6. McKenzie

5. Trengove

4. Green

3. Bruce

2. Watts

1. Frawley

Dunn panics in the heat of the moment, he always has. I see him as a player who has the skills and the body, but a fatally flawed thinking process. Shame.

6 - Green

5 - Trengove

4 - Watts

3 - McKenzie

2 - Frawley

1 - Bruce

6. Frawley

5. Cheney

4. Trengove

3. Bruce

2. Watts

1. Bennell

6. Frawley

5. Cheney

4. Trengove

3. Bruce

2. Watts

1. Bennell

I hope your joking. He was nothing short of horrendous.

I hope your joking. He was nothing short of horrendous.

Bit harsh...he was ok against Goddard, a fair assignment with which to prove yourself in first game of the year! Not sure he was worth 5 votes....Trengove & Chip clearly best.

6: Frawley

5: McKenzie

4: Green

3: Trengove

2: J MacDonald

1: Cheney

Keep at it Jack Watts

6.Trengove

5.Frawley

4.Moloney

3.Green

2.Jamar

1.........

6 Davey

5 Jamar

4 Bruce

3 Dunn

2 Cheney

1 Watts

Apologies: Macdonald, Green, Jones, Beamer, Chip, Garland

I just like the fact that they gave a damn, showed spirit and fought (at least or 3 quarters). Cheney alone showed more hardness than we saw for the whole game last week.

worse was Dunn's goal which he dribbled through from 40m. the choice of kick was absolute brain fade. he's just lucky it went through. unforgiveable. if someone doesn't give him a whack around the ears for that low percentage effort, we're as good as stuffed.

someone can tell him to shave that piece of **** of his upper lip too. it's a disgrace.

my votes:

6 - trengove

5 - mckenzie

4 - bruce

3 - jamar

2 - chip frawley

1 - bennell

someone can tell him to shave that piece of **** of his upper lip too. it's a disgrace. Is there, I didn't even see it.

I agree with your assessment the most GtW.

6 - trengove

5 - mckenzie

4 - bruce

3 - jamar

2 - chip frawley

1 - bennell

6. Trengove

5. Green

4. Frawley

3. Watts

2. McKenzie

1. Jamar

worse was Dunn's goal which he dribbled through from 40m. the choice of kick was absolute brain fade. he's just lucky it went through. unforgiveable. if someone doesn't give him a whack around the ears for that low percentage effort, we're as good as stuffed.

Yep, that was stupid as well. Low percentage rubbish kicks that I don't want people like Dunn, who can barely slot them from 9m directly in front taking. If you're Jurrah or Bennell, you can get away with it, if you're Dunn, then no.

Also agreed with Nasher that his brain does not cope under pressure. He makes terrible decisions, which is why he seems a lot better up forward where decision making isn't as crucial or necessary (not hard to decide between "go for goal" or "pass it on").

I know he played OK footy this season, but he has so many limitations, and for someone who doesn't fulfill a really vital role, that is not good. Bartram for example has limitations, but he does a very good job defensively and is required to play on small forwards, so you forgive some of his downfalls. But when you are a bit player with no real position, you need to have a lot of tricks up your sleeve to justify weekly selection.

6. Green

5. Trengove

4. Frawley

3. McKenzie

2. Watts

1. Garland

6. Green (ho hum...)

5. McKenzie

4. Frawley

3. Trengove

2. Watts (saw something big in him for the first time!!)

1. Jamar (keeps on keeping on...)

Well done to Cheney on his 2010 Season debut also. Was competitive and will hold his spot one would think.

Well done to Cheney on his 2010 Season debut also. Was competitive and will hold his spot one would think.

Goddard had 31 possessions and top votes in The Age FOTY. I'd hate to think what would have happened if Cheney wasn't 'competitive'.

Goddard had 31 possessions and top votes in The Age FOTY. I'd hate to think what would have happened if Cheney wasn't 'competitive'.

When does Goddard NOT have 31 possessions??

And, for the record, Cheney is a backman. Goddard was up forward for most of the match. How many goals did Goddard kick? Just the one...!

Cheney has that ability to not let many goals be kicked on him. He is a great spoil of the footy. He is a tough nugget and I loved his aggression. He won't find many more opponents tougher than Goddard.

He would have learnt lots from the game.

The Russian and his mate Beamer head the field:-

89.112 Mark Jamar

75.042 Brent Moloney

71.599 James Frawley

70.951 James McDonald

64.773 Jack Grimes

51.971 Jack Trengove

50.651 Brad Green

38.586 Tom Scully

36.483 Aaron Davey

33.878 Matthew Bate

32.347 Colin Sylvia

27.367 Jordie McKenzie

21.169 Cameron Bruce

20.656 Ricky Petterd

19.525 Nathan Jones

18.567 Jamie Bennell

17.257 Jordan Gysberts

17.065 Matthew Warnock

11.717 Lynden Dunn

11.680 Clint Bartram

8.662 Joel Macdonald

8.500 Cale Morton

8.211 Rohan Bail

8.073 Neville Jetta

7.064 Brad Miller

6.353 Jack Watts

4.872 Colin Garland

4.752 Cale Morton