Norm Smith's Curse

Nice thoughts but if a deal isnt done we wont pass.

As others have said - my understanding was that Viney is filling in for a bloke from Collingwood whose coming - and there is a team including Kelly O'something.

based on current form Id have to agree but I think he will get there.

Yepp prettymuch what everyone's been talking about for six months now... Hellsgate reckons that he has heard that there is a possibility we wont take Viney. Not what ive heard from a club source and time will tell. But could you imagine us picking another player over him who fails while he rips it up for GWS - the embarrassment...

Caddy is young and there is more to him than people are seeing. Still a gamble but if his brother is anything to go buy he, Toumpas and Viney in a midfield in two years time makes me dribble.

A bloke at work joked that if one kick had gone differently Ross lyon might be a premiership coach and Malthouse might be at Freo LOL. Ross seems like a really grumpy dude. But the proof is in the pudding. He has Freo up and about and looking dangerous in Victoria.

Did I say that mate? Cant remember typing that anywhere. Just making the point that he could have been ours and unlike some draftees that considered Melbourne undesirable. Tom McDonald is a handy back.

They may - its easier to look good in a top side though.

If there is one post I've read on these forums in recent times that is WAY off the mark there are two examples by IRW.

I heard his foot is basically cactus and will never be right again. He might be retiring is the call I heard. He was a fantastic talent in his day and did some great stuff early in his career - his speed and defensive pressure was second to none in the AFL at some stages. But when your on the bottom of the ladder with a new coach things change.

The demons said that Freo were the best team they played this year. I thought that was just a way of saying we had improved but maybe Freo could be the dark horse of the final series.

Good idea - Norm's curse might extend to these images if 2012 is anything to go by. Infact didnt we start going downhill from the time we adopted the new coat of arms thingie with the southern cross? In all serious though if you do add Mitch Clark - that image of him walking off being helped with the beard, the bezerker look in his eyes and his lips mouthing the f word in utter fury would be ideal.

This discussion on big footy has taken an interesting turn: http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/the-cut.947418/page-10 This is an unresolvable argument/debate. There are those who feel that as members their money has been used on this bloke and feel dissappointed that he has left. There are people like me who think it was inevitable and that he was gone either way. And there are people who feel that Liam has the right to move on and do what's best for him and that he doesnt owe the club anything - family comes first. What I will say is that his and a number of other communities up there are in near chaos at the moment. Even Alice Springs has become quite a dangerous place after dark and it used to be pretty peaceful.

Well said - the first post hit the nail on the head. I get the feeling that we were a soft club under Bailey.

perhaps our recruiting was part of our tanking strategy?

Not sure he was lazy in his last few games, more just confused and seemed to have no idea what he was supposed to be doing. He actually has pretty good disposal.

I for one see a lot of early Scott Thompson in Gys when he started out. I rate him as a player although it does seem strange that he is still quite thin. If he is a casuality of the 'behave yourself in or behave your way out' regime then I know that at least we will get a pretty decent trade for him. I havent heard anything about him going though other than speculation in the HUN so im not sure on this one.

Changing captaincy again would look bad.

All i can say on this topic is that I have inside info. Ive heard from a family member who knows his family that his preferred destination at the time of the draft was MFC and he even told the club so.

I know a number of MFC fans in the states. They try to watch as many games as possible. I support Arizona Cardinals - also rebuilding... I reckon larry Fitzgerald would be a good pick up for the dees!

hahah - sucked in - they have to lie to justify...

Melbourne footy club bent over backwards from what I understand and they have a the gall to say that. Unbelievable...

People questioning who will replace them need only look at Magner to see that you can bring in mature recruits who can fire for at least part of the year. lets be open about where we're at - bottom of the ladder with one win. Neeld looks up to Malcolm Blight - who sacked 16 as coach.

Spoke to my bloke and he is more convinced than ever that Viney is as good as a Dee - second round or pick 3 - whatever it takes - with an obvious preference. Jugding by the reactions here you are obviously a credible source so I wont get too carried away yet. Just seems confusing when you hear to differnet views that are both telling you one way or another.

Any word on whether Kelly will stay as part of recruiting?