old dee

They are both Backman they won't solve the KPF problem.

JVR, should never had been played this week. Form at Casey was average against the two bottom teams. IMO he only came because Johnson was rubbed out.

Picket fence are you out there? I never thought I would say this " we have to play Jefferson for the next 4 games" all the other KPF's on our list are not up to the job. We drafted Jefferson as a KPF. So let's find out if he has the goods. We sure won't find out playing him at Casey any longer or not playing in either team as an emergency. Play the kid for God's sake.

He isn't at the club yet. We have tried drafting kids. We have tried bring in second time players from other clubs, we even tried to find a diamond in the rough at Werribee. We have even tried turn back men into forwards It ain't easy. You have to keep turning over players till you snag a good KPF. We don't even need a champion just a good reliable player who who performs week in week out. We have to give Jefferson some games in a row to see if he can be that player. I doubt it but we won't know unless he plays at the top level.

I actually think he only got a game because Johnson was suspended. With his current form we would be better off playing Tmac in the roll.

Will he be missed? I doubt it! We have not won a game for the year with him in the team.

Another blinder from JVR. A goal from him and we win. Sorry he is not a KPF of senior level quality. Can we please play Jefferson for the next four games, it is hard to see him offering less. This year is gone let’s try players that may be the future and find out their value. Where we finish now doesn’t matter what is important is to gauge the untried players on our list.

Mostly agree Joe!

I almost agree with you Bbo. Cold, wet and hordes of pies forcing me to the top deck. Armchair for me too But sadly I cannot see a win.

That doesn't say much Dr those two are not senior level players.

That he seldom holds.

That he seldom holds. Still living on the promise of 2023.

It's also likely to be wet it's dangerous to go into tomorrow's game with 2 tall forwards who's only contribution is marking.

Achieval rate is low ghostwrter.

I can be enthusiastic but I wouldn't get a kick, the kolt always seems to get low statts and very few goals.

Where are you going to hide the Kolt? I would have him as the sub. The kolt is a low scoring forward player who doesn't seem to display the skill need at senior level.

PF I don't think you can play Jefferson and JVR together. Neither is good defensively and if they don't mark they contribute very little.

Probably hide as the medical sub deegirl.

It's certainly not because of form Jaded.

Why the Kolt? he has done little against what are probably the two worst sides in the VFL at present. Surely if you are dropped because of poor form you need the show you have improved at a lower level. Seems not.

Right now he doesn't have one pf. NGE. However I do agree he has been better than JVR. I think JVR has been picked on the promise from 2023 because hasn't shown a lot since.

Did Kentfield play in the forward line?

Windsor has played more good games than JVR in half the time. JVR seems stuck in his first season. Next to no improvement since. Please do not play him on Monday.

That form is the last two games against Preston and Sydney both at the bottom VFL. It is big step up against Collingwood. Having said that let's play Jefferson for the next month and see once and for all if he is an AFL level talent or not. JVR does not seem to have improved on his first year. If Jefferson comes in who does the back up Ruck? I have no idea. But please no JVR.

They have a lot of injuries GD.