My 3 word player analysis V The Dorks

[joeboy 3,166]

Bate - not enough impact

Bennell - taught a lesson

Bruce - a steady game

Davey - seemed greatly underused

Frawley - steadied after horrors

Green - reliable and steady

Grimes - seemed completely lost

Johnson - continues to impress

Jones - needs a rest

Maric - excellent first half

Martin - must be settled

McDonald - doesn't hurt opponents

McLean - lacks effective disposal

Miller - unfortunately no alternative

Moloney - unusually quiet game

Morton - disposal was amateurish

Petterd - can't justify retention

Rivers - quiet but effective

Robertson - selfish and undisciplined

Sylvia - career best performance

Warnock - stuck at task

Whelan - lost in mire

[praha 11,240]

Let's see if Sylvia can keep it up with a solid performance (at least) next week. I don't expect another blinder like today, but I want 20+ possessions with 80%+ efficiency and at least one goal.

[gOLLy 401]

Moloney : Worried about injury

Jones : First option please

Miller : Kick the goal

Robbo : Plays for frees.

[Guest sticksmorton]

maric - needs to put his head over the footy

mc lean - slow slow slow

sylvia - great game

[Roost It 1,434]

Bennell - battled on gamely - far from disgraced

Mclean - almost finished at this level

Robertson - you must be kidding

McDonald - hates the Hawks as much as me

Rivers - moving freely

Warnock - very game

Sylvia - best on ground

Martin - can play

Petterd - don't believe the hype

Maric - will be very good

Bate - not enough impact - we will persist

Jones - the most tackled player in the comp

[Ron Burgundy 8,584]

Joeboy, do you actually watch the game each week?

We lost the game by 22 points to last year's premiers - and, having said that, we missed about 8 easy shots on goal; yet, if you read your assessment, it would appear that we got belted by 200 - which, as an objective fact, did not occur. We were outclassed, but not embarrassed. More signs of improvement from a spirited list.

[rusty_kingswood 0]

Joeboy, do you actually watch the game each week?

We lost the game by 22 points to last year's premiers - and, having said that, we missed about 8 easy shots on goal; yet, if you read your assessment, it would appear that we got belted by 200 - which, as an objective fact, did not occur. We were outclassed, but not embarrassed. More signs of improvement from a spirited list.

In Joeboys defense, i don't think the score was quite indicative of the way that we played today.

It was an absolute insipid performance! We got flogged all over the ground, and frankly, the Demons have gone way backwards in their progress. Very upsetting!

[DangerousDemon 3]

Bate - not enough impact

Bennell - taught a lesson

Bruce - a steady game

Davey - seemed greatly underused

Frawley - steadied after horrors

Green - reliable and steady

Grimes - seemed completely lost

Johnson - continues to impress

Jones - needs a rest

Maric - excellent first half

Martin - must be settled

McDonald - doesn't hurt opponents

McLean - lacks effective disposal

Miller - unfortunately no alternative

Moloney - unusually quiet game

Morton - disposal was amateurish

Petterd - can't justify retention

Rivers - quiet but effective

Robertson - selfish and undisciplined

Sylvia - career best performance

Warnock - stuck at task

Whelan - lost in mire

Your assessment of Robertson is 100% correct a selfish game indeed.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

We lost the game by 22 points to last year's premiers - and, having said that, we missed about 8 easy shots on goal; yet, if you read your assessment, it would appear that we got belted by 200 - which, as an objective fact, did not occur. We were outclassed, but not embarrassed. More signs of improvement from a spirited list.

The scoreboard flattered MFC. We were given a fair lesson today. Hopefully the players will be better for the experience learned.

[Jaded No More 68,974]

Can someone tell me what happened with this Robbo incident?

It must have happened on the opposite side of the ground, because I don't remember seeing him do anything particularly bad...

[FitZ 0]

Took a screamer of a mark and then foolishly tried to kick it through while he was still on the ground. The hawthorn player just ran away with it. Reminded me of a certain piece of play that a one M.Jamar was involved in a few years ago!

[w00dy 146]

Can someone tell me what happened with this Robbo incident?

It must have happened on the opposite side of the ground, because I don't remember seeing him do anything particularly bad...

remember that big hanger he went up for in the goal square? and then hawthorn just got the ball somehow and cleared it?

well Robbo took the mark, was on his back in the goal square, and tried to kick the goal whilst on his back in the goal square... the ump called play on, and the hawks cleared the ball...

He would've been directly in front from the goal line, but his showboating cost us a goal...

[deeflog 679]

Moloney : Worried about injury

Jones : First option please

Miller : Kick the goal

Robbo : Plays for frees.

Robbo : Plays for himself!!!

[deeflog 679]

In Joeboys defense, i don't think the score was quite indicative of the way that we played today.

It was an absolute insipid performance! We got flogged all over the ground, and frankly, the Demons have gone way backwards in their progress. Very upsetting!

We should have been equal if not in front at quarter time, we missed far too many makeable shots on goal in that first quarter which really seemed to deflate the midfielders. I don't think tonight was a step back, but just a reality check for us to capatalise on opportunities when you get them

[grazman 7,451]

People are tough on Bate, I thought he had a reasonable game. He's one of the league's leading 'score assists' players and works a lot harder than many seem to understand.

[Jarka 767]

People are tough on Bate, I thought he had a reasonable game. He's one of the league's leading 'score assists' players and works a lot harder than many seem to understand.

His work effort has never been an issue, it's his lack of agility and smarts which is a concern.

[Je Roos Salem 661]

Took a screamer of a mark and then foolishly tried to kick it through while he was still on the ground. The hawthorn player just ran away with it. Reminded me of a certain piece of play that a one M.Jamar was involved in a few years ago!

Don't you mean the one last year against Essendon when he marked it and fumbled it in the goal square?

That effort from Robbo was shocking. He tried to kick the goal when he was on the ground which I didn't get, and he kicked the ball into his opponents shin (I think Beau Dowler). He is a very hard player to rate at the moment, some of the elements of his game look up to scratch if not better than before, like overhead marking, but he just isn't quick enough and needs to improve his set shot goal kicking and decision making.

[DaveyJones'sLocker 647]

how can the umpire call it play on ? robbo did not put ball to boot he did not move from his mark... it was foolish but i think he should have got another kick

u cant knock the ball out of somones hands after they mark it?

[Dee Fan 3,247]

We should have been equal if not in front at quarter time, we missed far too many makeable shots on goal in that first quarter which really seemed to deflate the midfielders. I don't think tonight was a step back, but just a reality check for us to capatalise on opportunities when you get them

Agree we had every opportunity to be on equal terms with them at quarter time but they got the breaks and we didn't. They got a couple of goals resulting from frees and that mark paid to Roughead that should have been against him for hands in the back.

We missed a couple of very easy shots today and why Miller didn't try to kick goals from marks when 50 out is beyond me.

They played better than us, but we hung in there and came back at them late in the game. We had a couple of players coming back from injury and they, Green in particular, got better as the game went on. Not too disappointed.

[PeterJames 46]

Sick of robbo playing for himself and thinking the game is about him! His diving for free kicks is so annoying. Fails to chase and do team things. He is lucky newton is no good. Would love bails to have some balls and drop him!

If petterd gets a game next week i'm nominating for the draft...

Great game col sylvia, was sensational. He was the sole reason it looked respectful in the end.

Bit stiff on brock, kicked a nice goal on the run. Is tough as nails, its not so much speed players need, he has quick hands and reads the play well which is more advantage than speed.

An is franklin the only one that can put his hands in the back off another player.. did it to frawley not once but twice and still was paid the mark!!!

THought grimes was pretty good on rioli... in a side that was dominating i think grimes won the battle.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Bate - Slowly adjusting to life as a permanent forward

Bennell - Quality without the quantity

Bruce - Middle of the road

Davey - Due for a quiet game

Frawley - Was much better suited to Williams than Franklin

Green - Good return from injury

Grimes - Still adjusting to AFL football

Johnson - I rate him, but just lacks polish at times

Jones - Disposal was terrible, bring in Valenti

Maric - Good signs

Martin - Decide whether he is a forward, defender or ruckman now and stick with it

McDonald - Fairly quiet game

McLean - Painfully slow

Miller - Not damaging in any way

Moloney - Quiet game

Morton - Good without being great

Petterd - Not a forward

Rivers - Did very well on Franklin

Robertson - Poor

Sylvia - Almost the best individual performance from any player I've seen in recent years

Warnock - Solid

Whelan - Awesome tackle on Franklin

[DemonDave 1,089]

Did the club make a mistake by resting Bennell last week? He just could not cope with the speed of the game today, it looked like he'd missed 4 weeks of football not 1 such was his lack of awareness of the pace of the contest. I'd say a run at Casey to get the confidence back would be in order for him, given Cheney is knocking down the door..

[Guest sticksmorton]

Did the club make a mistake by resting Bennell last week? He just could not cope with the speed of the game today, it looked like he'd missed 4 weeks of football not 1 such was his lack of awareness of the pace of the contest. I'd say a run at Casey to get the confidence back would be in order for him, given Cheney is knocking down the door..

In the long scheme of things No. Thinking long term here.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Did the club make a mistake by resting Bennell last week? He just could not cope with the speed of the game today, it looked like he'd missed 4 weeks of football not 1 such was his lack of awareness of the pace of the contest.

I thought Bennell showed a lot today.

[Trisul 664]

In Joeboys defense, i don't think the score was quite indicative of the way that we played today.

It was an absolute insipid performance! We got flogged all over the ground, and frankly, the Demons have gone way backwards in their progress. Very upsetting!

Other than the shining light that was Sylvia, not many of our players got above 'OK' from what I saw. A number were below. The last quarter was a given, the match was over and Hawthorn knew it.