old dee

I know about meniscus injury I have had one. I think you missed my point. I was suggesting that if the injury was only minor you might attempt to get him back but minor or not these is no reason to as we wont go beyond the end of August.

I assume you mean he was concussed, hopefully not long term as I was thinking yesterday he was starting to adapt to the tempo of AFL.

NO.

Your confidence in Gawns kicking for goal is way higher than mine DJ. Last year he should have won the game against the Cats from 30 metres and barely got a point. Then this year he should have goaled from a similar spot and missed then the Weid got all the crictism for missing a similar one a bit later. Two a game I think is the absolute ( excuse the pun) max.

I would think the ratio is draft 3 to get one Macca.

Binman do we actually know if Gawn will return or are we all just hoping? Also what are the injuries to Hore and Petty? I thought Petty played a lot better this week before he was injured or was that just my wishful thinking?

Forgive me rjay. But there are a couple of certainties but saying them would have me called pessimistic.

Lot of may, could and might there rjay.

If we were playing finals it may be different but more than happy with cautious approach.

Preuss is going to kick 6 goals till 3/4 time? perhaps 1 or 2 on his good days. The only hope is that his presence at full forward might make it easier for the smaller forwards to feed off the balls he brings to ground. It is time for the FD to show a bit of daring and do something different.

It will be till the end of the season. He is now the only CPF we have.

Without TMac the next five weeks looks really grim DJ. If we continue our 2019 form we won't win another game now that will impact the membership numbers.

Very good question Booby I am as mistified as you. Kicked 3 goals including the winner. Not a bad effort for a half forward.

You really think we are any danger to the flag in the next decade mono? you mistake reality for pessimism.

And we are DR.?

They have a better list than people think. If they had this coach earlier in the year they would have won more games. They will win a GF before us.

It that figure is correct ( who would doubt the honesty of the AFL) I reckon it was 50k Carlton and 5.5 MFC.

I honestly don't think he is more than a third best tall forward. However we would get nothing so might as well keep unless someone else is silly enough to make a decent offer.

But who would take the bait?

It makes you wonder what some people actually see at a game Mr Shadow. I thought he was one of our better players.

Me too!

Here is my prediction for 2019. Carlton will win a flag before we do.

At least he is trying half the others want to hand it off to anyone so the don't fail.

Got to admire your confidence Mr. Leg.

It is hard for him everywhere Mr Leg