Pick 2 on The Table Again

[Redleg 40,843]

This is why bringing in a Ryan O'Keefe would be a massive beneficiary for us.

Not sure if you saw the game this week. GWS despite no fit players on the bench, ran away from our players. It was unbelievable. We are a slow side.

You want to bring in a former great player, who was never quick, who hasn't played an AFL game this year, who turns 34 in January and will probably at best last one season, rather than bringing in a youngster, who could have a career ahead of him. Is that correct?

[stuie 7,374]

Our past draft failures were a result of BP targetting the wrong type and the game changing.

If we cant learn how to draft well and develop then we may as well fold now.

Cook and maybe Gysberts were surprise selections. All the rest were taken pretty much exactly where they were expected to go.

Then we threw them all in the 22 for every game of the season, with no support, no quality mature players around to carry the load, no good mature players to teach and lead them, and wondered why they didn't develop properly.

Have a look at how Salem and JKH have been handled this year, THAT'S proper development.

18 year olds are not our saviours. We should know that by now.

[Machsy 2,858]

Out of interest, if another team wanted to trade for that "run of the mill hardworking midfielder" Dom Tyson, what would we expect back for him?

I wouldn't let him go for at least a top 5 pick.

[old dee 23,781]

Tyson is barely 21, yet to have a full preason, and will likely be runner up in the Bluey. Pretty friggin good "bandaid" pal.

Also, you've just made it clear that you expect draftees to star and carry us, how did that work out from 2007-2013? Plus, you're ignoring the fact that 18 year olds don't develop properly without good mature players around them. You're falling into the same trap.

100% agreement Stuie

This club needs players with a few years under their belts not 18 year old kids who might be good in 2018.

All kids will lead to oblivion.

[Redleg 40,843]

Roosey's fishing ) good on 'im !!

Sitting on the pier and waiting to see what bites.

[Moneider96 1,045]

We better get someone pretty Fukin good if we're trading pick 2. I think pick 2 is more valuable this year considering that Oetracca should be pick 1 if it weren't for st kilda's need to replace riewoldt

[old dee 23,781]

Out of interest, if another team wanted to trade for that "run of the mill hardworking midfielder" Dom Tyson, what would we expect back for him?

I wouldn't let him go for at least a top 5 pick.

Spot on

[Moonshadow 17,675]

We won't develop them properly without quality peak age players to carry the load and teach the kids.

All I remember Roos saying about last year's draft was that they rated the top 10 all pretty evenly, never read anything about "no big bodied mids", but feel free to provide a link/source, cos right now I think you're making it up.

Wrong again Stuie!

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/2013-11-04/trade-period-was-a-success-roos

"We think pick two is going to be a good player, but having a guy that’s two years older, and a bigger body and a bigger midfielder – most of the top end players in the draft are smaller mids. On the back of Jack and Jimmy last year, we need some size and real strength, so getting Dom was fantastic.” - Roos.

[TheoX 1,222]

We have Tyson who struggles with a tag and a bunch of draftees who cant get double digits in posession counts. Wouldnt say it was an overwhelming draft last year. Tyson is a bandaid solution when compared to Josh Kelly and now we are looking at doing it again. Our past draft failures were a result of BP targetting the wrong type and the game changing.

If we cant learn how to draft well and develop then we may as well fold now.

This the same Josh Kelly that gets 0 posessions in nearly half a game as sub? Tyson is no bandaid.

[Ted Lasso 19,311]

I'll reserve judgement until I see which player we pick up, but personally I wouldn't be passing up Petracca unless a gun is on the table

[stuie 7,374]

Wrong again Stuie!

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/2013-11-04/trade-period-was-a-success-roos

"We think pick two is going to be a good player, but having a guy that’s two years older, and a bigger body and a bigger midfielder – most of the top end players in the draft are smaller mids. On the back of Jack and Jimmy last year, we need some size and real strength, so getting Dom was fantastic.” - Roos.

How is it that I'm wrong Moonie? I asked for a source/link, I didn't say "no he didn't say that" did I?

But good on you for trying to tap the grown ups on the shoulder to get some attention, back to the sandbox now little fella.

[olisik 4,060]

If we cant learn to draft and develop on our own then what hope do we have?

Constantly rely on AFL handouts in picks and then trade them for players other teams develop?

[Jaded No More 68,867]

Just because it's on the table doesn't mean we'll trade it away from nothing.

Roos might know something we don't. Would you trade pick 2 for say someone like Shields? Of course you would.

I trust Paul Roos. He is not just after quick short term fixes. He said himself after the game that this is a 3-5 year project.

We didn't pay overs for anyone who was a short term fix, like Cross or Vince.

Tyson is a long term prospect and was a great trade.

[Pennant St Dee 13,118]

Paul Roos just said Pick 2 or a priority pick is on the market again at years end.

I dont like it. Last year's excuse was that there was any big bodied midfielders in the top end.

This year we have Petracca and Brayshaw as potential picks and we are still going to trade it away?

I always said we must unfortunately rebuild through the draft and start fresh.

Paul Roos is after fix fixes im afraid..

Nothing wrong with putting it on the Table Dazzle, you need to see what clubs are prepared to offer or talk about.

GWS put Pick 1 on the Table last year

I'm open to listening to offers and making the decision from there

[Moneider96 1,045]

Collingwood might offer something good

[dazzledavey36 54,285]

Wrong again Stuie!http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/2013-11-04/trade-period-was-a-success-roos

"We think pick two is going to be a good player, but having a guy that’s two years older, and a bigger body and a bigger midfielder – most of the top end players in the draft are smaller mids. On the back of Jack and Jimmy last year, we need some size and real strength, so getting Dom was fantastic.” - Roos.

Beat me to it Moon. Proving stuies lack of research once again.

First of all I think Tyson will be an absolute star. We obviously have a good relationship with GWS but from im hearing Dylan shiel and the likes are close to re signing? He would be the only player id willingly give up pick 2 for.

If not why not Dayne Beams?

[Ted Lasso 19,311]

I'm sure we have made contact with alot of managers with big dollar offers, I'd love to see us hit Adelaide with a big offer for Dangerfield

[stuie 7,374]

If we cant learn to draft and develop on our own then what hope do we have?

Constantly rely on AFL handouts in picks and then trade them for players other teams develop?

You're still missing the point.

We won't develop anyone properly without support from quality mature players.

We will still draft players this year, just like last year, but who is going to carry the load and teach players like Salem, Toumpas, JKH, Tyson, Hunt, Harmes etc? Nate Jones by himself?

[stuie 7,374]

Beat me to it Moon. Proving stuies lack of research once again.

Hahahaha what? I asked for a link/source.

Far out, some of you guys really try your best to stretch things to suit your own needs.

[dazzledavey36 54,285]

How is it that I'm wrong Moonie? I asked for a source/link, I didn't say "no he didn't say that" did I?

But good on you for trying to tap the grown ups on the shoulder to get some attention, back to the sandbox now little fella.

No but you said I made it up.

LOL coming from the man himself that craves in all the attention you receive.

Pot calling the kettle black much jeez

[Moonshadow 17,675]

How is it that I'm wrong Moonie? I asked for a source/link, I didn't say "no he didn't say that" did I?

But good on you for trying to tap the grown ups on the shoulder to get some attention, back to the sandbox now little fella.

Hahahaha! Had your bluff called and you resort to belittling posters! Play the ball Stuie. Try checking your facts before you accuse a poster of making something up. You asked for a link, it has been provided. The least you could do is acknowledge to DD36 that he was correct.

I could end like you with a personal insult putting you down, but this time I don't think it's needed!

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

Going to miss out on potential superstar for another run of the mill hard working midfielder.

morton watts scully trengove sylvia mclean

bunch of potential superstars

[olisik 4,060]

You're still missing the point.

We won't develop anyone properly without support from quality mature players.

We will still draft players this year, just like last year, but who is going to carry the load and teach players like Salem, Toumpas, JKH, Tyson, Hunt, Harmes etc? Nate Jones by himself?

Mature players like Cross Dunn Grimes Garland Jones Jamar Dawes Vince ect?

We have the chance to take the best mid coming into the game, pretty sure we wont get the best mid of their respective draft year in return

[stuie 7,374]

Where did someone from the club say they didn't use pick 2 because there was "no big bodied mids"? Never read that.

Paul Roos last year said it was traded to get in a experience big bodied mid like Tyson because the top end of the draft were only small mid midfielder like Billings Kelly and Aish.

All I remember Roos saying about last year's draft was that they rated the top 10 all pretty evenly, never read anything about "no big bodied mids", but feel free to provide a link/source

Wrong again Stuie!

How is it that I'm wrong Moonie? I asked for a source/link, I didn't say "no he didn't say that" did I?

Beat me to it Moon. Proving stuies lack of research once again.

Classic Demonland "re-interpretation" by the usual suspects.

[stuie 7,374]

Mature players like Cross Dunn Grimes Garland Jones Jamar Dawes Vince ect?

We have the chance to take the best mid coming into the game, pretty sure we wont get the best mid of their respective draft year in return

You're forgetting the "quality" part.

We have 1 (arguably) top quality player on our list, Jones.