Jared Rivers

[daisycutter 29,892]

DC you have not given me a laugh in 3 weeks.

Up your game.

You have got to get a lot harder.

We will never make the Gf with the way you are going!

Come on now.

like a bad dose of gout I'm still struggling to recover from our annus horribillis

recent events have only slightly ameliorated my condition....I need action not words, and for that I have to wait what seems like another eternity but it is only 6 months....sigh

[old dee 24,002]

like a bad dose of gout I'm still struggling to recover from our annus horribillis

recent events have only slightly ameliorated my condition....I need action not words, and for that I have to wait what seems like another eternity but it is only 6 months....sigh

On the positive side DC we will not lose one game over the next 4 months.

Think of that no defeats.

Yes talk is cheap and unfortunately I have heard it all quite a few times in the past.

[Biffen 12,949]

JR is just a player in my opinion .Big surprise to me that he was 2nd in the BT medal .All said here must be true-it's how I see him .3rd man up ,loses his man sometime yet creates .Great spoiler but not big enough for the top forwards.Loose man in defence blah , blah , blah.

Another guy who needs to lift .

[H_T 3,049]

No, ........was Pooh that liked honey

lol....and Humphrey didn't ? Like Rivers and footy, you may want to check that

[beelzebub 23,390]

lol....and Humphrey didn't ? Like Rivers and footy, you may want to check that

whatever...you seem to know a lot about honey. Good for you , thats something I suppose.

[Kento80 83]

I've often been puzzled by the bagging Rivers gets from some on this forum. Some mea culpas are (over)due since Friday night's B&F result.

Anyone want to 'fess up to having no idea about how good this bloke has been?

I will admit I am not a fan, and didn't enjoy much about his 2010 at all, finding myself screaming his name at the tele on the regular. This year, he has taken a massive step forward. His spoils in defence were sublime, saving us from a world of hurt with ease of regularity. But this is where the love affair ends. When he is in offence, I cringe. As a leader he offers little. I am absolutely willing to give him a massive improvement tick from last year, but for my point of view, I cannot give him 2nd over Jones, Martin, McKenzie or Trenners. All of this is pointless though, as my opinion counts for nought, but it is my opinion and it won't change.

[jnrmac 20,276]

I've often been puzzled by the bagging Rivers gets from some on this forum. Some mea culpas are (over)due since Friday night's B&F result.

Anyone want to 'fess up to having no idea about how good this bloke has been?

The knock on Jarrod is that he is mostly terrible as a one on one player. When playing the nick maxwell third man up spoiling role he generally excels.

[The Red Fox 216]

JR is just a player in my opinion .Big surprise to me that he was 2nd in the BT medal .All said here must be true-it's how I see him .3rd man up ,loses his man sometime yet creates .Great spoiler but not big enough for the top forwards.Loose man in defence blah , blah , blah.

Another guy who needs to lift .

Agree with all but the first and last statements. Another who needs to lift? I think Jared is one of the few players on our list who is presently playing close to their maximum potential. We know he's a limited athlete (lacking speed and size for his position) but he's a courageous and smart footballer who, in my opinion, is getting the best out of himself.

[Trisul 674]

The umpires for all our games might need to 'fess up too.

[H_T 3,049]

The umpires for all our games might need to 'fess up too.

Care to elaborate Trident ?

B&F and Brownlow voting criteria are miles apart. For a start, B&F concerns one club only. And it doesn't end there....

[Trisul 674]

Yes, I am aware that the B&F and Brownlow are different.

The umpires didn't vote for him once in 20 games. 43 other players to beat. 3 voting positions. ~7% chance per game.

Seven 3-and-under-year players got votes (one came 3rd for club). Two of his line team-mates got votes. The captain got a vote. Moloney got 19.

It's a conspiracy.

[Axis of Bob 11,898]

What it says is that Rivers plays a role for our team that is directly under the instruction of the coaches.

Because he plays the role that he's asked, the way that he's asked and gets the results that are asked of him, the coaches reward his good team role with votes in the club best and fairest.

The coaches know what role he was asked to play and thought he performed that role exactly the way he was asked.

In the Brownlow the umpires have no idea what role a player is asked to play. So they give the votes to the player who they notice the most. Generally it isn't the contest killing tall defender.

Guess how many votes 2011 All Australian defender Darren Glass got? Between the three key defenders in the 2011 All Australian team (Glass, Reid, Scarlett) they got 4 votes. Glass had zero, Reid had one (for a 31 disposal effort against Hawthorn) and Scarlett three (one three vote game after 29 disposals against Hawthorn).

[H_T 3,049]

Yes, I am aware that the B&F and Brownlow are different.

The umpires didn't vote for him once in 20 games. 43 other players to beat. 3 voting positions. ~7% chance per game.

Seven 3-and-under-year players got votes (one came 3rd for club). Two of his line team-mates got votes. The captain got a vote. Moloney got 19.

It's a conspiracy.

People think the same for Silvagni, Fletcher and Scarlett.

Umpires have a history of voting who they see more of during a game. As AOB states, they don't seem to notice the defenders who kill contests.

Fwiw, I did votes throughout the year on what I thought and I only predicted that Rivers get three - that was from one game. I was surprised he didn't get any from that game, but given the Brownlow's history of umpires of overlooking performances, I shouldn't have been.

From that game the vote getters were 3-McKenzie, 2-Gysberts, 1-Trengove who were all named in the best along with Rivers. All midfielders. That was our Friday night game against the Bombers. (Mine were 3-Rivers, 2-McKenzie, 1-Martin)

Ask Greg williams who once got 44 possessions in a game and not one vote. It's no wonder the umpires are often referred to as blind maggots.

[Trisul 674]

OK. Happy place.