Everything posted by Roger Mellie
-
Simon Goodwin Sacked
IMO she also intentionally or otherwise puts Goodwin in the frame for leaking in the article
-
Simon Goodwin Sacked
Or Melbourne
-
Simon Goodwin Sacked
It suggests that Green wants to hold onto the gig even though Smith has returned home. Suggests Green acted on Goodwin deliberately before Smith got home. Implies that Smith came home to assume the presidency and that Green doesn't want to give it up until December - but is happy to give it up then as planned. States that Green, Agela Williams, Richardson and Chippindall went to tell Goody and that Green and Williams were asked to leave after a few minutes, but the others stayed longer. They were then asked to leave as Goodwin wanted to be just with his family.
-
Simon Goodwin Sacked
So [censored] sick of this: https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl/awkward-scenes-in-simon-goodwin-s-kitchen-and-a-power-play-in-the-boardroom-20250815-p5mn6a.html Either more muckraking or more instability. Take your pick! Perhaps we can narrow down who's leaking.
-
Welcome to Demonland: Jai Culley
My bad! He said in his interviews it was new to him. I deleted the post - cheers
-
Welcome to Demonland: Jai Culley
Well done JC
-
TRAINING AFLW: August 13, 2025
Thanks for the report. Has Jacinta Hose been ruled out for the season? That would be two seasons in a row - a huge blow for her.
-
Who Will Be Our Next Coach?
Ted Lasso!!!
-
What's Collingwood ever done for Melbourne?
- What's Collingwood ever done for Melbourne?
I'd like to think of what we could do for Collingwood in two weeks! Do Landers realise, if Adelaide hopefully thump Collingwood this week (or even just beat them) and we beat them in the last round, the Bulldogs would get ahead of them on percentage and the filth will be out of the finals. This is assuming the bullies beat West Coast this weekend then Freo at home the following. What a short but magnificently sweet deathride. Come on Dees (and Bulldogs) - GET ON BOARD- Parkin a lifetime MFC supporter !
- Who Will Be Our Next Coach?
Did Collingwood ship out Grundy under Buckley or McRae out of interest?- Simon Goodwin Sacked
Thanks. Does the club have a clue as to who the leaker is?- Who Will Be Our Next Coach?
He also wrote we may go with an untried coach as well - which covers every possible option. Pointless post from a pointless journo.- Caroline Wilson’s article 2 August 2025
I'm certainly not saying he is the right candidate and I'm well aware that 99% of readers on this site believe MFC/AFL takes precedence over everything. Just not sure if he dumped this world conference at this late stage, how good a look it would have been. Maybe that's back on the board for agreeing to it. Either way Duffy is suggesting he's on holiday so who knows WTF's going on.- Caroline Wilson’s article 2 August 2025
I don't get it. He's always maintained he's there until Smith takes over and that he doesn't have the time for the role. What's he taking exception to? The word 'interim'?- Caroline Wilson’s article 2 August 2025
Yes and me either.- GAMEDAY: Rd 21 vs West Coast
What's happened there Jnr? I was sure he recently had at least top 5 finish in their B 'n F. McQualter not a fan? He must be coming to the end of his contract too.- Caroline Wilson’s article 2 August 2025
I used to think that too, but in the media jostling and scrabbling for AFL headlines, she's slipped. Had she done her research, she would have known Conca has been a runner since he started at the club (replacing Burns in the same role). Perhaps she could have also mentioned that Guerra's prior commitment to organising a world conference actually might be significant and that to ditch that for his new role might also be showing a lack of leadership. Green has always maintained he is President for the short term and that it is particularly difficult juggling that with a young family and a business. If Green was 'bristling,' I doubt it was about that. Other than that, I agree with the leadership questions but good journos deal in facts rather than framing to suit their narrative.- POSTGAME: Rd 20 vs St. Kilda
Agree. The whole team should then be made to watch the last quarter again as a group. I'd feel a bit better if the main culprits in cruise mode were then omitted. I'm not interested in giving these players an opportunity to respond. We've seen it happen time and time again eg. first quarter against the Suns.- My 3 word player analysis V StKilda
Snatched a loss Midfield are plodders- POSTGAME: Rd 20 vs St. Kilda
That 6-6-6 debacle wouldn't have been an issue if we hadn't gone into cruise mode in the last quarter. That's what embarrasses me most. Oliver and Petracca were already cooked and the remaining players were either celebrating the victory early or had switched off. Pathetic! Earlier in the game I was thinking how well our defence was going without Lever and May. I still believe they can function well. The midfield was the problem. Shown up by Max Hall in the last and we didn't bother to respond other than have faith in our mids to respond. [censored] that! Hard tag on Hall FFS The 6-6-6 free was the MFC executing the dumbest of dumb footy. Max came back to the centre square with his arms in the air questioning why, when he didn't have to. Viney inexplicably standing by himself on the wing (assume he thought a complete restart was required). The rest of the players were dumbfounded (it's a theme) while NWM and Marshall came up with a winning plan.- PREGAME: Rd 20 vs St. Kilda
My tip is a Moir-type young or no-name player who we don't bother to do our homework on, who then runs amok - Collard for mine, then Sharman if Collard doesn't play.- Judd McVee Contract
I doubt he was only offered two years. I suspect he was offered a range of options and he preferred/settled on the two year deal. It's not uncommon for players to do that until they hit free agency.- The Kalani White Thread (F/S)
- What's Collingwood ever done for Melbourne?