Cranky Franky

Agree 100%. This nonsense unravelled our 2022 season.

And last game he let Stewart get Geelong over the line in the last qtr.

You are kidding BBB was woeful apart from maybe 2 slick handballs early. I don't totally blame him as he should not have played in the conditions.

That's a pretty disappointing comment & put down. Only the first 3 Dees mentioned were full forwards plus B Brown. Dillon was an outstanding CHF or flanker & played for Victoria. Robertson was a very good HFF who kicked 75 goals one year & should have been AA. Parke was the best mark of his era & one year took the most marks in the comp. And a number of the opposition players you mentioned never played at full forward.

Not sure what they do in meetings & training session but the plan seems to be to kick it half a metre over the head of the forward. Thursday the only decent fwd delivery all night was Petracca to Fritter for the last goal.

Fair enough. Everybody (especially footballers) seems to unnecessarily add "to be honest" to every sentence. Goodie ads at least 2 "there's no doubt about that" to every press conference.

Hate to be a pedant but why add "to be honest" ?

Its not about exact like for like match ups its about the defence working as a unit. Sometimes for short periods McVee has to mark a bigger opponent, Hibbo has to tag resting rucks or May on a small quick player. You just dont drop players in good form & in any case Petty, apart from the odd flash, has been in average form this year.

A totally subjective and absurd statement. Tommo matches up fine. If he is dropped after an excellent game its the worst selection decision since Dunn was kept in the 2s by Oscar McD. It would be a repeat of our silly selection decisions of 2022.

Demonland has several confirmed nut cases as well as numerous serial windbags.

I'll do my best.

When someone suggests that Salem is not an elite kick then yes that's clueless.

I don't often agree with Binman but he's spot on here. DeeSpencer's analysis is pretty much clueless.

That assessment is absolute nonsense. The defence as a unit worked very well. If we kick straight we win by 5 or 6 goals.

I thought Deakyn was going to be a gun a couple of years ago but he has gone backwards. He's inconsistent & no better than Casey's VFL players.

You managed to infer violence in football is due to Anglocentric Colonialism. Apparently other non Anglo cultures didn't have violence in their societies.

Embarrassed !! Are you kidding ? I was there & it was against Collingwood & I'm only sorry he didn’t clean up more of the snipers.

All good forwards have to back themselves. Fritta did the right thing.

I'm complaining to the Club about this. On most Club sites there is an easy link to their VFL team with plenty of information. On the MFC site there is no obvious link. If you do a search on the MFC site & type in Casey then you do get a link & useful information about this week's team & this week's game. The other Victorian Clubs can do it so lift your game MFC.

Some posters here remind me that I know people who are still convinced that Lindy Chamberlain is guilty.

Tell me about it. As a migrant I copped it in the neighbourhood as well as at school. The ones who copped it worse were English migrants aka poms. Back then when we copped abuse we gave it back in return.

Sadly whenever the word "racism" is involved then fairness & common sense go out the window & the lynch mob turns up and there are many here on Demonland always ready with pitchforks & torches.

Oops I didn't see that game so I stand corrected but gee he is skinny.

As I've said I watched Jefferson in 4 games & you would expect a high draft pick like him to show something at VFL level, not to star or dominate but the odd sign of future potential but all I've seen is Michael Newton or Lucas Cook so far.

I've seen 4 of Jefferson's games & for a high draft pick he's shown very little. Reminds me of Lucas Cook or a young Michael Newton both in build and ability.