Narrowing in on either Grimes or Trengove for Captain

[Sir Why You Little 37,033]

That's not an answer and it could be said for every player on the list - just let them play footy.

We've seen he can play.

I'm waiting for him to lead the club.

Of course it is an answer. You just don't like it 25.

I am waiting for Frank Grimes to play at least 10 consecutive games against top opposition. No point being captain otherwise.

[Redleg 40,895]

I'm totally with you on this one. Leave the kids to play. I'd stick with Greeny, he will have learnt a lot from last years experience.

Agree. They have enough pressure already without adding more at this time. One can't even get on the park. Greeny should go one more year.

[Dockett 32 1,239]

Agree. They have enough pressure already without adding more at this time. One can't even get on the park. Greeny should go one more year.

For some reason I'd be surprised if they go that way Redleg. The new broom seems to be about delivering change.

[rpfc 28,384]

Agree. They have enough pressure already without adding more at this time. One can't even get on the park. Greeny should go one more year.

If you don't want to burden the kids why not give it to Moloney or Jones?

Green has shown he couldn't handle the burden, why not try a different Demon?

[Wadda We Sing 10,685]

If you don't want to burden the kids why not give it to Moloney or Jones?

Green has shown he couldn't handle the burden, why not try a different Demon?

Jones would be an interesting option, he certainly would play with it.

[Red and Blue Flame 186]

If we want the change, and i think Greeny will play better footy if he isn't captain- Is Mark Jamar too old/not good enough to take it up for 2 years whilst Trengove/Grimes get more exp/footy under their belt?

[Roger Mellie 4,012]

If you don't want to burden the kids why not give it to Moloney or Jones?

Green has shown he couldn't handle the burden, why not try a different Demon?

Because with Green you have an escape clause - he's less likely to play after 2012 - perfect timing for Trengove or Grimes to takeover.

I wouldn't want to give it to Moloney or Jones as an interim measure and then take it from them when JT or JG are ready.

Nietz and Junior were ordinary captains in their first year to boot.

[rpfc 28,384]

Because with Green you have an escape clause - he's less likely to play after 2012 - perfect timing for Trengove or Grimes to takeover.

I wouldn't want to give it to Moloney or Jones as an interim measure and then take it from them when JT or JG are ready.

Nietz and Junior were ordinary captains in their first year to boot.

Inspiring stuff...

"We stuck with Brad because it is a convinience."

Cough.

[Range Rover 1,935]

If you don't want to burden the kids why not give it to Moloney or Jones?

Green has shown he couldn't handle the burden, why not try a different Demon?

Jones, seriously? What case is there to be made for him?

[Lutz 76]

He shouts a lot at training and has a prestigious blog, sir.

[Range Rover 1,935]

He shouts a lot at training and has a prestigious blog, sir.

Don't know about the blog (nathanjones.com.au), he's been a bit tardy. Last entry ... March 23 last year.

But his tweeting is Olympic class ...

nathan2jones Nathan Jones

The surf forecast is rank! Keep the weather but send some surf! A surf post trainin, would be a big + #getsobored no surf & too hot for

golf 18 hours ago

[GawnWithTheWind 604]

I have been away for a couple weeks, been watching the posts but didn't have much time to post myself.

We need to stop turning on our own, we forget the great things great players have done for our club so quickly its disgusting.

Bradley Green is one of the most passionate and loyal players this group has. He is mature, understand what it takes to become an elite player and knows what the MFC stand for.

I will be the first to admit, he could not back up 2010 form last year, and did struggle with the media attention on his leadership but he is still a fantastic contributor to our club that doesn't deserve the hating.

This time last year we all voted on leaders for 2011, and the results came up with Brad Green or Brent Moloney for captain. You chose it too! So stop turning on him. He didnt turn his back on us when Eddie and his CashBags offered him a chance to be in a real premiership chance, he held fast and stayed with the club he loves.

I also believe he will not be given the chance to captain the team again, but he still deserves our respect.

Carn the dees

[rpfc 28,384]

Jones, seriously? What case is there to be made for him?

We have no perfect candidate I have said repeatedly.

It's about time people got used to the fact that there will be flawed leader in charge of the Dees in 2012.

Jones is in the mix to be that flawed leader.

[rpfc 28,384]

I have been away for a couple weeks, been watching the posts but didn't have much time to post myself.

We need to stop turning on our own, we forget the great things great players have done for our club so quickly its disgusting.

Bradley Green is one of the most passionate and loyal players this group has. He is mature, understand what it takes to become an elite player and knows what the MFC stand for.

I will be the first to admit, he could not back up 2010 form last year, and did struggle with the media attention on his leadership but he is still a fantastic contributor to our club that doesn't deserve the hating.

This time last year we all voted on leaders for 2011, and the results came up with Brad Green or Brent Moloney for captain. You chose it too! So stop turning on him. He didnt turn his back on us when Eddie and his CashBags offered him a chance to be in a real premiership chance, he held fast and stayed with the club he loves.

I also believe he will not be given the chance to captain the team again, but he still deserves our respect.

Carn the dees

And he gets it from most of us.

But calling him a disappointing captain is not turning on him, it is stating the truth that even you evidence by your belief that he won't return as captain.

[Dr. Gonzo 24,207]

And he gets it from most of us.

But calling him a disappointing captain is not turning on him, it is stating the truth that even you evidence by your belief that he won't return as captain.

So give him a chance at redemption. He had one bad year but has been one of our best performers for the last 5 or so years. With the experience of a year of captain under his belt, a more mature team, a new coaching department he deserves another shot at it. It also gives JT & Grimes another year to develop and stay on the park.

[Sir Why You Little 37,033]

So give him a chance at redemption. He had one bad year but has been one of our best performers for the last 5 or so years. With the experience of a year of captain under his belt, a more mature team, a new coaching department he deserves another shot at it. It also gives JT & Grimes another year to develop and stay on the park.

i would rather see Brad redeem himself by kicking goals in a top forward line. I doubt Neeld will keep the same captain as last year. It didn't work.

[Biffen 12,943]

If we can't turn on our own then what will we do?It's a Demon tradition .

[Roger Mellie 4,012]

Inspiring stuff... "We stuck with Brad because it is a convinience." Cough.

Stick with the small picture then but in doing so - have a bit of a look at the players in question

[Hannibal 5,814]

Jones is in the mix to be that flawed leader.

He's no chance. I'm surprised that someone who posts a lot and watches a lot would even think he was.

[rpfc 28,384]

He's no chance. I'm surprised that someone who posts a lot and watches a lot would even think he was.

We all have different ideas on who would be the most suitable choice.

He isn't my first choice, but unlike another mooted leader (Jamar) he has been in the Leadership Group in his career.

And unlike another mooted leader (Moloney) the difference between his best games and his worst games isn't huge.

And unlike another mooted leader (Grimes) he consistently stays on the park.

And unlike another mooted leader (Green) his body language isn't pathetic when things are difficult.

I am not saying I would give him the reigns because of these reasons, but he is in the mix for the captaincy and these arguments in favour of him.

Again, I will say - stop putting crosses through names people, because you will be left with 6 vice-captains and no captains...

We have no perfect candidate.

[rpfc 28,384]

So give him a chance at redemption. He had one bad year but has been one of our best performers for the last 5 or so years. With the experience of a year of captain under his belt, a more mature team, a new coaching department he deserves another shot at it. It also gives JT & Grimes another year to develop and stay on the park.

If a reason for a captain is that "he gives time for X and Y to develop into a captain" you may aswell forget about it.

Green may be captain again, but it will be because of a significant improvement of his leadership in the off-season (if the new FD can determine that) and hopefully a heart-to-heart with Neeld about what is expected of him.

Besides, his redemption will come with consistent performances as a leader and he can do that without a title, and might be better off achieving this redemption (if it required for fans) without a title.

[Hannibal 5,814]

We have no perfect candidate.

That's a given, but some are more palatable than others. One things is for certain, it won't be Jones.

[Left Field 313]

To be a mid-sized player and be guaranteed a start every week, you need to be versatile. If you don't want your captain sitting in the stands, they really need to be top 10 automatic selections.

Green last year played as a one dimensional lead up forward. He would have been dropped more often if he had not been captain; indeed it became a bit of a distraction when his form really ebbed away. Unless he can rotate back through the midfield, which he realistically probably won't, then Green is not a top 10 pick. Green cannot be captain.

Grimes has only played as a medium sized rebounding defender. Until he spends time rotating through the midfield (and putting a string of games together) he is not a top 10 first pick.

When available, Jamar, Frawley, Trengove, Jones and Moloney will all be amongst the first 10 picked.

Frawley for me, with these others as his deputies.

[Guest Jackie]

One thing I find intriguing about Brent Moloney, was his role in the 186 debacle which in my opinion has never been satisfactorily explained. Sort of disappeared in the storm that blew up soon after. Nil possessions till halftime then subbed which is a very strange statistic for a leading midfielder. Coming after CS was supposedly going to get the sack and DB to get another two years. Was this some sort of coup plot and is he some sort of string puller amongst the players?

[old55 23,547]

I'd go with Green. Grimes is ideal if he can play but he needs a solid year on the field. Trengove just needs to play. It'll will be fascinating © to see what happens.