Motlop & Richmond in discussions today. Some news expected tomorrow.

7 minutes ago, Oliver Sholem said:

Motlop & Richmond in discussions today. Some news expected tomorrow.

Motlop is perfect for Richmond, he is well suited to their downhill skiing.

2 hours ago, Oliver Sholem said:

Motlop & Richmond in discussions today. Some news expected tomorrow.

Some teams just never learn, Yarran last year, now Motlop

On 10/6/2016 at 2:16 AM, dee-tox said:

Remember Todd Viney a few years back going on about four pillars they were looking for in recruits:

... the recruiters rank the players on competitiveness, physical attributes, football attributes and character.

Not sure if Motlop fits all of these.

Or any of them......

5 hours ago, Oliver Sholem said:

Motlop & Richmond in discussions today. Some news expected tomorrow.

Zanotti files?

Initially I wasn't keen.

But with none of the clubs being interested in him driving the asking price right down, along with Geelong desperately needing to clear cap space for Deledio and Tuohy- it's definitely become appealing.

And Geelong have a good history of doing generous trades to allow their players to land where they want without hassle.

Hope we get him, or anyone. This trade period is coma inducing.

So you want someone just because you want a trade done? Good reason.

14 minutes ago, mauriesy said:

So you want someone just because you want a trade done? Good reason.

Cheers

If no one is interested then clubs must know something we don't.  We all know how inconsistent he can be, which includes some electrifying performances and some absolute shockers, and I understand why some supporters would be interested.  But if he is being dangled as trade bait and no one is keen, what's the problem?  Cats asking for too much?  Clubs don't think he can get any better than he currently is?  Pest off the field?

Who knows, but if the FD are showing no interest in him then I'd hazard a guess that he is not someone really worth pursuing.

What's the deal with Viv Michie? Can we use him in a trade for Motlop, or is VM just biding his time until he's delisted in a year or two and in that case, why is he still on our list? Michie or ANB and a pick could get it done? 

Edited October 12, 20169 yr by DominatrixTyson

3 minutes ago, DominatrixTyson said:

What's the deal with Viv Michie? Can we use him in a trade for Motlop, or is VM just biding his time until he's delisted in a year or two and in that case, why is he still on our list? Michie or ANB and a pick could get it done? 

Why would Geelong have any interest at all in Viv Michie?  He isn't worth anything.  Adding him to a 'pick' won't get anything done as it doesn't add any value.

Just now, Wiseblood said:

Why would Geelong have any interest at all in Viv Michie?  He isn't worth anything.  Adding him to a 'pick' won't get anything done as it doesn't add any value.

You obviously haven't heard about a little sweetener called "steak" and "knives." 

Just now, Ethan Tremblay said:

You obviously haven't heard about a little sweetener called "steak" and "knives." 

In this case it's a well done steak with a plastic knife.

1 minute ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

You obviously haven't heard about a little sweetener called "steak" and "knives." 

The little sweetener is actually "cr" and "ap".

Well I guess it's a third or fourth rounder and a starting 22 player, or a 2nd round pick then.... 

 

Edited October 12, 20169 yr by DominatrixTyson

I'd trade Garlett for Motlop + Pick swap. Our 3rd for their 4th I suppose.

Garlett doesn't seem to be weighing heavily in anyones major plans going forward and he has a reasonable amount of worth.

They'd probably want Kent though.

Edited October 12, 20169 yr by DominatrixTyson

8 minutes ago, DominatrixTyson said:

I'd trade Garlett for Motlop + Pick swap. Our 3rd for their 4th I suppose.

Garlett doesn't seem to be weighing heavily in anyones major plans going forward and he has a reasonable amount of worth.

They'd probably want Kent though.

I reckon the fact that he has just recently signed a three year extension suggests that Jeffy is weighing heavily in the club's plans going forward.

4 minutes ago, Tough Kent said:

I reckon the fact that he has just recently signed a three year extension suggests that Jeffy is weighing heavily in the club's plans going forward.

I meant Demonlanders. A lot of people lost confidence in him this year and when the forward line is spoken about on the forum, it's usually only Hogan/Watts/Wiedeman mentioned re long term with Kent and Petracca as the other untradeables flanks/pockets. Extension or not, if we want Motlop we have to give something. No Steak knives :/

Edited October 12, 20169 yr by DominatrixTyson

1 minute ago, DominatrixTyson said:

I meant Demonlanders. A lot of people lost confidence in him this year and when the forward line is spoken about it's usually only Hogan/Watts/Wiedeman 

You build your forward line around your key forwards. Jeffy is still our #1 small forward. 29 goals from 17 games in a year he'd rather forget is not awful. I'd be backing him to bounce back strongly next year.

13 minutes ago, DominatrixTyson said:

I'd trade Garlett for Motlop + Pick swap. Our 3rd for their 4th I suppose.

Garlett doesn't seem to be weighing heavily in anyones major plans going forward and he has a reasonable amount of worth.

They'd probably want Kent though.

Just a tip for you when it comes to posting about potential trade ideas.

Step 1- pick up phone

Step 2- put down phone

Step 3- walk away.

 

 

1 minute ago, Tough Kent said:

You build your forward line around your key forwards. Jeffy is still our #1 small forward. 29 goals from 17 games in a year he'd rather forget is not awful. I'd be backing him to bounce back strongly next year.

I'm not disputing that Jeffy has worth. But Motlop however you put it, is an upgrade on Garlett and he's on the market.

Edited October 12, 20169 yr by DominatrixTyson

1 minute ago, DominatrixTyson said:

I'm not disputing that. But Motlop however you put it, is an upgrade.

That's debatable and Jeffy is already on our list. It costs nothing to bring him on.

2 minutes ago, DominatrixTyson said:

I'm not disputing that Jeffy has worth. But Motlop however you put it, is an upgrade on Garlett and he's on the market.

You are kidding, Motlop is the biggest front runner in the AFL!!  Bigger even than Bruest and Mayne!

Would not even consider him for a set of plastic knives and forks, no name brand burgers and recycled toilet paper towels!

Next!

7 minutes ago, picket fence said:

You are kidding, Motlop is the biggest front runner in the AFL!!  Bigger even than Bruest and Mayne!

Would not even consider him for a set of plastic knives and forks, no name brand burgers and recycled toilet paper towels!

Next!

This has become the newest meme in the AFL: how bad Motlop is due to some especially poor efforts in the last month. It's confirmation bias

Take a look at his stats. Admittedly in the midfield, but still. 80 fantasy points per game is nothing to be sneazed at.

 

http://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/ft_player_compare?playerStatus1=A&tid1=12&playerStatus2=A&tid2=10&type=A&pid1=3189&pid2=3145&fid1=A&fopt1=28&fid2=A&fopt2=26

Edited October 12, 20169 yr by DominatrixTyson