Bombay Airconditioning

Apologies, I’m confused. I thought that’s what I was getting out. What did you think I said? Or do you mean that by his turnovers he creates goals for the opposition hence not stopping them? And against if that is the case what is everyone else doing?

Agree to disagree on Frosty Wise, Frosty can play on more than just the KPF. I believe we could have May, Lever and Frost in the same side if we got more creative/damaging drive from our two back flankers and wingers.

In response to Nick Dal Santo : Why is Frost the problem? What is the primary role of key defender? We have a key defender that can on his day beat the best fwds in the comp, his speed is an asset when attacking the footy to spoil a mark or chase down an opposing player. He also uses his speed to run and carry and break lines, this does result in a lot of turnovers. Why does Frost continually do this? Can we either work with him on his disposal or make those around him accountable? What exactly is Hibberd good for? How did people view his season? Salem his generally a good user of the footy but how damaging is he? Does he take the game on enough or does he play it too safe? Surely there’s room for his game to go to another level. Couldn’t agree more, primary job of a key defender is to shut down opposition key fwds. He does in spades.

Wasn’t there a few games when May, Lever and Frost played together?

That’s currently the case for the majority of the list at the moment. I think it would be a fair guess to say we’re paying a few based on potential or their name.

If Joel Smith is fully fit and gets a good run at it, how would his game compare to Tomlinson?

A lot of posters talking about other posters overrating Frost. I think we all know where Frost is at, can’t blame him for wanting more money, it’s only natural. The two most overrated players on Demonland in recent history are Hogan and Petracca, at least Hogan could dominate the weaker sides.

What’s he asking? I would love to know what players are getting starting with Petracca, Viney and Hibberd.

Taranto

Regardless of what anyone else is doing, we’re only interested in one player, and for how much a season?

Currently MIA.

Besides Melksham who from our side can kick it from outside fifty? Not many names come to mind.

Salem’s disposal is pretty decent at times.

With regards to GCS citing keeping the mates together as justification for picks 1 & 2. Hasn’t one of the Adelaide boys from last year not re signed whilst the other has?

We’re all aware of Frost’s pro’s and cons, I really hope we keep him.

What I take from that is he’s happy for someone to clean him up come next weekend.

How good is King? We still need midfield class if we are serious about competing. I understand scoring was an issue this year but I believe that can be addressed easier than our midfield problems.

I’d like to think we’re still looking at drafting in some small forwards. Always need to have an eye to the future as well as the present.

If Kings that good trade Petracca for him and keep our early pick.

Would love Frosty to stay. Yes his disposal at times is a concern, if we had some more class around him this wouldn’t be such an issue. I often wonder where our salary cap goes looking at our list we must have a few players cleaning up.

Who kicked Collingwood’s goals? Dusty kicked 6. J Kelly 3 , Greene 3, Finlayson 3, Cameron 4 Cripps 4 , Kennedy 4, Ryan 3 If we get pick 2 we need to get some midfield class. Would go pick up 2 small forwards also.

Rioli, Ryan, Rioli, Ryan, Ryan, Rioli, Rioli, Rioli, Ryan, Rioli, Ryan.... Stuff one small fwd, we need two.

I understand your perspective on this however after seeing Green take part in the EJ Whitten it should be revisited. Green should be sought out for a role as little as two days a week for a couple of hours a day to help the players with their kicking. When Green played he was such an accurate shot on goal from multiple angles. A great player I really enjoyed watching play.

2 small forwards.

I’d be targeting two small fwds Wise, when Liam Ryan and Willie Rioli are on it’s a pleasure to watch. Pace, skilful, kick goals and both can take a decent mark. Then there’s the tackling. Also if drafting as opposed to trading for them I go after three using all our late picks/rookie draft. We have to allow they all won’t make it.