Demonland Player of the Year

[Demonland 71,832]

It's starting to look very much like Aaron Davey's season ...

95.262 Aaron Davey

57.718 Brent Moloney

42.745 Brock McLean

40.932 Cale Morton

40.838 Colin Sylvia

37.845 Nathan Jones

32.042 James Frawley

31.493 Brad Green

30.197 Cameron Bruce

19.408 Brad Miller

14.443 Matthew Warnock

13.629 Mark Jamar

12.825 Jared Rivers

12.420 Paul Johnson

12.402 Jack Grimes

11.805 Ricky Petterd

10.711 Stefan Martin

10.053 Kyle Cheney

8.827 Jamie Bennell

8.794 Matthew Bate

6.300 Addam Maric

6.126 Russell Robertson

4.374 Clint Bartram

3.333 James McDonald

3.077 Neville Jetta

0.667 Lynden Dunn

0.634 Liam Jurrah

0.613 John Meesen

[titan_uranus 24,984]

Far too late, but what the heck:

6 - Grimes (how did neither paper have him in our best?!?)

5 - Bruce

4 - Green

3 - Frawley

2 - Sylvia

1 - Jetta

[H_T 3,043]

Man, I'd prefer an inteligent poster not call someone a joke for posting their opinion.

Ok. I'll take it back 45h.

He's got rocks in his head.

Is that better?

[Carn dees 108]

Ok. I'll take it back 45h.

He's got rocks in his head.

Is that better?

Mate for some reason i didnt notice bruce do any thing special an he just didnt come to mind at the time.

Also robbo being one of my all time favorite players i obviuosly would of noticed what he did more than what others would have.

Personally i thought it was one of Jones poorer games but you still managed to stick him in.

[H_T 3,043]

Mate for some reason i didnt notice bruce do any thing special an he just didnt come to mind at the time.

Also robbo being one of my all time favorite players i obviuosly would of noticed what he did more than what others would have.

Personally i thought it was one of Jones badder games but you still managed to stick him in.

Each to their own. I wasn't the only one who put Jones in. There were a few others. You were the only one who put Robbo in and you were the only one who missed watching Bruce and missed putting him in the votes. I find it somewhat mind boggling how on earth you could miss Bruce. He was up & down the field all night. Despite the sides very poor showing.

Anyway. I'd rather look forward to West Coast now. At the time on Saturday night, I'd had a few. Looks like I took out my frustration then. No hard feelings.

[Carn dees 108]

Each to their own. I wasn't the only one who put Jones in. There were a few others. You were the only one who put Robbo in and you were the only one who missed watching Bruce and missed putting him in the votes. I find it somewhat mind boggling how on earth you could miss Bruce. He was up & down the field all night. Despite the sides very poor showing.

Anyway. I'd rather look forward to West Coast now. At the time on Saturday night, I'd had a few. Looks like I took out my frustration then. No hard feelings.

Nah your right mate, i was extremely frustrated that night as well and i didnt take much time on my votes, but inlike others or everyone lol i did think robbo did ok from what opportuntiys he had. Any ways i think against westcoast things will be alot different considering i recon we'll acually win.

[Yze_Magic 3]

It's starting to look very much like Aaron Davey's season ...

95.262 Aaron Davey

57.718 Brent Moloney

42.745 Brock McLean

40.932 Cale Morton

40.838 Colin Sylvia

Morton , Moloney and McLean ahead of Sylvia

[CarnTheDees 52]

It's starting to look very much like Aaron Davey's season ...

95.262 Aaron Davey

57.718 Brent Moloney

42.745 Brock McLean

40.932 Cale Morton

40.838 Colin Sylvia

37.845 Nathan Jones

32.042 James Frawley

31.493 Brad Green

30.197 Cameron Bruce

19.408 Brad Miller

14.443 Matthew Warnock

13.629 Mark Jamar

12.825 Jared Rivers

12.420 Paul Johnson

12.402 Jack Grimes

11.805 Ricky Petterd

10.711 Stefan Martin

10.053 Kyle Cheney

8.827 Jamie Bennell

8.794 Matthew Bate

6.300 Addam Maric

6.126 Russell Robertson

4.374 Clint Bartram

3.333 James McDonald

3.077 Neville Jetta

0.667 Lynden Dunn

0.634 Liam Jurrah

0.613 John Meesen

Not sure if this has been suggested previously, but to me the 'weighted' voting system only adds to the 'soft' tag that has been attached to the MFC for far too long. Why? Because we are more heavily rewarding the players that play well in a winning team, ie the downhill skiers.

Although it won't make much of a difference in a season with 1 win on the board, it would be interesting to compare the numbers above based on an un-weighted system, and an inverse system where the weighting factor is the opposition's percentage from the game...

[cooko 124]

Far too late, but what the heck:

same!

6 Davey

5 Bruce

4 Sylvia

3 Jones

2 Green

1 Grimes

[Yze_Magic 3]

Not sure if this has been suggested previously, but to me the 'weighted' voting system only adds to the 'soft' tag that has been attached to the MFC for far too long. Why? Because we are more heavily rewarding the players that play well in a winning team, ie the downhill skiers.

It means Colin Sylvia was punished for his 37 possession, 4 goal effort against Hawthorn.

If that didn't deserve full votes, then nothing ever will.

[titan_uranus 24,984]

Morton , Moloney and McLean ahead of Sylvia

I guess this proves the system has flaws. Sylvia should definitely be above those 3. McLean shouldn't be anywhere near the top 4.

And welcome back YM...

[45HG 1,539]

Part and parcel of a system that ranks per game though.