Dion Prestia

[Generation dee 1,336]

14 minutes ago, P-man said:

People get defensive when it comes to how Jones is rated. Myself included. It's understandable as to why. The bloke IS the club.

Out of interest, what is the one trait that separates Sloane from Jones?

Point exactly. I would say midfield depth. Sloane has a strong workmanlike midfield around him, as well as possibly the best forward line in the comp. A lot easier to kick long to this forward line than what ours has consisted of, especially the past 5 years.

[old55 21,788]

Jones. Chronically over rated by some - he wouldn't be in the best 3 players of any of the top midfields.  And chronically under rated by some - he would be in all the top midfields.

[Gator 16,921]

16 minutes ago, Generation dee said:

If you're going to say anything at all about the one consistent shining light of our deplorable team over the past 8 or so years, be prepared for a backlash no matter how much "you're not after a discussion on jones"

While Jones may not have an elite trait, in your eyes, how do you measure durability, ability to extract clearances, get to contest after contest, contend with tagging, perform consistently above average for a midfielder in disposals, tackles contested possessions all while doing so playing high game time with (until recently ) little to no midfield help? You want to talk about elite traits? How does leadership sound? Anyway, you can say what you want. Disagree all you like, Jones is in the top 25 midfielders in the comp and has been for several seasons. 

Prestia coming will simply add more midfield depth to our already growing young stocks, especially as he is closing in on 100 games and has hopefully come through his injury issues.

 

Don't get your knickers in a knot.  I don't rate Todd Viney A-grade and he made the team of the century. 

[rjay 24,130]

6 hours ago, ChaserJ said:

Have watched a fair bit of Treloar going back to his Stingray days.  No doubt has the potential to be absolutely top notch, but would still say he has a way to go. At the moment he is very much a one way player.  He’d be a better all-round mid if he ran even half as hard defensively as he does offensively. I’d go as far to say that he’s a liability in this area.  All well and good if you’re at a club that surrounds you with hard working mids who can cover (Hawks, Sydney), but was Collingwood have a number of downhill skiers in their midfield at the moment, so poor defensive transition and accountability is the norm (with standout performances against Geelong and Brisbane proving to be the exception).

 

 

Yep, the Cats have their fair share of downhill skiers in the midfield too. Probably why they match up well.

[Gator 16,921]

38 minutes ago, P-man said:

People get defensive when it comes to how Jones is rated. Myself included. It's understandable as to why. The bloke IS the club.

Out of interest, what is the one trait that separates Sloane from Jones?

You're right to point out Sloane, as I don't consider him elite/A-grade.

He's a far better mark and just as dogged in the application and contested ball stakes, but like Jones he's blue collar. 

He's been better younger (than Jones), but unlike Priddis and Swan he too is probably not elite in any one skill in the game. 

This is the last comment I'll make on Jones, as I'd rather rearrange my sock drawer.

[McQueen 17,864]

8 hours ago, Django said:

This is definitely true. The same can be said about Viney and so many clearance players, because that's the nature of the contest around centre bounces and stoppages. 

But apparently none of this matters AF because you have been deemed a 'pleb'. It's all over.

Yeah, time to update username to AdamPleb.

[jumbo returns 6,604]

1 hour ago, ProDee said:

Don't get your knickers in a knot.  I don't rate Todd Viney A-grade and he made the team of the century. 

Wowee.....wrong about Jones - that makes x4

You've had a tough week, Benny boy!

[Gator 16,921]

1 hour ago, jumbo returns said:

Wowee.....wrong about Jones - that makes x4

You've had a tough week, Benny boy!

If we're on the wrong page I sit very comfortably. 

[PaulRB 6,048]

There's a particular Demonland experience when you start reading a thread because you're interested in the topic, you read a couple of pages to the end and you think why am I reading that?, where am I? did I click into the wrong thread or is the site broken?...

An then remember you're on Demonland...

[jumbo returns 6,604]

1 hour ago, ProDee said:

If we're on the wrong page I sit very comfortably. 

I know, right? Denial is a beautiful thing

[What 18,810]

We will have three A graders by mid 2017 - Gawn, Viney and Hogan.  

Neither Prestia or Jones are A graders, and thats not a knock on them they are both absolute guns.

[beelzebub 22,631]

Prestia's  "grade' is dependent upon fitness and mindset.....     possibly ....location  

 

hes a gun...a walk in best 4 in our midfield. let's be real.

[Binmans PA 26,603]

12 minutes ago, Petraccattack said:

We will have three A graders by mid 2017 - Gawn, Viney and Hogan.  

Neither Prestia or Jones are A graders, and thats not a knock on them they are both absolute guns.

Haven't you gone back and forth on Prestia being an A grader? So will you say he's an A grader next week?

[What 18,810]

3 minutes ago, AdamPleb said:

Haven't you gone back and forth on Prestia being an A grader? So will you say he's an A grader next week?

 

no AF, I have always said he was a solid B grader.  Copped  a lot of heat for it during trade period when the Prestia thread was very busy.

[Binmans PA 26,603]

9 minutes ago, Petraccattack said:

 

no AF, I have always said he was a solid B grader.  Copped  a lot of heat for it during trade period when the Prestia thread was very busy.

Fair enough. When he comes across to Melbourne, I'll be keeping my eye on you, HH.

[jumbo returns 6,604]

Harsh markers on the skip.

Nate Jones is a star!

[dazzledavey36 49,635]

21 minutes ago, AdamPleb said:

Fair enough. When he comes across to Melbourne, I'll be keeping my eye on you, HH.

Why the name change Adam?

[Generation dee 1,336]

1 hour ago, jumbo returns said:

Harsh markers on the skip.

Nate Jones is a star!

Will go down in history as one of our finest, not only for his career, but how he conducted himself, stayed loyal and bought a lot of belief and mate ship over a young team.

Anyone disputing that, gtfo.

[Binmans PA 26,603]

2 hours ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Why the name change Adam?

 

7 hours ago, McQueen said:

Yeah, time to update username to AdamPleb.

 

[mattjm 151]

4 hours ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Why the name change Adam?

 

[Old Man Rivers 326]

13 hours ago, Generation dee said:

Short memory mate, there were things Brayshaw did last year that absolutely demonstrate how he will become a terrific player for us. Pay no attention to his first 6 months of this year- preseason injury, concussion and a lack of continuity playing have worked against him. Think he will develop into a player very similar to Jobe Watson was at his peak.

100% Correct... Gus was amazing last year & clearly has the ability to take himself to A Grade in the midfield not off half back. Didn't he play nearly every game last year in his first season. You are clearly judging him on 5 minutes in 2016 & have dismissed his entire awesome 2015 season.

[Ethan Tremblay 28,720]

A grade, B grade, D grade who really cares. Perform and play your role in game day. I think there's too much emphasis on 'grading' players.

[Gator 16,921]

5 minutes ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

A grade, B grade, D grade who really cares. Perform and play your role in game day. I think there's too much emphasis on 'grading' players.

C- post

[Ethan Tremblay 28,720]

9 minutes ago, ProDee said:

C- post

I give this thread a D. At least I'm boosting it's grade. 

[Skuit 9,382]

On 6/17/2016 at 5:31 PM, McQueen said:

Yeah, time to update username to AdamPleb.

I'm a pleb and I take offense to this nomenclatural co-opting of my class identifier for pejorative purposes.

Edited June 18, 2016 by Skuit
Speling misstakes of course