Best 18

[old55 21,922]

Bit of off season entertainment:

Pick one player from each club plus any one extra in position to form an 18 to win the next 3 flags.

Will be better when GWS comes in and it can be truly one from each club.

[Eth 4]

B: Johncock Frawley O'Brien

HB: Gilbee Taylor Goddard

C: Boak Judd Swallow

HF: Didak Franklin Goodes

F: LeCras Brown Riewoldt

R: Sandilands Ablett Watson

Adelaide: Johncock

Brisbane: Brown

Carlton: Judd

Collingwood: Didak, O'Brien

Essendon: Watson

Fremantle: Sandilands

Gold Coast: Ablett

Geelong: Taylor

Hawthorn: Franklin

Melbourne: Frawley

North Melbourne: Swallow

Port Adelaide: Boak

Richmond: Riewoldt

St.Kilda: Goddard

Sydney: Goodes

West Coast: LeCras

Western Bulldogs: Gilbee

[old55 21,922]

Yaeh pretty good selections - I fear there may be a fair few similar results with Ablett, Franklin, Riewoldt etc.

Maybe raise the bar and no repeat selections. Clearly it gets harder ...

[DeeSpencer 23,695]

Adelaide: Thompson

Brisbane: Brown

Carlton: Judd

Collingwood: Pendlebury

Essendon: Watson

Fremantle: Sandilands

Gold Coast: Ablett

Geelong: Bartel

Hawthorn: Franklin

Melbourne: Frawley

North Melbourne: Harvey

Port Adelaide: Boak

Richmond: Riewoldt

St.Kilda: Goddard

Sydney: Goodes

West Coast: LeCras

Western Bulldogs: Griffen, Lake

FB: Bartel Frawley Lake

HB: Griffen Goddard Boak

C: Harvey Watson Thompson

HF: Goodes Brown Pendlebury

FF: LeCras Riewoldt Franklin

Foll: Sandilands Ablett Judd

[Range Rover 1,935]

Using different players ...

B: Harbrow Maxwell Drummond

HB: Deledio Fisher Malceski

C: Salopek Cooney D.Thomas

HF: Sylvia Pavlich Dangerfield

F: Rioli Kennedy L.Thomas

R: Hille Murphy Selwood

Adelaide: Dangerfield

Brisbane: Drummond

Carlton: Murphy

Collingwood: Maxwell/Dale Thomas

Essendon: Hille

Fremantle: Pavlich

Gold Coast: Harbrow

Geelong: Selwood

Hawthorn: Rioli

Melbourne: Sylvia

North Melbourne: Lindsay Thomas

Port Adelaide: Salopek

Richmond: Deledio

St.Kilda: Fisher

Sydney: Malceski

West Coast: Kennedy

Western Bulldogs: Cooney

Edited November 28, 2010 by Range Rover Realism

[Deestroy All 14,262]

CLASSIFIED

Edited December 3, 2010 by Deestroy All

[Trengove 0]

Using all new players again

Adelaide: Kurt Tippett

Brisbane: Mitch Clark

Carlton: Bryce Gibbs

Collingwood: Dane Swan

Essendon: Tayte Pears

Fremantle: Paul Duffield

Geelong: Paul Chapman, Harry Taylor

Gold Coast: Jarred Brennan

Hawthorn: Luke Hodge

Melbourne: Liam Jurrah

North Melbourne: Michael Firrito

Port Adelaide: Danyle Pearce

Richmond: Trent Cotchin

St Kilda: Nick Riewoldt

Sydney: Marty Mattner

West Coast: Adam Selwood

Western Bulldogs: Shaun Higgins

B: Marty Mattner, Tayte Pears, Michael Firrito

HB: Paul Duffield, Harry Taylor, Luke Hodge

C: Adam Selwood Trent Cotchin, Danyle Pearce

HF: Paul Chapman, Nick Riewoldt, Shaun Higgins

F: Liam Jurrah, Kurt Tippett, Jarred Brennan

Foll: Mitch Clark, Dane Swan, Bryce Gibbs

Haha, i dont think this team would win any premierships, tough task

[Deestroy All 14,262]

Using all new players again

Adelaide: Kurt Tippett

Brisbane: Mitch Clark

Carlton: Bryce Gibbs

Collingwood: Dane Swan

Essendon: Tayte Pears

Fremantle: Paul Duffield

Geelong: Paul Chapman, Harry Taylor

Gold Coast: Jarred Brennan

Hawthorn: Luke Hodge

Melbourne: Liam Jurrah

North Melbourne: Michael Firrito

Port Adelaide: Danyle Pearce

Richmond: Trent Cotchin

St Kilda: Nick Riewoldt

Sydney: Marty Mattner

West Coast: Adam Selwood

Western Bulldogs: Shaun Higgins

B: Marty Mattner, Tayte Pears, Michael Firrito

HB: Paul Duffield, Harry Taylor, Luke Hodge

C: Adam Selwood Trent Cotchin, Danyle Pearce

HF: Paul Chapman, Nick Riewoldt, Shaun Higgins

F: Liam Jurrah, Kurt Tippett, Jarred Brennan

Foll: Mitch Clark, Dane Swan, Bryce Gibbs

Haha, i dont think this team would win any premierships, tough task

Naughty naughty, start again.

[Roger Mellie 3,692]

B::McMahon-Lake-H. Shaw

HB:Malcezski--Frawley--Hodge

C::Griffin--Ablett---Deledio

HF:Dangerfield--Riewoldt-Hurley

F::LeCRas---Brown-----Gray

Fol Sandilands Selwood Judd

Adelaide: Dangerfield

Brisbane: Brown

Carlton: Judd

Collingwood: Shaw

Essendon: Hurley

Fremantle: Sandilands

Gold Coast: Ablett

Geelong: Selwood

Hawthorn: Hodge

Melbourne: Frawley

North Melbourne: McMahon

Port Adelaide: Gray

Richmond: Deledio

St.Kilda: Riewoldt

Sydney: Malczeski

West Coast: LeCras

Western Bulldogs: Griffin, Lake

Difficult

[old55 21,922]

Some good efforts with unused players!

[Carlos Danger 380]

Adelaide: Nathan van Berlo

Brisbane: Jonathan Brown

Carlton: Jarrad Waite

Collingwood: Dane Swan

Essendon: Michael Hurley

Fremantle: Aaron Sandilands, Matthew Pavlich

Gold Coast: Gary Ablett

Geelong: Joel Selwood

Hawthorn: Luke Hodge

Melbourne: James Frawley

North Melbourne: Ryan Bastinac

Port Adelaide: Danyle Pearce

Richmond: Jack Riewoldt

St.Kilda: Brendon Goddard

Sydney: Adam Goodes

West Coast: Beau Waters

Western Bulldogs: Brian Lake

B: Frawley Lake Waters

HB: Hodge Goddard Waite

C: Selwood van Berlo Bastinac

HF: Goodes Pavlich Pearce

F: Riewoldt Brown Hurley

R: Sandilands Ablett Swan

[H_T 2,941]

Adelaide: Walker

Brisbane: Fevola

Carlton: Kruezer

Collingwood: Jolly

Essendon: Fletcher

Fremantle: Ballantyne

Gold Coast: Brown

Geelong: Enright, S.Johnson

Hawthorn: Roughead

Melbourne: Scully

North Melbourne: Wells

Port Adelaide: K.Cornes

Richmond: Martin

St Kilda: Gilbert

Sydney: Bolton

Western Bulldogs: Boyd

West Coast: Hurn

Backs: Brown Fletcher Hurn

H Backs: Enright Bolton Gilbert

Centres: Scully Boyd Wells

H Fwds: Walker Roughead Johnson

Fwds: Kruezer Fevola Ballantyne

Foll: Jolly K.Cornes Martin

Nice task old55. Difficult using players not previously mentioned above. The above posters have alot the same with one another. Happy with my side nevertheless.

[old55 21,922]

Top effort with the remaining players HT.

To make it fairer maybe we should have a draft with the 8 posters selecting their 18 in turn - same rules one from each club + 1

Post your selection and club and fill in your team as you go, e.g.

===

Fremantle: Sandilands

B:

HB:

C:

HF:

F:

R: Sandilands

=====

Draft Order:

Round 1

1. High Tower

2. Deez Nutz

3. Roger Mellie

4. Trengove

5. Destroy All

6. Range Rover Realism

7. The Master

8. Eth38

9. Ox 5 Demons

10. E25

Round 2

1. E25

2. Ox 5 Demons

3. Eth38

4. The Master

5. Range Rover Realism

6. Destroy All

7. Trengove

8. Roger Mellie

9. Deez Nutz

10. High Tower

R3 repeat Round 1 order

R4 repeat Round 2 order

etc to Round 18.

That's 180 picks ...

Edited November 30, 2010 by old55

[H_T 2,941]

OK. I'm first {yes!}

{In the voice of Demetriou}

"ROUND 1 Selection 1 - High Tower !"

High Tower: "Player no. 1300GODEES... Melbourne.... James Frawley"

edit:

Backs: Frawley

H-Backs:

Centres:

H-Fwds:

Fwds:

Foll:

Selection number two - you're up Deez Nutz !

[Eth 4]

I'm down for this.

It makes me think, a fantasy competition would be good on here. SuperCoach or Dream Team scoring, but a full draft so that no player can be selected twice. And no starting price for players - either have no money involved, or you pay the players whatever you want out of a certain amount, like in real life.

(Considering the off-season activity, it'd have to start soon)

Edited November 30, 2010 by eth38

[H_T 2,941]

I'm down for this.

Yes. How's your recruiting department ? I've spent squillions on my boys ! ...

[Eth 4]

Yes. How's your recruiting department ? I've spent squillions on my boys ! ...

Boys?

I hope you're not guaranteeing certain players to reach your next selection

[H_T 2,941]

Boys?

I hope you're not guaranteeing certain players to reach your next selection

Not at all. I was referring to my team of recruiters and resources in each state.

[ox_5 163]

Considering that this hasn't really got started can I jump in at pick 9?

Looks a solid time waster!!

[old55 21,922]

Considering that this hasn't really got started can I jump in at pick 9?

Looks a solid time waster!!

Yes and I'll take 1 more to round it out to 10, next in best dressed - it's gonna get too hard to pick players if we go beyond top 10 on each list - 10 decent West Coast or Essendon players - pleeeeease!!!!

[H_T 2,941]

Hard task that one.

*BUMP* _ Who will join in for entrant no.10 ?

[e25 5]

Go on then, slot me in.

[old55 21,922]

Done - E25 - entries closed

Can't seem to find Deez Nutz when you need them?

[H_T 2,941]

Done - E25 - entries closed

Can't seem to find Deez Nutz when you need them?

I PM'd him earlier, my next pick is effectively pick 20 (the cream will be just about gone !)...this could take a while.

10 entrants - 180 players to be selected. OMG. This could take a fortnight.

This thread will end up over 300 posts at a guess. Effectively 7-8 pages. You've created a monster.

[ox_5 163]

I PM'd him earlier, my next pick is effectively pick 20...this could take a while.

10 entrants - 180 players to be selected. OMG. This could take a fortnight.

Perfect! Do we set a time limit on picks to be taken otherwise it's a pass?