thaipantsman

Keep telling you people to stop watching the commercial TV. Watch Marngrook and this will give you a hit for the week.

Nice team. Chapman to start in the pocket and doubt if Davey will stay.

Yes agree to some extent? Which leads to the topic question to whether a Leigh Mathews type would fit and and adapt to the current style of play.

Intersting call on Spencer. Would put Jamar ahead of him still by a long way. Lets review Spence in two years.

Pickett certainly good one and Tingay was up there. Possible= Brad Miller before he curbed his Natural Mongrel tendencies ?Couldn't get them into my original top 6 though. What's your top 6 since 66??

Perhaps "the silent mongrel" Would certainly put him in the hard nut category

yes Jordie. Thought long and hard about McK. In the end don't think he is feared . Would have to put Dunny up before him.

Brent Moloney, Liam Jurrah, Jared Rivers, Ricky Petterd, Matthew Bate, Lynden Dunn, Joel Macdonald, Jamie Bennell, Clint Bartram, James Sellar and Troy Davis. Comments?

They may be hunted a bit belz! For example Dermie had heaps of Mongrel and skill. He was hunted big time!

before I go to sleep have had a re-think about our current list. Tapscott, Sylvia and Clark

Forgot to ad Sylvia to my current day "Rate the Mongrel" post. Sylvia is a bad man that's why we must keep him

Hei Tona! No I mean real MONGREL! Tapscott, Clark agree though! Cut me some slack. It's late!

Fellow Demonlanders Do you think Melbourne are missing some star "mongrel" types just at the minute? Do you think the effectiveness of the "mongrel" is no longer prominent given video technology and rule changes designed to make AFL football a safer game? How effective would Leigh Mathews be in this age and do you think he could adjust his style and be just as good? Since 66 from what you've read or seen who would you rate to be Melbourne's 6 most effective "mongrel" players in order. For me without consulting any memorabilia and straight off the top of my head as follows Ditterich Biffen Molloy Fowler Grinter Viney I couldn't think of one player in the current Melbourne list that would go close. Current terminology "hardnud"...

what is it? Am in Supercoach ! Love it. Before I started Supercoach I used to wonder why Melbourne kept losing. It's not until you really study the depth of the other teams you find the answer. Love to join up please?

Hei Oli Yes interesting and a little like moving swapping Pawns with your chess buddy

Range Rover, on 09 August 2012 - 07:49 PM, said: 268 - 10 Keep 'em coming folks! 130 replies to this topic

Range Rover on Neeld's first year http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-1efGFYcxJg&feature=player_embedded

do you ever have any substance to add RRover? Sick and tired of you bagging out on practically the entire list. Sylvia Pretender? Get real and actually watch a few games. Apart from yesterday and he stayed on playing with extreme pain he's put 5 good games together. As for your pretender=you may apply that theory to Mark Neeld before Sylvia?? I wouldn't suggest such a thing though.

Your Coaches call!

Soldee Settle down a little. He played the entire game with a bad leg and several shots of cortisone during the day to stay on the Park. Tired of the anti Sylvia Posts. One of the few match winners we have.

Interesting there has been 278 yes votes and 128 replies to the topic.

gptta love Range Rover's persistence to keep his Poll alive. Interesting Mathews insists Port Adelaide go for an experienced Coach. Melbourne should of done the same IMO> Experience a must at Port: Leigh Matthews

BE VERY CLEAR HERE!! READ THE TOPIC!! ITS CLEARLY ASKS IF YOU SUPPORT MARK TO REMAIN COACH IN 2013? MANY OF US DEMONLANDERS DID NOT VOTE SIMPLY BECAUSE THE QUESTION IS NOT WITHOUT MISCHIEF. MOST WANT MARK TO COACH UNTIL THE END OF HIS CONTRACT 2014 AND THE REMAINDER (VAST MAJORITY) DON'T CARE OR SEE A NEED FOR SUCH A POLL. THE MERE FACT THERE IS A POLL SUGGESTS NEELDS'S GRIP IS FRAGILE AND THIS SUGGESTION IS COMPLETE AND UTTER NONSENSE Edited by thaipantsman, 09 August 2012 - 06:10 PM.

Is this an away-"but can use membership to gain entry" match??

IMO This was Melbourne's best performance this year.