His best career game was this year against Richmond when he kicked 2.4. I guess that says it all.

Still, we've got a very impotent fwd line (especially now that Robbo's gone) so having him as a back up isn't the worst thing in the world.

Big year for the Juice!

Juice Newton= 2010 Delistee. Deal with it.

I recall watching Juice in a game v North Melbourne and his lack of strength was obvious as he struggled against physically bigger opponents. Good on him for putting in that bit of extra effort in the gym. I hope it pays off and that the extra size also gives him the confidence to turn 2 goal games into 5 and 6 goal games.

Because its been a few months since we've seen this "High Flyer" in action you could almost forgive yourself in thinking maybe there was hope for him. I'll dress up like superman and streak across the mcg queens birthday 2011 if he is actually still on the list.

Because its been a few months since we've seen this "High Flyer" in action you could almost forgive yourself in thinking maybe there was hope for him. I'll dress up like superman and streak across the mcg queens birthday 2011 if he is actually still on the list.

You might get Wrathchild to dress up as Lois Lane and run across with you if Juice is still around.

You might get Wrathchild to dress up as Lois Lane and run across with you if Juice is still around.

I bet me dressed up as Lois Lane would make your "Redleg" stand up on end. If Juice is still on the 2011 list you might want to buy extra Kleenex that week.

Returned serve well.

Because its been a few months since we've seen this "High Flyer" in action you could almost forgive yourself in thinking maybe there was hope for him. I'll dress up like superman and streak across the mcg queens birthday 2011 if he is actually still on the list.

Could you please wear a Collingwood scarf or beanie .... I don't to how else I will be able to explain it to my kids.

If you'd actually watched him play a game this season, you wouldn't be making comments like that. You can say many things about Newton, but his defensive pressure is no longer a deficiency in his game. In fact, it is now one of his strengths...

I really think he's a confidence player, and if he can find some confidence with his goal kicking, then I think he'll prove to be a good target next to Jurrah and Watts...

Agree

It is really unfortunate that Newton maybe one of those that lets the oppurtunity pass him by

Has got to get his mind right to give himself any chance

Time ISNT on his side

Juice Newton= 2010 Delistee. Deal with it.

I can't deal with it.

He should have been paid out this year so that we could have kept Buckley around for a little longer or used another draft pick.

I can't deal with it.

He should have been paid out this year so that we could have kept Buckley around for a little longer or used another draft pick.

Yeah, they screwed up.

Let's hope the costs are not that great.

I don't think they will be.

Yeah, they screwed up.

Let's hope the costs are not that great.

I don't think they will be.

I reckon he's a confidence player. If he had converted his opportunities over the last two seasons, I don't think we would be cursing his 2 year contract. Full forwards are so hard to find - that you've got to give prospects the benefit of the doubt.

If someone could teach him to kick - he's still a chance...but only just!

Edited October 31, 200916 yr by hoopla

This may cause laughter from some of you, but I believe that Juice is such a confidence player, that if he could have a day out it could completely change his football future. He doesn't have to kick a 100 a year but rather contribute in a meaningful fashion. That could be a few goals and some assists each week. With the spread of goalkickers we have, he could still be a part of our future, but it is completely up to him.

His bigger frame can only help.

Edited October 31, 200915 yr by Redleg

This may cause laughter from some of you, but I believe that Juice is such a confidence player, that if he could have a day out it could completely change his football future. He doesn't have to kick a 100 a year but rather contribute in a meaningful fashion. That could be a few goals and some assists each week. With the spread of goalkickers we have, he could still be a part of our future, but it is completely up to him.

Agree. He's got a year. In that time, either he finds the confidence and becomes something, or he's out the door. I don't see why we're gnashing teeth over him this year.

And I don't see Buckley as having been such an exciting prospect that we need to argue one or the other.

Speaking of Newton, I saw him with Martin at Derby Day today. Newton pretended like he didn't play for Melbourne, obviously because he didn't want the attention, but Martin was pretty happy, advertising that he played for a Melbourne to a few nice girls standing near where we were.

Newton pretended like he didn't play for Melbourne

We as fans pretend he doesn't play for Melbourne as well.

We as fans pretend he doesn't play for Melbourne as well.

To be fair he doesn't very often.

How exactly do you advertise that you play for Melbourne?

Was he walking around with a mega-phone trying to pick up chicks?

To be fair he doesn't very often.

How exactly do you advertise that you play for Melbourne?

Was he walking around with a mega-phone trying to pick up chicks?

I was with some friends on the grass right near the finish line, and I saw him but wasn't sure if it was him. I just asked if he played for Melbourne and he said no, and I said it was alright, I'm not some deranged fan that really gave a [censored] that he was there (I actually said that lol). It's not that big a deal that he said he didn't play for us - obviously didn't want the attention. But then Martin rocked up and started speaking to the girls that were there and he was happy to advertise that he played for Melbourne. The funny thing is that when they left, the girl turned around to me and said "god! why didn't you pull me away? they just wouldn't leave!" lol

I reckon he's a confidence player. If he had converted his opportunities over the last two seasons, I don't think we would be cursing his 2 year contract. Full forwards are so hard to find - that you've got to give prospects the benefit of the doubt.

If someone could teach him to kick - he's still a chance...but only just!

Hoopla -sounds like Juice is your next project. If you get him going you'll be like the Horsewhisperer of MFC.

Despite his bad kicking he still averages over a goal a game at AFL level.

He cops a lot of [censored] from our supporters who don't watch games (He doesn't chase, he's a pea heart etc) but IMO he could be a decent player at AFL level. Remember our forward entries are IIRC the fewest in the comp, if we improve next year like we all hope I think a 40 goal season is a realistic target for Juice.

Despite his bad kicking he still averages over a goal a game at AFL level.

He cops a lot of [censored] from our supporters who don't watch games (He doesn't chase, he's a pea heart etc) but IMO he could be a decent player at AFL level. Remember our forward entries are IIRC the fewest in the comp, if we improve next year like we all hope I think a 40 goal season is a realistic target for Juice.

This is rich. I went to all games at the mcg last year, and i still give him [censored]

and 40 goals? he gets pushed off the ball too much to kick that many

Despite his bad kicking he still averages over a goal a game at AFL level.

He cops a lot of [censored] from our supporters who don't watch games (He doesn't chase, he's a pea heart etc) but IMO he could be a decent player at AFL level. Remember our forward entries are IIRC the fewest in the comp, if we improve next year like we all hope I think a 40 goal season is a realistic target for Juice.

I question his commitment away from the field. I hope he has rectified the issue of his undeveloped upper body, because he certainly hasn't done the work in the gym up to this point.

As for the 40 goals...

Are we to have injuries to Green, Jurrah, and Bate?

He would have to play 20 games at FF in 2010 to kick 40 goals. And why should he have the privilege?

Why not give that to Jurrah (20 goals from 9 games, and a star in the making) or Green (anyone for Carlton in 2000) or Bate (27 goals in 2009 from HFF!).

Lord knows all three would kick more than Newton at FF.

Green (anyone for Carlton in 2000)

Just for those of us too young to remember this game (ie me) what did Green actually do in this infamous final. I can't even remember Carlton even being in finals.

Just for those of us too young to remember this game (ie me) what did Green actually do in this infamous final. I can't even remember Carlton even being in finals.

Green played out of the square and kicked 4 goals. 3 (I think) of which in the 2nd half as we stormed back from 5 goals down in the third to beat the heavily favoured Carlton by 9 points.

He provided a deep lead up target all day and single handed, some say, won us a final in his first year.

(Note: Bruce also played a ripper from memory)

Edited November 4, 200915 yr by rpfc