old dee

I have no problem with those de listings, clearly over the last two year we lost out in the talent pool especially in the 20 to 30 range of players. Add VFL players who never showed more talent than VFL level e.g Verrall. I am no big fan of Spargo and he has become injury prone over the last couple of seasons. He can walk away with a premiership medal that is something a lot never achieve. Changes need to be made!

Looks like a disaster in the making DJ.

All true DJ, However the only interest I have is praying we don't get any injuries to our players. 14th February in Perth it is liable to be 43deg. I hope it is a night game.

Yep sounds like a good idea to me.

Is he a good player? Don't know but what i do know is the best we can offer is JVR with an average of 1 per game. Our best and i am not sure we would classify him as a KPF is Melksham with an average of 1.7 per game. Sadly Melksham is at the end. God knows who we look to for the future.

Excuse my ignorance RM but I don't know him is he any good? We have a number of midfielders why would we be interested?

Not forwards Binman! we have Zero KPF of any talent.

The ANZ have been robbing the community for years and none of them have been arrested Bluey! We need to be harder to deal without being the bombers.

The thing I like about this decision is that not a single word came from the club during the process. Too often clubs have serious leaks including the mfc. Not a word of comment from the club. A Solid effort.

As you are no doubt aware brownie the VFL must be the worst run sporting competition in Australia. I think they don't want to subtract one fan from the WAFL. They want ever possible pair of eyes on the WAFL. In fact they will probably count the fans watching by individual eyeballs. 20k eyeballs looks a lot bigger than 10k spectators.

Agree DS. We have 3 NQRs in Fullerton, Jefferson and Dull. You mentioned Adams, hmm 1 poor game at senior level to his credit. Being average in your first game is half expected. But Poor! Let's say that the job is in front of him.

This raises an interesting situation at the MFC. We have no coach yet we seem to be making decisions on who comes and goes.

Journalists! 95% are commentators. CT hails from the 5% area.

IMO Mr. Leg he has already shown us what he can do. It ain't much.

Sorry sns. I will have to reread, leaving that aside I think GWS would be the poorer from such a deal. May's value is over rated on here.

Have you watched any games this year? He has consistently been the best KPB this year. He is the glue that has held the backline together and will do so again next season.

I would take that in a flash, sadly GWS are not that silly.

Why on earth would GWS want May!

Agree with all except Salem. Culley is a keep for mine. You are supposing 6 changes, that is a high number by the averages. The problem is who are you bringing in to replace them? It's pointless if you are only replacing one nqr with another nqr. Take JVR as an example. Good Key forwards seem to be rarest of players across the league. In JVR's case in his first year he showed a lot of promise. Since then zero improvement imo. I don't think you would get much if you traded him. From memory we coffed up a first round pick for him. In my wildest dreams I don't think we would get more than a 2nd round pick.

Sorry I was referring to Lever.

That's if he gets on the park Mr. Leg. In the last 2 years he has played a hand full of games. Seems to be having a lot of injuries to his feet. Next year I would be surprised if he got 10 games. In fact very surprised. That being the case now is the time to off load him while he has a small amount of currency left. Of course it is all speculation. He might be very happy getting paid a lot of money for a small number of games.

Without Tmac they would be found out in a big way in 2027. Sadly they are not good enough to replace May and Lever. If May and Lever want out I don't see it as impossible. Father time as caught up with May and Lever is injury prone in one of the worst areas " his feet". The problem is we would get 9 tenths of nothing for them. The only positive thing I can see losing them might help is the Salary cap. Both would be on fairly high salaries.

Hmm, 12 on the player list and 13 results!

Well this is a surprise Joe. I agree with most however I think you are a little harsh on Salem and Adam’s only had one game. This year I am sad to say I have finally come to agree with you Sparrow. Why is his in the team?

Spot on JCB.