Pennant St Dee

I think one of Macrae, Carroll or Perkins will be there at 18

Medium size players needed who can have a combination of at least 2/3 of use the ball well have pace run and carry win their own ball intercept win groundballs/apply pressure hit the scoreboard 1 or 2 players always slide, I think 1 from Mcrae, Perkins, Chapman will slide. Wouldn't mind taking one of them with one of Carroll, Powell or Henry with picks 18 and 19. Pick 28 best available for our needs if Downie is available then bid for him here

Eddie's ego is about wrestling back support not immediate recovery. Nothing like a big signing to build hope and garner favour with the masses

Beware the Pies and Eddie's ego. They may look to trade in someone big coming out of contract next season to win back disgruntled supporters

So did you come on to offer something or just be negative. You can actually answer your own questions by reviewing other threads or going to the AFL site. Let's be truthful you rarely post when we win have contributed little during trade period won't acknowledge the excellent deal for Brown would be the first to complain if we tied up $1.1million of our cap in Phillips and Treloar which meant we could not give Clarrie and Jackson what they wanted to extend. Let's not even contemplate the Dogs gave up a first rounder for Treloar. But hey any chance to have a baseless shot at the club and we know you're in the first dozen FMD

I'm not, yes he'd have been a good acquisition but we don't want to fall into the same trap as the Pies with contracts. Tmac will be a year down on his contract next season and we'll need money in the cap for Clarrie and LJ

I'm hearing he's keen to stay. Settled in really well with the group. Both WA clubs have sounded him out, but it's believed he will stay. Smart move to not extend at this stage

Yes I believe he will. I

Because we keep one of them and I anticipate Pies will slide next season that's why. Gets us back into next years forst round and I'm backing us to finish above the Pies in 2021

Would we trade 18 or 19 for Pies 2021 first rounder? Considering Nick Daicos anticipated to go Top 5 next season

Yes reading all those apology posts is amazing. Memories are short, next season the same naysayers will repeat their doubts

But nobody on here reads that or listens to trade radio. They just hear things??

Take your pick, Petty, Smith, Jetta( although the end is near) and Tmac is looking more likely to stay

B. Lockhart May Hibberd HB. Rivers Tomo Lever

Disagree it's a small industry and people move from club to club all the time they are professional enough. Applying and getting are 2 different things. Put yourself in his position your position is under review and you don't know the outcome a vacancy becomes available, what do you do?

He's applied for the Essendon Head of Football job

Not saying he's quick, just saying of the current crop he's the one I like the most. Although I agree with Rjay that Mcrae could be a gun wingman if used there more often

There's no one player around playing on a wing who has all his attributes Acceleration Clean hands Penetration in his kick Good cruise speed Modern day wingers tend to be endurance beasts working between the arcs, but Matera had that ability to burst off half back either with the ball or providing an outside option at full tilt. If I could have my pick of a current wingman it's Mcluggage

Going to be a good pick up for whoever gets him.

Can you let those not thinking logically have their rant before you bring such a considered approach to the thread

Is this post serious ET or are you joking Asking for a friend ?

Seems strange, although with the club not leaking over the last few years I would think we have something going on

Be good for both sides, and cover the needs of both

Very good assessment LT

Yep it's called every thread and saying I am hearing ?????. Then when that poster is pulled up on it by another poster who heard or read it elsewhere. Said poster responds with, I don't read that site/paper or I didn't hear that interview I'm just passing on what I have heard