I wonder if we've made it to another banner's worth of derision yet 

  On 05/04/2019 at 13:11, olisik said:

To be fair Omac was looking the goods a few years back under Rawlings. Then along cake Chaplin.

First things first Chaplin needs to go, then we can assess whether or not the issue actually is with OmAC or not. Wouldn’t be surprised if it’s Chaplin telling him to play loose off his man.

No, never.

  On 05/04/2019 at 12:48, DV8 said:

ground coverage we couldn't cover the ground tonight as it was,  with all the space we allowed them.   They cut us up with that space.  These two players are 2 of our best distance runners,  with our style, we cannot lose them. or things will bet worse.

What your asking for is a total change of gamestyle and personnel. And we do not have the skilled players to play that way.

Sorry DV8 but all ANB does is run laps around the MCG a million miles from the footy and when he does get near it or heaven help us gets it he turns it over. That dropped chest mark is a good example. Fine to have runners but they  indeed need to be also footballers.

  On 05/04/2019 at 11:49, Wiseblood said:

@binman

ANB can get stuffed, though.  That dropped mark in the third term was it for me.

lost the game there. itnis demoralising.

  On 06/04/2019 at 00:50, praha said:

lost the game there. itnis demoralising.

It's the most frustrated I've been at a player for a long time.  I'm said elsewhere that moments before that he fumbled a ball at half forward, and then he goes and drops a simple chest mark under no pressure.  Unforgivable stuff.

  On 05/04/2019 at 23:26, beelzebub said:

I wonder if we've made it to another banner's worth of derision yet 

Our contributions to the Club, outside of words, are enormous. Maybe our words are the best gift that we can present, after all. Everything else is ignored. The banner could state the facts as these are seen by the supporters, the general footballing public and the Club members. Somehow, we seem to be out of control, rabid and full of expectation to be heard now that Pert is in the chair. Maybe not?

  On 05/04/2019 at 23:54, jnrmac said:

No, never.

The 'avoid impact' at all costs and the running out of the zone as soon as teammates arrive to take the blame/provide support by leaving their own zone and/or opponents to assist in a crisis and then appear to be responsible for the error - after the fact - for a stuff-up or failure have always been characteristic OMac on the field. Long sentence and description, but a long journey for teammates with no end in sight. 

  On 05/04/2019 at 22:27, Clint Bizkit said:

I’d love to know how many (or how few) hours the coaches are putting in to working on ANB’s touch to fix his fumbles.

He should be spending at least two hours a week just working on this. I’d be shocked if they have spent two hours in total over his whole career judging by how often he still fumbles.

I reckon it's a game-day pressure thing.

He is probably clean and crisp at training but once opposition heat is applied in the cauldron atmosphere of a H&A game he seems to crumble.

It's the only explanation I can think of because if that is simply a reflection of his level of ability (i.e. dropping sitters and fumbling ground balls) then he wouldn't even be a VFL standard footballer.

  On 05/04/2019 at 22:11, Redleg said:

Incorrect, our whole team is a dysfunctional mess.

I was referring to Hunts role... and the 3 smalls  (chandler, bedford or spargo)  would be better in our congested dysfunctional forwardline.

  On 05/04/2019 at 13:57, Dee Zephyr said:

He can be as dumb as dog poo for all I care if he kicks 3 every week. Weren’t you one suggesting for him to play in the forward line? 

I called for Hunt to play from deep forward,  leading out toward the ball.  (in an open sort of forwardline with clean ball coming in) 

But our ball coming in is so chaotic,  he will struggle in congestion, as we all saw.   It only worked when he got alone.  He was lucky johnny on the spot, last night.

 

...  but how many did he create for others ???

  On 06/04/2019 at 04:24, DV8 said:

I was referring to Hunts role... and the 3 smalls  (chandler, bedford or spargo)  would be better in our congested dysfunctional forwardline.

I called for Hunt to play from deep forward,  leading out toward the ball.  (in an open sort of forwardline with clean ball coming in) 

But our ball coming in is so chaotic,  he will struggle in congestion, as we all saw.   It only worked when he got alone.  He was lucky johnny on the spot, last night.

 

...  but how many did he create for others ???

I haven’t seen Chandler or Bedford play so I can’t possibly make a comment on either. You have obviously seen them play to make that judgement.  

Hunt was good in my opinion last night, at least he was in some kind of spot. The forward line seemed more open to me in the 2nd when T Mac was off injured. As to your question, Hunt had one goal assist and 10 score involvements, whatever they mean.

  On 06/04/2019 at 00:36, Docs Demons said:

Sorry DV8 but all ANB does is run laps around the MCG a million miles from the footy and when he does get near it or heaven help us gets it he turns it over. That dropped chest mark is a good example. Fine to have runners but they  indeed need to be also footballers.

Yes,  that's right,  and he contributes to us closing down space defensively.   This is important to our gamestyle of pressing back and forward,  to close off escape routes.

This gamestyle isn't working atmo...  but that is not ANB's fault. 

It's others not defending properly, and running hard enough.  Some aren't...  and some can't,  by the looks of them. TMc.

I think this is why they are playing TMc deep, and Weide high. TMc's playing hurt.

  On 06/04/2019 at 04:37, Dee Zephyr said:

I haven’t seen Chandler or Bedford play so I can’t possibly make a comment on either. You have obviously seen them play to make that judgement.  

Hunt was good in my opinion last night, at least he was in some kind of spot. The forward line seemed more open to me in the 2nd when T Mac was off injured. As to your question, Hunt had one goal assist and 10 score involvements, whatever they mean.

Yep and neither have I,  'DZ'.   but their speed and agility,  and that quick footy IQ that comes with being a handy small footy player,  would enable them to get around much traffic. causing Oppo defenders more pressure.

 

Petracca and Hunt struggle by foot in congested traffic     which is what we're getting atmo.

This is why I want Petracca in the midfield,  where his lack of agility quickness... will be less telling.

Also he will find more space in general play, playing thru the middle of the ground...  to use his foot skills.   in time and space. 

Another thing is,  he will be better matched thru the middle...  he'll have to contend less often with larger opponents, than he has to up forward.   His creativity should be more noticeable.

 

At the moment Tracca is very one-dimensional... and defenders would be happy to play on him.   He's too heavy,  and so is too slow up front. 

Our forwardline is like treacle, with Tracca and TMc there.