CBDees

I don't mind your team with Toumpas and Newton being the other two interchange.

Maybe we won't pinch anybody from the Saints after their from behind win against the in-form Bulldogs!

Hodge is out for three matches.

Passionate supporter he is not. Eddie McGuire is passionate! The only time Garry Lyon has tipped Melbourne in recent history was against GWS ( and he got that wrong )! Have you ever seen Eddie tip against Collingwood or John Elliot against Carlton ( despite them being a basket case)? Apparently performing well in the footy tipping is more important in Lyon's priorities than showing some faith or loyalty towards the MFC.

That is because the umpire gifted them marks for ten metre kicks instead of fifteen. He has no concept of 'fifteen' hence the discrepancy.

Why am I surprised that Henrietta likes this?

Henrietta why don't you go onto the MFC website and see exactly what Jamar and the rest of Watt's teammates (and coaches) appreciate in him and how much they value the actual contribution that he brings to the Club and the team?

Then you obviously know more than Jamar and the rest of his teammates and the coaches who are all 100% behind Watts, if the Jamar interview on the MFC website is to be believed.Meanwhile, Jamar praised forward Jack Watts, who is set to play his 100th game against Fremantle this round.

Thanks guys! Now all the team has to do is beat Freo on Sunday and you will coast thru it next week!

I follow your argument regarding Terlich over Grimes to fill for Jetta this week, however I feel that it might be hard to overlook the past co-captain when you are filling a backline position. As regards a replacement for Kent, I don't think that it is merely a case of speed and ability to tackle because Kent also knew how to find the goals. I suspect that Bail and Toumpas both shade Jones on this score.

Yes and our last win was an away game for us. Keep this up and they may even award us a Friday night match next year, ironic since we are a metamorphous of the landlord.

When I started following the Dees they were officially the "Melbourne Cricket Club Football Club" (one of the MCC sporting sections along with lawn bowls, lacrosse, etc)!

Why wouldn't he stay? With Petracca, Trengove etc coming into the mix next year, he has as much chance of being involved in a Premiership with Melbourne as with any other Club.

Listening to him most mornings, he seems pretty passionate to me!

Clive Palmer?

Actually I think that "Lawyers, Guns & Money" featuring Donaghue, Banks and Campbell (Stevenson) was on 3AW.

Well said Binman. It is nice to see some supporters look objectively at the efforts put in by our players. Roos does not get it wrong in his team selections.

That is because it is even though the co-host goes under the non-de-plume Stevenson (instead of his real name Campbell), probably because of his embarrassment of being a Hawthorn supporter.

Lawrence Money - journalist Bruce Armstrong -sculptor (the Big Bird at Docklands) (Both are passionate Melbourne supporters)

Pedo, Toumpas, Bail, Grimes/fitzy

Sounds like we were umpired out of it!

Is anybody going to be there that can send through a commentary?

At least the Song shares your optimism!

Great win by Casey in the Development League but disappointing to not see any of the four Demons listed amongst the best players!On another note, is there any radio station broadcasting the match today?

Most pleasing thing is that 19 out of 22 players have scored votes after four rounds, suggesting a solid team contribution.