PLAYER RANKINGS

[WERRIDEE 5,643]

I've rated the players 1 to 45

1 - PETRACCA

2 - GAWN

3 - OLIVER

4 - VINEY

5 - MAY

6 - LANGDON

7 - FRITSCH

8 - HARMES

9 - SALEM

10 - BRAYSHAW

11 - T.MCDONALD

12 - BENNELL

13 - HIBBERD

14 - LEVER

15 - PICKETT

16 - WEIDEMAN

17 - HANNAN

18 - VANDENBERG

19 - O.MCDONALD

20 - MELKSHAM

21 - JETTA

22 - JACKSON

23 - LOCKHART

24 - TOMLINSON

25 - JONES

26 - NEAL-BULLEN

27 - SMITH

28 - RIVERS

29 - HUNT

30 - BROWN

31 - BEDFORD

32 - SPARGO

33 - C.WAGNER

34 - JORDON

35 - SPARROW

36 - J.WAGNER

37 - BAKER

38 - CHANDLER

39 - DUNKLEY

40 - PREUSS

41 - BRADTKE

42 - HORE

43 - PETTY

44 - KOLODJASHNIJ

45 - NEITSCHKE

[spirit of norm smith 16,681]

This must be based on “currently available to play” ratings.
 

Hore, Petty and Preuss would be all around 31-33 mark in normal business. Hore especially was very good last year.  I’d certainly rate all above Bedford, Spargo and Cwagner.  

[Lord Travis 10,819]

Is this ranked as current output or potential output?

[Lord Nev 13,512]

11 hours ago, WERRIDEE said:

34 - JORDON

35 - SPARROW

36 - J.WAGNER

37 - BAKER

38 - CHANDLER

39 - DUNKLEY

40 - PREUSS

 

42 - HORE

43 - PETTY

44 - KOLODJASHNIJ

 

On what basis exactly is a player who is yet to debut ranked above 9 others who have?

 

[dazzledavey36 56,399]

10 minutes ago, Lord Nev said:

On what basis exactly is a player who is yet to debut ranked above 9 others who have?

 

I loved the bit where Bradke was rated higher then Hore and Petty.

Hore was only rated 4th for intercept marks in the AFL in 2019... but yeah cool.

[Skuit 10,031]

I ranked the players using a more objective method:

Christian Petracca 2280

Jack Viney 2666

Clayton Oliver 2248

Max Gawn 2200

Jake Melksham 2213

Jake Lever 2072

Angus Brayshaw 1888

Michael Hibberd 1741

Tom McDonald 1635

Christian Salem 1402

Charlie Spargo 1229

Harley Bennell 892

Sam Weideman 869

Bayley Fritsch 755

James Harmes 753

Josh Wagner 734

Aaron vandenBerg 687

Alex Neal-Bullen 689

Nathan Jones 685

Jayden Hunt 651

Mitchell Hannan 642

Oscar McDonald 611

Steven May 496

Joel Smith 474

Kade Kolodjashnij 335

Mitch Brown 313

Neville Jetta 274

Toby Bedford 235

Adam Tomlinson 181

Braydon Preuss 170

Ed Langdon 112

Corey Wagner 104

Tom Sparrow 95

Oskar Baker 76

Marty Hore 66

Harrison Petty 65

Kyle Dunkley 65

Jay Lockhart 61

Kade Chandler 49

Kysaiah Pickett 39

Luke Jackson –

Trent Rivers –

Aaron Nietschke –

James Jordan –

Austin Bradtke –

 

 

 

[Engorged Onion 10,226]

Give us a clue @Skuit

[Skuit 10,031]

Just now, Engorged Onion said:

Give us a clue @Skuit

The exercise in compiling the rankings was the definition of a complete waste of time but the numbers aren't totally random (like derived from numerology for instance). A box of McDonald's cookies in the mail for whoever cracks the code. 

[Swooper1987 3,322]

I'd be concerned with any ranking system that doesn't have Gawn as our number 1. Three times AA in the past 4 years, dual B&F, AFL Coaches Award winner in 2018. And once again having another consistent and brilliant season. 6 games ago Tracc finished 5th in our club B&F - his first top 5 finish.  He's played three outstanding games this season (Carlton, Hawthorn, GC and a couple of good ones).  I'd think there would still be some distance between his and Gawn's output.  But if he can go past Gawn then we will have two genuine champions and be well on our way to some long overdue team success.

[Bring-Back-Powell 15,576]

13 hours ago, WERRIDEE said:

6 - LANGDON

I reckon he's heading for a top 5-8 B&F finish. Been a great pick up aside from 1 or 2 quietish games at the G earlier in the season.

 

[WERRIDEE 5,643]

1 hour ago, Lord Travis said:

Is this ranked as current output or potential output?

Current output

[WERRIDEE 5,643]

38 minutes ago, Skuit said:

The exercise in compiling the rankings was the definition of a complete waste of time but the numbers aren't totally random (like derived from numerology for instance). A box of McDonald's cookies in the mail for whoever cracks the code. 

I can't crack the code but how on earth is Melksham so high?

[WERRIDEE 5,643]

24 minutes ago, Swooper1987 said:

I'd be concerned with any ranking system that doesn't have Gawn as our number 1. Three times AA in the past 4 years, dual B&F, AFL Coaches Award winner in 2018. And once again having another consistent and brilliant season. 6 games ago Tracc finished 5th in our club B&F - his first top 5 finish.  He's played three outstanding games this season (Carlton, Hawthorn, GC and a couple of good ones).  I'd think there would still be some distance between his and Gawn's output.  But if he can go past Gawn then we will have two genuine champions and be well on our way to some long overdue team success.

Petracca has been on fire. Toss of the coin with those 2. I think they are the best 2 in the league.

[WERRIDEE 5,643]

1 hour ago, Lord Nev said:

On what basis exactly is a player who is yet to debut ranked above 9 others who have?

 

It's based on this year he was an emergency in one game.

[Skuit 10,031]

6 hours ago, WERRIDEE said:

I can't crack the code but how on earth is Melksham so high?

Melksham being so high might be a clue together with Hibberd's rather elevated status. I would say Spargo and Jones are the real anomalies.