Alwyn Davey - Melbourne 2011

[saka888 54]

Im not trying to start a rumour nor have I heard one. My mind has just been pondering the thought of MFC recruiting Alwyn Davey. Aaron is a very passionate player whose dream is to run out on the ground with all the other indigenous players in our side ( wouldn’t we love to see LJ and Wonna together). And im taking a fair punt in saying that I’m sure that both Alwyn and Aaron have a dream to play together in the same side or at least entertained the idea over some bush tucker.

Now Aaron is an important player at our club both for the leadership group and a mentor for the indigenous boys, im sure he could pull a few strings at the club, for them to at least consider the idea.

Now would be a great time for Alwyn to come over, Im sure he doesn’t want to be stuck in the bombers sinking ship, especially with the GC17 & GWS coming in, Essendon could be there for a very long time.

Just to make this a little bit more interesting, Alwyns contract finishes at the end of this year.

So do you think the MFC would take him?

Would he want to come?

[Guest Rojik of the Arctic]

Do we want or need him is a bigger question? If Aussie stays fit and plays good footy and / or Benny takes a few more chances that work for him (and I think they will start doing that) where would you fit him in? And what would you pay for him?

[Trengove_is_God 0]

Alwyn Davey LOL

You gotta be kidding.

[JACKATTACK 17]

Alwyn Davey LOL

You gotta be kidding.

This reply is about as predictable as this thread.

I would take alwyn over wonna, and at this stage Neville and maric. Which is not to say that these players won't one day be better maybe, just that alwyn has runs on the board. That said I don't think Alwyn would really be at the front of our recruiting department's mind.

[Freddy Fuschia 665]

Apart from his first season with the Bombers I don't think Alwyn Davey has really done enough in his career to warrant us chasing him. That said, if there was a low key swap on offer it might work but I doubt it.

[Neita3000 37]

Well we through the kitchen sink at him 2 years ago to try and get him through the pre season draft.

I think he would go better at Melbourne but as to how damaging he would be remains a bit of an unknown.

Dennis Commetti made the comment the other night that he is more effective when he doesn't have the ball that when he does.

Alwyn may have great frontal pressure skills but he aint a great kick like his brother and his decision making leaves much to be desired .

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

No.

The MFC is not a family repatriation service.

And its aan unfair comparison of Davey with Maric, Jetta and Wonna.

Davey is older and should have more runs on the board than players who have either young,been chronically injury or have less than 2 years football experience.

At this point there is no surity than any of them offer a long term AFL proposition to MFC.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Dennis Commetti made the comment the other night that he is more effective when he doesn't have the ball that when he does.

Ouch!!

[Jarka 767]

No.

The MFC is not a family repatriation service.

And its aan unfair comparison of Davey with Maric, Jetta and Wonna.

Davey is older and should have more runs on the board than players who have either young,been chronically injury or have less than 2 years football experience.

At this point there is no surity than any of them offer a long term AFL proposition to MFC.

Have to agree with Rhino on this one

[Spirit of the Demon 209]

The MFC is not a family repatriation service.

There's always an exception to every rule and I would make an exception in the case of Jack Viney for the sake of repatriating a member of the Viney clan to the club.

[JACKATTACK 17]

Have to agree with Rhino on this one

On current value, wonna is behind Alwyn because Wonna is injured. Fair? No, but footy isn't fair. Fit I would rather have Wonna than Alwyn.

I am beginning to lose faith in his hamstrings.

[e25 5]

It's funny, the only game I've ever been to at Etihad was last year against the bombers in Jurrah's first match and i was taking great pleasure in yelling out "you'll never be as good as your brother!" whenever Alwyn had the footy and hearing a mob of deluded essendon suuporters yelling back to the contrary.

Seriously, I wonder what they all think now.

Last year he was coming back from injury & they were all convinced he was the second coming.

[e25 5]

Ouch!!

So true though.

[Great Sage 51]

For me it all comes down to price. If you had to trade a good player or an early draft pick then the answer would be no. However if you are talking Bell, Miller or a late draft pick I would do it in a heartbeat. This could only happen if he falls out of favour at Essendon which would reduce his trade value and the club believes they could get a better return from Alwyn than he currently provides.

[Lil_red_fire_engine 10,203]

Im not trying to start a rumour nor have I heard one. My mind has just been pondering the thought of MFC recruiting Alwyn Davey. Aaron is a very passionate player whose dream is to run out on the ground with all the other indigenous players in our side ( wouldn’t we love to see LJ and Wonna together). And im taking a fair punt in saying that I’m sure that both Alwyn and Aaron have a dream to play together in the same side or at least entertained the idea over some bush tucker.

Now Aaron is an important player at our club both for the leadership group and a mentor for the indigenous boys, im sure he could pull a few strings at the club, for them to at least consider the idea.

Now would be a great time for Alwyn to come over, Im sure he doesn’t want to be stuck in the bombers sinking ship, especially with the GC17 & GWS coming in, Essendon could be there for a very long time.

Just to make this a little bit more interesting, Alwyns contract finishes at the end of this year.

So do you think the MFC would take him?

Would he want to come?

Alwyn had his chance to join his brother at the end of 2009 and chose to stay with the bombers. He is also potentially once of the most overrated players in football. Doubt he would get a game for us. Next.

[Summer Blease 0]

No.. thinking this is why we have Jetta!

[jayceebee31 669]

As RR rightly pointed we are not a repat centre nor he would not get a game with us now let alone in the future. With midfielders a plenty right now which includes the possibilities of these players running through the centre: Bail,Bartram*,Bell*,Bennell, Blease, Bruce**,Aaron Davey,Dunn,Green, Grimes,Gysberts,Jetta,Tapscott,Trengove,McKenzie Jones,Maric,MCDonald**,Moloney,Scully, Strauss, Sylvia, as well as Jack Viney to come I think we have enough smalls to cover Midfield and small forward positions.

Furthermore, he trained with us --and we did not pick him up.We were supposed to have offer him to come to us again and he knocked us back. He cannot get a regular game with Essendon - SO WHY WE?

GO DEES and furthermore Aaron would try to feed him to get a kick rather than -What he does sometimes now- look after the indigenous players instead of other players in better positions.

* = possible delisting next year or next

** = possible retirement, next year or the following.

Edited April 30, 2010 by jayceebee31

[stevethemanjordan 6,952]

I would have no problem picking him up in the NAB draft for a late pick

or the pre season draft.

Bar injuries, he is a very valuable player.

Once again, no brainers on this site just cannot and will not see any value in a player

that is not wearing a red and blue jumper.

I wonder what you all thought of Joel Mac before he was picked up by the dees? If I had asked

anyone what they thought of trying to get him to the dees last season, I can only imagine what the response would be.....

Alwyn is a very good and dangerous player when fully fit. His issues with injuries is the only question mark I would

have in determining whether or not we should go for him.

Nothing worse than ignorant and biased Melbourne supporters.

Edited May 1, 2010 by stevethemanjordan

[Nasher 33,065]

Bar injuries, he is a very valuable player.

So valuable, in fact, that he's a peripheral player in a pretty ordinary Essendon side, even when not (perpetually) injured. I think it's you that needs to take the rose coloured glasses off, not us. He's JASF (just another small forward). If his surname wasn't Davey I doubt anyone would be all that interested.

And FWIW I was stoked that we picked up Joel Macdonald as I did rate him previously.

[jayceebee31 669]

So valuable, in fact, that he's a peripheral player in a pretty ordinary Essendon side, even when not (perpetually) injured. I think it's you that needs to take the rose coloured glasses off, not us. He's JASF (just another small forward). If his surname wasn't Davey I doubt anyone would be all that interested.

And FWIW I was stoked that we picked up Joel Macdonald as I did rate him previously.

Well posted Nasher..furthermore Joel was a player that fitted into our team needs. He is a defender that can play in many positions and experienced in doing so.The Oz felt he was a round 2 pick up..On current form Alwyn would not get a game in the Senior team..

[stevethemanjordan 6,952]

So valuable, in fact, that he's a peripheral player in a pretty ordinary Essendon side, even when not (perpetually) injured. I think it's you that needs to take the rose coloured glasses off, not us. He's JASF (just another small forward). If his surname wasn't Davey I doubt anyone would be all that interested.

He has had injuries as I said. I'm sure you are smart enough to know that players have ups and downs and

sometimes need a change of scenery to reignite their career.

I believe that Alwyn would flourish in a new environment. A new team such as Melbourne who's prospects

are so positive and exciting and to play with his brother. Do I really need to explain that?

Yes it may be a risk and he may not turn out but ffs the upside far outweighs the down if we were

to get him for next to nothing.

And FWIW I was stoked that we picked up Joel Macdonald as I did rate him previously.

Easy to say in hindsight. He has reignited his career at the dee's it seems. Voss dropped

him for the first final. Where are all you posters that state, "I will take the opinion of an expert over yours"?

Honestly.

Congrats to you Nasher if you rated him previously.

Edited May 1, 2010 by stevethemanjordan

[stevethemanjordan 6,952]

Well posted Nasher..furthermore Joel was a player that fitted into our team needs. He is a defender that can play in many positions and experienced in doing so.The Oz felt he was a round 2 pick up..On current form Alwyn would not get a game in the Senior team..

Joel fitted into our teams needs?

He has added experience to the backline and that's it. We have plenty of backs? Rivers playing for Casey this week is proof.

We got him because he was the only worthwhile pickup in the pre season draft. A number of positions? Where else could he play?

On Joel's form last year, nobody would have said he would get a game at Melbourne !!!! Nobody !!!

It's not about current form jayceebee.

[Inner Demon 1]

Discussed it over some bush tucker???? They're from Darwin...

In any event, all the points made above are valid and true. MFC & Aaron tried hard to get him across a couple of years ago and he turned us down. Now he struggles for a game in an ordinary team and we have Aaron, Jetta, Bennell, Wona already.

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

On current value, wonna is behind Alwyn because Wonna is injured. Fair? No, but footy isn't fair. Fit I would rather have Wonna than Alwyn.

I am beginning to lose faith in his hamstrings.

I'd take Alwyn if Aaron could get into the coaching panels ear and prove to them somehow that he could bring about the same quality of disposal that the elder has been delivering for a couple of seasons now.

At best it would be speculative, but given how little there will be in the draft for a side that could possibly be finals bound, I wouldn't be completely against putting him on the list.

I always feel as though we miss Aaron in the forward line (though not for the last 4 weeks)... having another Davey to put in the forward pocket to do what Aaron USED to do would be pretty awesome.

I say yes to Alwyn, with a raft of Caveats.

[H_T 2,941]

Lost interest after the first 3 words of the OP: "I'm not trying..."