Last day of trade week!

[Guest IKTPQMCR]

10 MINUTES!!!!

[H_T 3,043]

Apparently Cats and Bombers still in talks

Yes Prismall to essendon for there 3rd round pick (pick 39). Done.

WARNOCK TO CARLTON !!!!!!!!

[Nicho 1]

Prismall to ESs for pick 39.. CONFIRMED

[Demon_Tingles 211]

Warnock to Carlton confirmed

[Nicho 1]

TRADE Fremantle send Robert Warnock and round five pick (No.69) to Carlton for three draft picks: round two (No.24), round four (no.56) and round 5 (no.72).

[Kiss of Death 747]

Dees won't do jack.

[DaveyJones'sLocker 647]

we might be able to take o keefe in the PSD?

[Nicho 1]

No1 wants to play for Melb...

Lets build through the draft!!!!

[Nicho 1]

With 3 mins to go:

In summary, though: RICHMOND get Adam Thomson from Port Adelaide for pick 42.

COLLINGWOOD traded Rhyce Shaw and their fourth-round pick (No.61) to Sydney for the Swans' third-round round selection (no.46).

BRISBANE traded Anthony Corrie to Collingwood for a seventh round pick (No.93).

BULLDOGS traded Farren Ray and a third-round pick (No.48) to St Kilda for a second-round selection (No.31).

GEELONG traded Brent Prismall to Essendon for a round three pick (No.39)

FREMANTLE sent Robert Warnock and round five pick (No.69) to Carlton for three draft picks: round two (No.24), round four (no.56) and round 5 (no.72).

[Nicho 1]

Thats all..no more trades

the deadline has passed.

[Kiss of Death 747]

trading over, another top effort by the dees to secure quality players and draft picks

so PSD - now do we want cousins (old and trouble), o'keefe (old), lovett (trouble)??

[mo64 5,853]

No1 wants to play for Melb...

Lets build through the draft!!!!

Great selling point for much needed sponsors.

The last time we finished bottom in 1997, we were able to attract Jeff White and almost got Peter Matera.

Well done to the football department. :angry:

[mauriesy 7,261]

So let's retrack a few predictions:

Yze Magic

Melbourne send Brad Green and pick 51 to Collingwood in exchange for pick 29 and Ben Reid. WRONG

Robbie Warnock will not get to Carlton, and will come to the Demons in the PSD. WRONG

O'Keefe to Hawthorn , pick 16 to Essendon, Andrew Lovett and pick 23 to Sydney. WRONG

Brent Prismall to the Bombers for a 3rd rounder. RIGHT, BUT HARDLY A UNIQUE PREDICTION.

West Coast to send Ashley Hansen to the Bulldogs for a 2nd rounder. WRONG

Nudge

Mark Seaby appears almost a certain demon unless Warnock can somehow slip through. WRONG.

Trade of pick 1 for 2, with the eagles adding in a late pick, and the proviso that the Eagles take Naitanui with the no.1 pick, leaving Watts for the dees. WRONG.

It now appears more likely by the day that Green may just move on. WRONG.

Chris Johnson appears likely to be traded back to WA. WRONG

Ryan O'keefe ... has been made the subject of a big play by the Bulldogs, the mail is that they may have their man this time. WRONG

Other players that may be looking for a new home are: Ashley Hansen, Brent Reilly, Farren Ray, Sam Butler, Leigh Fisher, Kane Tenace, Ed Barlow, Jason Davenport, Brad Fisher and Mitch Clarke. FARREN RAY WAS RIGHT ... 1/10

The demons are being reported to have made a formal offer for Power defender Greg Bentley, word around is he WILL be at MFC next year. WRONG

Bell to the crows along with 51 for pick in return for pick 28. WRONG

The demons are the clear front runners for Prismall. WRONG

Maric Legend

Brad Green will re-sign for whatever we were offering him. RIGHT, but ALWAYS LIKELY.

Robbie Warnock comes to the Dees for pick 19. WRONG

Seaby goes to Richmond for something. WRONG

Prismall goes to the PSD. WRONG

Don't think O'Keefe will end up leaving. RIGHT, but ALWAYS LIKELY.

Deetention

Several clubs are reported to be keen on Brad Green. NOT KEEN ENOUGH APPARENTLY ... He didn't leave.

Package him with an Aaron Davey or Green, Bell and Pick 19 and I believe that will get us Pick 4. WRONG

Brent Prismall is almost certain to move and is likely to be a Demon ... Kangaroos the only other club to be keen in his services. WRONG

Richmond is likely to give West Coast a 2nd round pick for Seaby. WRONG

O'keefe is favoured to go to Essendon. Sydney likely too land Lovett, but also keen on Stanton. WRONG.

Hope when all the "inside mail" predictions from "people with contacts" come out next year, this thread is brought up as a reminder.

[Nasher 33,607]

Anyone still think Nudge isn't full of faeces?

[H_T 3,043]

Anyone still think Nudge isn't full of faeces?

[Guest Maric Legend]

So let's retrack a few predictions:

Yze Magic

Melbourne send Brad Green and pick 51 to Collingwood in exchange for pick 29 and Ben Reid. WRONG

Robbie Warnock will not get to Carlton, and will come to the Demons in the PSD. WRONG

O'Keefe to Hawthorn , pick 16 to Essendon, Andrew Lovett and pick 23 to Sydney. WRONG

Brent Prismall to the Bombers for a 3rd rounder. RIGHT, BUT HARDLY A UNIQUE PREDICTION.

West Coast to send Ashley Hansen to the Bulldogs for a 2nd rounder. WRONG

Nudge

Mark Seaby appears almost a certain demon unless Warnock can somehow slip through. WRONG.

Trade of pick 1 for 2, with the eagles adding in a late pick, and the proviso that the Eagles take Naitanui with the no.1 pick, leaving Watts for the dees. WRONG.

It now appears more likely by the day that Green may just move on. WRONG.

Chris Johnson appears likely to be traded back to WA. WRONG

Ryan O'keefe ... has been made the subject of a big play by the Bulldogs, the mail is that they may have their man this time. WRONG

Other players that may be looking for a new home are: Ashley Hansen, Brent Reilly, Farren Ray, Sam Butler, Leigh Fisher, Kane Tenace, Ed Barlow, Jason Davenport, Brad Fisher and Mitch Clarke. FARREN RAY WAS RIGHT ... 1/10

The demons are being reported to have made a formal offer for Power defender Greg Bentley, word around is he WILL be at MFC next year. WRONG

Bell to the crows along with 51 for pick in return for pick 28. WRONG

The demons are the clear front runners for Prismall. WRONG

Maric Legend

Brad Green will re-sign for whatever we were offering him. RIGHT, but ALWAYS LIKELY.

Robbie Warnock comes to the Dees for pick 19. WRONG

Seaby goes to Richmond for something. WRONG

Prismall goes to the PSD. WRONG

Don't think O'Keefe will end up leaving. RIGHT, but ALWAYS LIKELY.

Deetention

Several clubs are reported to be keen on Brad Green. NOT KEEN ENOUGH APPARENTLY ... He didn't leave.

Package him with an Aaron Davey or Green, Bell and Pick 19 and I believe that will get us Pick 4. WRONG

Brent Prismall is almost certain to move and is likely to be a Demon ... Kangaroos the only other club to be keen in his services. WRONG

Richmond is likely to give West Coast a 2nd round pick for Seaby. WRONG

O'keefe is favoured to go to Essendon. Sydney likely too land Lovett, but also keen on Stanton. WRONG.

Hope when all the "inside mail" predictions from "people with contacts" come out next year, this thread is brought up as a reminder.

Just so were clear, I hope your not putting me in the group of "people with contacts", I was just having a punt on what might happen.

Im 16 and live in Adelaide...

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Great selling point for much needed sponsors.

The last time we finished bottom in 1997, we were able to attract Jeff White and almost got Peter Matera.

Well done to the football department. :angry:

They should have gone out and done some riduculous trades for trades sake.

We almost got Matera just like we almost got Warnock, Judd etc.

[mo64 5,853]

They should have gone out and done some riduculous trades for trades sake.

We almost got Matera just like we almost got Warnock, Judd etc.

When Chris Connolly comes out and says that Warnock and Prismall didn't want to come to the club, it's obvious that we seriously targeted these players, and what we offered were better deals than what Freo and Geelong ultimately accepted.

Neil Balme also made that point that Geelong wasn't happy with what they got, but did the right thing by the kid. This suggests that we had a better offer, but Prismall wanted to go to Essendon.

If you think that pick 35 for Prismall and pick 19 for Warnock are ridiculous trades, you've got no idea. But I've always thought that anyway.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

When Chris Connolly comes out and says that Warnock and Prismall didn't want to come to the club, it's obvious that we seriously targeted these players, and what we offered were better deals than what Freo and Geelong ultimately accepted.

Neil Balme also made that point that Geelong wasn't happy with what they got, but did the right thing by the kid. This suggests that we had a better offer, but Prismall wanted to go to Essendon.

If you think that pick 35 for Prismall and pick 19 for Warnock are ridiculous trades, you've got no idea. But I've always thought that anyway.

Just a lesson, yet another one.

Before you start putting trade picks you have to ascertain that the players concerned actually want to play for you. Neither Prismall nor Warnock wanted to play for MFC. Basic but you missed it nothing new.

And I am not sure that either are proven players that I am going to shed to tears or offer very long contracts on big money.

Anyway name the sponsors that cash their chips on trade week.

Just another pathetic whinge without any substance.

[titan_uranus 24,974]

Nudge and Deetention...

Well done you two. About 20 different scenarios listed by Maurie, and not one correct trade.

[mo64 5,853]

Anyway name the sponsors that cash their chips on trade week.

Just another pathetic whinge without any substance.

Dementia has set it. Chris Judd to Carlton. Say no more.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Dementia has set it. Chris Judd to Carlton. Say no more.

Chris Judd is a player and not a sponsor and if you check your facts or indeed actually get some you will find that MFC were never in the hunt for Judd and his tyre kicking was a front. He was going to Carlton all along and despite best efforts MFC were not a show.

Come on name the sponsors that act on trade week Mo. Another case of put up and I bet you wont as usual.

Say no more.

Is that a promise?

[mo64 5,853]

Chris Judd is a player and not a sponsor and if you check your facts or indeed actually get some you will find that MFC were never in the hunt for Judd and his tyre kicking was a front. He was going to Carlton all along and despite best efforts MFC were not a show.

Come on name the sponsors that act on trade week Mo. Another case of put up and I bet you wont as usual.

Is that a promise?

I thought you'd be too thick to understand. If you don't think that Chris Judd going to Carlton didn't attract more corporate sponsorship for the Blues, you are just a plain ignoramous.

Why do you think that Paul McNamee was so keen to get Jonathon Brown?

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

I thought you'd be too thick to understand. If you don't think that Chris Judd going to Carlton didn't attract more corporate sponsorship for the Blues, you are just a plain ignoramous.

Why do you think that Paul McNamee was so keen to get Jonathon Brown?

You trade to improve your list not attract sponsors.

And you would have backed Macca's plan? I bet you would. Given you pillared Hansen as too old for a CHF position. Its no wonder Macca found himself on the outer with that deal.

Maybe they recruited Chris Judd to play football.

So on your own snivelling intelligence which player traded this week would have been a sponsorship coup?

Its no wonder you get pantsed by various posters on this site for your silly and thoughtless comments.

[H_T 3,043]

This is by far more entertaining than trade week.