RUMOUR FILE

[Whispering_Jack 29,731]

Kicking of the rumour file, here's one from "Deep Throat" on twitter:-

Mitch Clark wants out. Home move most likely but don't discount Victorian teams. Melbourne and bulldogs circling

NOTE: You can't just do a Chilliboy (a former well loved poster here) and state a rumour or make one up. You have to point to a source, even if it has no credibility whatsoever.

[Ron Burgundy 8,584]

Kicking of the rumour file, here's one from "Deep Throat" on twitter:-

NOTE: You can't just do a Chilliboy (a former well loved poster here) and state a rumour or make one up. You have to point to a source, even if it has no credibility whatsoever.

Can Mitch Clark play forward? Or would this free up Jamar to play forward (assuming there's substance to the rumour of course).

[7-UP 107]

here's a rumour from Keith Conlon in twitter

Rowie's rumour on @1395FIVEaa- Ross Lyons to coach #Melbourne next year. 5 year deal. #afl

[7-UP 107]

There's another one from Tom Steinfort from twitter

"Sheedy just hinted very strongly to me that Tom Scully will be announced as a GWS player next Monday""

Then he tweeted

"To clarify - I said "what day next week will you announce Scully's signing?", Sheeds said "the early bird catches the worm"

Hope not true.

[BLWNBA 923]

Nothing in this apart from the I've heard etc so I'd really say nothing in it, but I've ears Martin is a massive chance of going to Richmond. If it were true this could explain our supposed interest in Mitch Clarke.

[east gippsland demon 7]

Nothing in this apart from the I've heard etc so I'd really say nothing in it, but I've ears Martin is a massive chance of going to Richmond. If it were true this could explain our supposed interest in Mitch Clarke.

I thought i read somewhere last week that Martin signed a two year deal ?

[BLWNBA 923]

I thought i read somewhere last week that Martin signed a two year deal ?

Yeah I thought that I'd heard he'd sines as well, but someone posted on here that he's unsigned. Not sure what his current status is. Any info on that would be great!

[east gippsland demon 7]

Yeah I thought that I'd heard he'd sines as well, but someone posted on here that he's unsigned. Not sure what his current status is. Any info on that would be great!

I remember reading that he signed and that secured our ruck stocks with Jamar in contract ,Gawn signed up and then stef . 90 percent sure he signed back up but confirmation would be good .

[Choko 493]

Kicking of the rumour file, here's one from "Deep Throat" on twitter:-

NOTE: You can't just do a Chilliboy (a former well loved poster here) and state a rumour or make one up. You have to point to a source, even if it has no credibility whatsoever.

I have heard that one too. I am a massive Mitch Clark fan, so would love this to happen for the right price.

[H_T 3,043]

Some may have read my comments regarding Brendan Goddard on a thread or two. It's no secret that I have mentioned him in filling our needs as far as leadership goes and strengthening the midfield as far as quality goes. He ticks a few boxes, and I have said dangle something with the captaincy.

I have a source (close to Carlton) that says he wants out at the Saints and wouldn't mind going to Carlton ($@@!). He had good mail on R.Warnock before it blew up.

I'd like our club to approach Goddard. G.Lyon addressed a possible scenario back in June regarding Goddards comments at the time that would suggest he would be open to a change of clubs, that the Saints be better off trading Goddard this year, instead of next year if GWS targeted him in return for compo picks. ie. get something in return now like compo pick/pick/and/or player.

A decent enticement.... ? And insurances off-field matters are a thing of the past... . Long shot, but...

I've been saddened by the news that Jordan Russell is on the outer at the Blues...

[beelzebub 23,312]

Curious there HT..is Gods probs with Lyon ( Ross ) ??

[MadAsHell 4,212]

Some may have read my comments regarding Brendan Goddard on a thread or two. It's no secret that I have mentioned him in filling our needs as far as leadership goes and strengthening the midfield as far as quality goes. He ticks a few boxes, and I have said dangle something with the captaincy.

I have a source (close to Carlton) that says he wants out at the Saints and wouldn't mind going to Carlton ($@@!). He had good mail on R.Warnock before it blew up.

I'd like our club to approach Goddard. G.Lyon addressed a possible scenario back in June regarding Goddards comments at the time that would suggest he would be open to a change of clubs, that the Saints be better off trading Goddard this year, instead of next year if GWS targeted him in return for compo picks. ie. get something in return now like compo pick/pick/and/or player.

A decent enticement.... ? And insurances off-field matters are a thing of the past... . Long shot, but...

I've been saddened by the news that Jordan Russell is on the outer at the Blues...

Would love to land Goddard, that would be a huge win for the club. I'm sure all St. Kilda supporters would love us if we picked up not only their coach but Goddard also.

Very pleased to hear Russell's on the way out at Carlton. He's someone I've mentioned in another thread that I reckon we should chase, ticks a few boxes for us I reckon.

Edit: Russell plays for Carlton, not St. Kilda

Edited September 13, 2011 by Tall Defence

[MadAsHell 4,212]

Russell? You make me spew! Is'nt the type of player we need. He aint good enough for AFL. Very very ordinary!

We are seriously in trouble if we go down this path...

2nd in Carlton's B&F the other year, uses the ball well, decent pace and can play a shut down defensive role on small and mid sized forwards, no don't know what I was thinking....

Russell in our back line means someone like a Grimes, Bail or Blease can spend more time in the midfield to cover Scully's loss.

[Bhima 0]

A source at work - a current st kilda player - was told by Ross Lyon last week that Lyon would be coaching at the Saints next year. Another separate source at work, a well connected Melbourne supporter who is good friends with St Kilda's list manager, told me that everyone at St Kilda thinks Lyon is locked in at the Saints.

Now, this is not to say that Lyon isn't coming to Melbourne. Rather, it is suggesting that Lyon is no sure thing and that if he is coming to Melbourne he has a lot of people within the club fooled. Personally, I'm more confident that he'll come to the Dees than I was about Scully staying...hmmm, do you think Betfair will be able to work out odds based on that statement?

The Saints are sitting down with him this week, so I think by the end of this week we will have our answer...

Probably first and last rumour from me.

Enjoy

[BLWNBA 923]

I remember reading that he signed and that secured our ruck stocks with Jamar in contract ,Gawn signed up and then stef . 90 percent sure he signed back up but confirmation would be good .

Reported in The Sun that Morton and Martin both resigned yesterday. Looks like CM is in future plans for the time being.

[davey_magik 1]

James McDonald to be a playing coach at GWS next year.

[Pennant St Dee 13,044]

James McDonald to be a playing coach at GWS next year.

My mail is Luke Power will be player coach!

[Heart Beats True 1,170]

It's on Twitter:

SpyandSource deepthroat

GWS presser tomorrow to announce that James McDonald will be coming out of retirement in a playing/coaching role for the next 2 years.

[Bhima 0]

A source at work - a current st kilda player - was told by Ross Lyon last week that Lyon would be coaching at the Saints next year. Another separate source at work, a well connected Melbourne supporter who is good friends with St Kilda's list manager, told me that everyone at St Kilda thinks Lyon is locked in at the Saints.

Now, this is not to say that Lyon isn't coming to Melbourne. Rather, it is suggesting that Lyon is no sure thing and that if he is coming to Melbourne he has a lot of people within the club fooled. Personally, I'm more confident that he'll come to the Dees than I was about Scully staying...hmmm, do you think Betfair will be able to work out odds based on that statement?

The Saints are sitting down with him this week, so I think by the end of this week we will have our answer...

Probably first and last rumour from me.

Enjoy

Well, my rumours are on the money, considering Ross Lyon had already confirmed he is staying at the Saints - fail.

[Guest Jack Donaghy]

Has he though? Has it been confirmed?

[H_T 3,043]

Curious there HT..is Gods probs with Lyon ( Ross ) ??

No idea.

Would love to land Goddard, that would be a huge win for the club. I'm sure all St. Kilda supporters would love us if we picked up not only their coach but Goddard also.

Very pleased to hear Russell's on the way out at Carlton. He's someone I've mentioned in another thread that I reckon we should chase, ticks a few boxes for us I reckon.

Edit: Russell plays for Carlton, not St. Kilda

Yes Russell plays for Carlton. Why I mentioned him - I'm guessing. Has been mentioned in despatches with GWS murmurings, but if the rumour is true that BG wants to get to the Blues, they'll have to trade accordingly to meet the needs of the Saints. Blues have a few players they can trade, Russell being one. They'll have to give up 'a fair bit' to get him though. It would take more than Russell. Just my thoughts.

It may not even be this year...apparently (could be next year, when his contract finishes).

I would just like our club to investigate. That's all I want.

PS. I'm relieved this thread is rumour only, no facts...lol

[DemonDave 1,089]

Jordan Russell is a spud. Its all good and well to say he had a high B&F finish at his club a couple of years ago, but so did Matthew Bate.

The fact that he cant get a game at the moment in front an ungainly Irishman (Tuohy) and an equally spud-like Marcus Davies tells me his time at Carlton is coming to an end. No Thanks.

Interesting the irony of supposed links between Goddard and Carlton, given that before AFL sanctions removing their picks 1&2 in the draft he, along with Daniel Wells, would've ended up Blues players.

[Guest Jack Donaghy]

It was seen as a bit of a fairytale leading up to the draft, before the picks were taken away from Carlton.

Goddard comes from a fiercely bogan diehard Carlton supporting family.

He was said to be crushed when he found out about the cap breach penalties.

I reckon he has always harboured a desire to go to Carlton, as have their supporters, so I'm not at all surprised to see this rumour floated as soon as the sign of cracks begin to show at Moorabbin.

[Yokozuna 1,004]

You would think that Goddard would want to go to a club that is going to win a Premiership in the next few years, so I think we might be out of the race there! Dont want to see him go to Carlton, they dont deserve him after their cheating.

[BLWNBA 923]

Rumour doing the rounds at work, Chris Dawes has been offered a contract.