Is the perfect type we are missing to play 2nd ruck/tall fwd. Is very injury prone but might be a bit of risk and reward. Behind Hawkins Stanley smith even maybe Clarke in Geelongs team. Thoughts???  

Edited June 11, 20169 yr by Grimes Times

Yeah nah

At what cost?

Would love him, but would potentially miss 16-22 weeks a year through injury - like every other year!

So that's a no

1 hour ago, Roger Mellie said:

Would love him, but would potentially miss 16-22 weeks a year through injury - like every other year!

So that's a no

Hahaha 

so well put

if a player is Behind Clark in relevance i think that is a clear

"Next...Don't call us, we'll call you..."

NO.

His hips & knees are cactus.

Surprised that he ever played another game, but there's also a reason Geelong have loaded up on so many bigs.

Not against it for the righg price, as when he's injury free he's quite a talented player.

Issue is, I don't see him, Hogan, Watts & Weideman all fitting into the same forward line.

Edited June 12, 20169 yr by AngryAtCasey

48 minutes ago, AngryAtCasey said:

Not against it for the righg price, as when he's injury free he's quite a talented player.

Issue is, I don't see him, Hogan, Watts & Weideman all fitting into the same forward line.

Also Dawes, Pederson and Hulett! (Plus Petracca, Garlett and Kent/Harmes to also fit somewhere)

Edited June 12, 20169 yr by CBDees

This guy is constantly injured.

Why would we want him?

Would rather Majak Daw who has a higher ceiling and not injury prone at all.

Constantly injured and can't get a game at Geelong...it's a yes from me.

Only if he was delisted and we could offer a rookie spot. Big talent but too fragile given constantly injured.

Majak Daw still not strong enough,gets pushed off the ball too easily. Vardy is damaged goods,probably not many games left in him.

9 minutes ago, ENYAW said:

Majak Daw still not strong enough,gets pushed off the ball too easily. Vardy is damaged goods,probably not many games left in him.

Geelong seem to take a very conservative approach with their injured players, if he can't get up for them, I think it's too risky. Even as a DFA (if he comes to that), I think the clubs time and effort could be better spent.

Edited June 12, 20169 yr by Ethan Tremblay