Was the Jack Trengove hearing fair?

[Radar Detector 1,347]

I think you'll find it's Tinney's job whether he agrees with what he's saying or not. He's been hired to prosecute for the MRP, not go in and argue for Jack. Give the Tinney bashing a rest.

[Guest Artie Bucco]

Adam McNicol: Tinney says medical report showed Dangerfield did suffer severe concussion. The fact he could train today "doesn't in any way change the fact this was a significant injury he sustained."

Dog!

[Tricky 341]

That Tinney bloke is a dog.

Yes and Adam McNicol didn't post comments regarding Tinney - can't imagine why?

[Nasher 33,617]

I think you'll find it's Tinney's job whether he agrees with what he's saying or not. He's been hired to prosecute for the MRP, not go in and argue for Jack. Give the Tinney bashing a rest.

This, with moderator's endorsement added on top.

[Kiss of Death 766]

Fix is in.

AFL is refusing to accept Melbourne's argument that the original hearing was a dodgy hearing with only enough time for the panel to pop into the loo before coming out and toeing Demetriou's line.

[Tricky 341]

This, with moderator's endorsement added on top.

May I say that I get the feeling Tinney and I would not become great friends if we were to ever meet? (Just a feeling I get)

[Suzanna 72]

Was the hearing fair? It doesn't appear so. Is the appeal open and accountable? The media have been banned from twittering during the hearing - is the AFL afraid that the public might be disquieted from what is being said? There is no reason that this hearing should be closed in this manner - it is worrying that it is.

[PaulRB 6,432]

Given he was charged on the back of an Adelaide medical report I would think an updated report that downgrades the severity of the concussion (i.e. Dangerfield is now ok to play this weekend), should help.

[Brayshaws' Helmet 143]

May I say that I get the feeling Tinney and I would not become great friends if we were to ever meet? (Just a feeling I get)

Yeah... he kind of makes me want to punch him in the back of the head, whilst he's sipping some coffee

[Tricky 341]

Is Adam McNicol really just an alias for Vlad?

[Guest 36DD]

get wikileaks on-board this stinks

[brendan 3,444]

wow i think we are wasting our time here the afl has never admitted or never will admit that they got something wrong

[Wadda We Sing 10,685]

Come on dees....

[The Great One 99 125]

Hello Adam. Does Tinney have any friends? Was he picked on as a child?

Adam wont answer my question.

[Deestroy All 14,266]

Fingers crossed

[buddha82 12]

Based on what I've been reading I think we're sunk. Hasn't introduced any startling new evidence or clearly shown where the original tribunal verdict was incorrect. Think it's going to stand.

[Tricky 341]

18:32

Adam McNicol: Tony, the tackling player has to take care so that he does not put his opponent's head into the ground and cause him an injury.

Can u believe this shisen?

And some of the knuckle draggers that came up with this have actually played footy!

[Brayshaws' Helmet 143]

Based on what I've been reading I think we're sunk. Hasn't introduced any startling new evidence or clearly shown where the original tribunal verdict was incorrect. Think it's going to stand.

Yep that's the AFL dictatorship for you

[brendan 3,444]

i think adam would have got many questions about tinney

[brendan 3,444]

wont take 4 minutes this time gauranteed there in there talking about there plans 4 the weekend to drag it out

[Kiss of Death 766]

Only about 800m from Etihad right now.. and wearing a Demons jacket. So, so tempted to wander on down and glare at people exiting the media centre.

[daisycutter 29,891]

well they have deliberated for more than 4 mins at least

[Guest 36DD]

could adelaide's dubious role in this have something to do with the departure of Todd Viney and the commitment to Jack Viney?????

[daisycutter 29,891]

lasted 6 mins...waiting

[Kiss of Death 766]

6 minutes this time!