We support HT all the way. We will honor his contract

Cue rpfc - "I believe in HT"

And perhaps no Clark ?!

and 2 top tens

but I still lilke bitching about the dog .

We Scully haters consider ourselves a bit like the Simon Wisenthal Centre.

It may be a long time ago but we refuse to let it go.

If that is a politically incorrect comment then swap it for an old digger who survived Changhi and wont forgive the Japanese .

Either way ,the 31 jumper is tainted forever with disgrace .

It gives me great joy to see $cully fail and I'm not sure if it's because it sticks it up Sheedy, or it makes $cully look like a money grabbing scumbag who's turned out to be an absolute dud of a player, one that's totally devoid of any personality and conscience.

It will please me no end when the media start to put the acid on both of them.

It will also please me no end when Sheedy starts to lose players because of the obscene contract that $cully is on.

it will also please me no end when we select two players for the price of half of one and they are both playing well whilst $cully is playing in the local league as the most expensive seconds player ever.

Thanks Sheeds, you pathetic old fool, how does your judgement look now?

Cue rpfc - "I believe in HT"

Should I hold a press conference ?

We Scully haters consider ourselves a bit like the Simon Wisenthal Centre.

It may be a long time ago but we refuse to let it go.

If that is a politically incorrect comment then swap it for an old digger who survived Changhi and wont forgive the Japanese .

Either way ,the 31 jumper is tainted forever with disgrace .

Agree with that (and extra bonus points for working in both theatres of WW2) except for the jumper bit. The jumper is ALWAYS bigger than the man that wears it.

Agree with that (and extra bonus points for working in both theatres of WW2) except for the jumper bit. The jumper is ALWAYS bigger than the man that wears it.

Hope the 31 locker remains welded shut .

Barassi and $cully left it full of evil spirits.

Should I hold a press conference ?

Wait until the end of the year...all talks on hold.

And perhaps no Clark ?!

Not a world I want to live in.

It gives me great joy to see $cully fail and I'm not sure if it's because it sticks it up Sheedy, or it makes $cully look like a money grabbing scumbag who's turned out to be an absolute dud of a player, one that's totally devoid of any personality and conscience.

It will please me no end when the media start to put the acid on both of them.

It will also please me no end when Sheedy starts to lose players because of the obscene contract that $cully is on.

it will also please me no end when we select two players for the price of half of one and they are both playing well whilst $cully is playing in the local league as the most expensive seconds player ever.

Thanks Sheeds, you pathetic old fool, how does your judgement look now?

Phew why dont you tell us how you feel Robbie.......nice to see you havent lost your passion

Edited July 27, 201213 yr by IRW

Get over it Jumbo!!

For heavens sake Scully did the correct thing moving to GWS. Who cares anymore?? You obviously loved him otherwise you wouldn't sulk so much. Scully is still a kid same as Trengove. He'll be good don't worry about that.

I know, thaipantsman, I know...but I'm so damn angry at how all this unfolded.

I healed a little bit when we thrashed them, I need time.

Sorry for being so grumpy.

I'm with you Jmac.

Sheedy wanted pay back bad.

Sheedy has always been lower then a snakes belly.The way he treated Allan Jeans,a true gentlemen who was twice the man, was disgraceful.

Would love to see his knee fall apart and 5mill go down the drain.

Am I bad for wishing evil sh!t on the little bogan?

Don't care .

Would love to see his knee fall apart and 5mill go down the drain.

Am I bad for wishing evil sh!t on the little bogan?

Don't care .

His knee doesn't have to fall apart for that money to go to waste.

Can't helping wondering if Scully would be a far better player now if he had committed to Melbourne in a professional way from the start. He has lost 2 years of development since his first year. I remain bewildered that Melbourne never did due diligence on him and his family. I have never believed in the chorus line of recruiters who all agree on the order of first picks.

We Scully haters consider ourselves a bit like the Simon Wisenthal Centre.

It may be a long time ago but we refuse to let it go.

If that is a politically incorrect comment then swap it for an old digger who survived Changhi and wont forgive the Japanese .

Either way ,the 31 jumper is tainted forever with disgrace .

Both shocking comparisons and your comments taint all future comments of yours as insensitive. Personally anyone who participates in mass genocide and war crimes should be hunted down and punished accordingly. Leaving a job for better pay and securing a financial future for one's family is hardly a comparison. I wonder what you would do if you were offered a significant amount more only to change jobs. Yes I was annoyed but enough of a realist to see it. Please please avoid comparisons like this again.

Both shocking comparisons and your comments taint all future comments of yours as insensitive. Personally anyone who participates in mass genocide and war crimes should be hunted down and punished accordingly. Leaving a job for better pay and securing a financial future for one's family is hardly a comparison. I wonder what you would do if you were offered a significant amount more only to change jobs. Yes I was annoyed but enough of a realist to see it. Please please avoid comparisons like this again.

Anyone who's mad that he left for more money has no support from me, but anyone who believes that the way Scully left was wrong has absolutely got every right to hold that against him. If you ask me, lying is not inherently wrong, but unnecessary lying is; and furthermore, it is a sign of a deep-seated lack of morals.

A "fine young man" Scully is not.

Edited July 27, 201213 yr by Chook

Both shocking comparisons and your comments taint all future comments of yours as insensitive. Personally anyone who participates in mass genocide and war crimes should be hunted down and punished accordingly. Leaving a job for better pay and securing a financial future for one's family is hardly a comparison. I wonder what you would do if you were offered a significant amount more only to change jobs. Yes I was annoyed but enough of a realist to see it. Please please avoid comparisons like this again.

Don't know if I agree with you on that but you're entitled to your opinion.As for this tainting every future comment I make then simply hit the ignore button mate.Personally ,I see little point in hunting down 90 plus year olds 70 years after a war.The comparison to hating Scully is known as Irony or Satire.

Don't know if I agree with you on that but you're entitled to your opinion.As for this tainting every future comment I make then simply hit the ignore button mate.Personally ,I see little point in hunting down 90 plus year olds 70 years after a war.The comparison to hating Scully is known as Irony or Satire.

I can think of 6 million reasons (1 million of which relate to children). Not to mention another 4 million reasons nothing to do with religion. I imagine if a person killed a member of your family, you would want he or she brought to justice no matter their age but that is a guess. The comparison is insensitive and inappropriate. My comment on tainting is also satire and irony. Mmmmm. Perhaps acknowledging an error in attempting some humor is warranted rather than trying to justify it.

Anyone who's mad that he left for more money has no support from me, but anyone who believes that the way Scully left was wrong has absolutely got every right to hold that against him. If you ask me, lying is not inherently wrong, but unnecessary lying is; and furthermore, it is a sign of a deep-seated lack of morals.

A "fine young man" Scully is not.

I can understand that and agree. People are entitled to be mad. What upset me is the comparison to genocide and mass murder.

I can think of 6 million reasons (1 million of which relate to children). Not to mention another 4 million reasons nothing to do with religion. I imagine if a person killed a member of your family, you would want he or she brought to justice no matter their age but that is a guess. The comparison is insensitive and inappropriate. My comment on tainting is also satire and irony. Mmmmm. Perhaps acknowledging an error in attempting some humor is warranted rather than trying to justify it.

There are about 40 million reasons to forget about WW2. You want to demand an apology?Move on...Look forward.

I can understand that and agree. People are entitled to be mad. What upset me is the comparison to genocide and mass murder.

I think Biffen was saying that because some Japanese participated in genocide and mass murder, some elderly Australians are unwilling to associate with any Japanese person.

I'm not sure Biffen was comparing what Scully did to mass murder; rather that a negative experience can fundamentally alter a person's attitude towards a group (or in this case an individual).

Edited July 27, 201213 yr by Chook

There are about 40 million reasons to forget about WW2. You want to demand an apology?Move on...Look forward.

Thought you may be too small to even acknowledge you were insensitive. I can only hope you never experience the pain and hurt my family experienced. Until my last breath I support anyone who brings evil people to justice and will ensure people remember what happened to ensure this never happens again.

I think Biffen was saying that because some Japanese participated in genocide and mass murder, some elderly Australians are unwilling to associate with any Japanese person.

I'm not sure Biffen was comparing what Scully did to mass murder; rather that a negative experience can fundamentally alter a person's attitude towards a group (or in this case an individual).

Thanks for the clarification Chook. I was not involved in WW2 and see no reason to apologise for the actions of the Germans or Japanese.I don't condone the actions of the SS either. I resent the inference also.

I'll move lest I be tried for cyber-crime.

I think Biffen was saying that because some Japanese participated in genocide and mass murder, some elderly Australians are unwilling to associate with any Japanese person.

I'm not sure Biffen was comparing what Scully did to mass murder; rather that a negative experience can fundamentally alter a person's attitude towards a group (or in this case an individual).

Simon Wisenthal was about bringing Nazis to justice, not in punishing anyone of German heritage. That is the fundamental difference. If what you say is what he Meath then all he needed to do was say that was not his intent and I would have stopped. As it is, I have made my point so I am ready to move on.

I hereby decree under the law that is Godwin that thoust thread shall be locked and added wherest such degenerated threads belong. Concilled to the annals of forum history.