48 minutes ago, Fat Tony said:

OMac was good against Adelaide but otherwise his form has been down the last two months. Some will put it down to Lever being out of the side but it is more than that IMO. I am not an OMac bear and can see him being a good AFL player in time, but I think Pedersen might be a better option at present. Especially this week against McCartin.

Letting the Sexton goal from 80m bounce through (and getting behind Leslie who would have kicked the goal if it didn't) was particularly poor play from OMac.

Pedersen has the turning circle of the queen mary so will be caught out even more by those balls that get over the top. In general OMac's strength in the last few weeks has been that goal keeping role where he is the last man back, that Sexton goal was a freak event that in the same situation would be lucky to go that way 5 times out of 100 (blaming OMac is drawing a very long bow). 

I've asked but no one has been able to really give an answer on what Ped's role at Casey has been, has he been playing as an intercepting 2nd/3rd type tall or as a main key defender. I know we've got Petty and Keilty down there as well, so he might come in as a direct replacement for Smith if playing a 2nd/3rd defender role but I don't think he'd come in to replace either Frost or OMac as a main tall role - especially against Sydney who rely on Buddy and smalls.   

1 hour ago, Red and Blue realist said:

Pedersen has the turning circle of the queen mary so will be caught out even more by those balls that get over the top. In general OMac's strength in the last few weeks has been that goal keeping role where he is the last man back, that Sexton goal was a freak event that in the same situation would be lucky to go that way 5 times out of 100 (blaming OMac is drawing a very long bow). 

I've asked but no one has been able to really give an answer on what Ped's role at Casey has been, has he been playing as an intercepting 2nd/3rd type tall or as a main key defender. I know we've got Petty and Keilty down there as well, so he might come in as a direct replacement for Smith if playing a 2nd/3rd defender role but I don't think he'd come in to replace either Frost or OMac as a main tall role - especially against Sydney who rely on Buddy and smalls.   

The Sexton goal would have been terrible play even if it had missed. OMac misread the flight of the ball and then was so slow to get back that Leslie beat him to the goal line despite starting well in front. OMac started the year well but has been poor since mid year.

 

I just got told Gawn is out this week.

4 minutes ago, Demons11 said:

I just got told Gawn is out this week.

Bit more info?

7 minutes ago, Fat Tony said:

The Sexton goal would have been terrible play even if it had missed. OMac misread the flight of the ball and then was so slow to get back that Leslie beat him to the goal line despite starting well in front. OMac started the year well but has been poor since mid year.

 

Suggest you watch it again, the ball carried well over their heads, which was happening a lot during the early part of the game due to the wind, as they turned Leslie put an arm across OMac which checked his run but in the end neither managed to get back to the ball. OMac had one very poor game against Geelong, but has been very good besides that and won't be dropped on the back of the 2 games since then. 

1 hour ago, Wiseblood said:

Our number one key defender on their number one forward is funny?  Righto.

While I think Frost is the better matchup, I'd be more than happy to see Oscar get first crack on Sunday afternoon.

Exactly.

Omac has taken the oppos number 1 forward all season.

At the pointy end of the season we are top 4, so unarguably one of the best sides in the competition.

They may well go with frost because they think he is a better match up (ie pace and strength). But given our ladder position they are just as likely to stick with a winning formula.

On a related note, suggestions he might be dropped are absurd.

4 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Bit more info?

Sore calf not sure how bad 

In -     Pedersen,  Melksham

Out -  Gawn (inj) Smith (inj)

 

Pedders to play in the ruck like last season when Gawn was out.

Who comes in for Max?

Pedo was likely to come in anyway as a defender/relief ruck.

Did Melksham train today?

6 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Bit more info?

Isn't Demons 11 the bloke who claimed Gus was looking elsewhere and that we are right into Hannebery?  If it is then I'd be reticent to believe him, although I guess with this one he is a 50/50 in being right.

10 minutes ago, Demonland said:

Who comes in for Max?

Pedo was likely to come in anyway as a defender/relief ruck.

All of your threads of opposition watch 3 weeks out have cursed us, I blame you.

13 minutes ago, Wiseblood said:

Isn't Demons 11 the bloke who claimed Gus was looking elsewhere and that we are right into Hannebery?  If it is then I'd be reticent to believe him, although I guess with this one he is a 50/50 in being right.

Thanks Mr know it all. 

Have you not heard this week Hannebery’s name being floated that he will be leaving Sydney.

16 minutes ago, Wiseblood said:

Isn't Demons 11 the bloke who claimed Gus was looking elsewhere and that we are right into Hannebery?  If it is then I'd be reticent to believe him, although I guess with this one he is a 50/50 in being right.

http://m.afl.com.au/news/2018-08-09/gawn-late-to-training-only-walks-laps

23 minutes ago, Demonland said:

Did Melksham train today?

Melk and  Hibbo were training separately from the main group. I saw them doing leading and kicking drills with Crossy. Both looked to be moving well, no sign of problems but they never joined the main group and left early so looks like another week or so. 

19 minutes ago, Demons11 said:

Thanks Mr know it all. 

Have you not heard this week Hannebery’s name being floated that he will be leaving Sydney.

Great.  We aren't even mentioned in being interested in him, which you said we were.

1 minute ago, Wiseblood said:

Great.  We aren't even mentioned in being interested in him, which you said we were.

We have a pretty good habit of not making those things public.  

So you can prove we are not interested? 

44 minutes ago, Demons11 said:

I just got told Gawn is out this week.

I just got told your full of it, unless your very close to the fd you wouldn't be told anything factual at this stage.

Goodwin seems to think he will play.

5 minutes ago, Demons11 said:

We have a pretty good habit of not making those things public.  

So you can prove we are not interested? 

The burden of proof isn't on me, it's on you.  You've been wrong a few times now, it's not a good look.

6 minutes ago, Wiseblood said:

The burden of proof isn't on me, it's on you.  You've been wrong a few times now, it's not a good look.

Been wrong once mate and don’t really give a s@$t what you think.

congratulations on never being wrong. 

Edited August 9, 20187 yr by Demons11

11 minutes ago, drysdale demon said:

I just got told your full of it, unless your very close to the fd you wouldn't be told anything factual at this stage.

Just passing on the info that was going around mate.  F@&k we have some touchy supporters. 

Edited August 9, 20187 yr by Demons11

5 minutes ago, Wiseblood said:

The burden of proof isn't on me, it's on you.  You've been wrong a few times now, it's not a good look.

 

6 minutes ago, Wiseblood said:

The burden of proof isn't on me, it's on you.  You've been wrong a few times now, it's not a good look.

Feel free not to read my messages, I don’t have any tolerance for people like yourself.

5 minutes ago, Demons11 said:

Just passing on the info that was going around mate.  F@&k we have some touchy supporters. 

Not touchy mate, just sick of the garbage that is continually posted on this site.

3 minutes ago, drysdale demon said:

Not touchy mate, just sick of the garbage that is continually posted on this site.

The bloke didn’t train on a Thursday before a game and reports were a calf issue and wouldn’t be playing.

Was just passing on the info as I’m sure others would be interested as I was.