp you should consider it. Now’s the best time, too. This team is an absolute joy to watch. They’re in scintillating form and the vibe at matches is always good. There’s six H&A rounds remaining, even if you just attend only one, that’d be great. And for those who don’t have W membership, a ticket is only $10.

See you there WCW!

[bing181 9,349]

Already pointed out I know, but some real discrepancies in the voting. e.g., Sheezel won North's B&F, but only 3 x 1 Brownlow votes.

[Guest]

Just now, Hawk the Demon said:

See you there WCW!

Awesome! Every person who attends a W match is worth 50 people attending a men’s match. I think. Maths is not my forte, but you get my point. 😊