old dee

I agree 100% e25 I have read this story a dozen times and for the life of me I cannot see anything in it. And the photo is a disgrace. Next we will have him scratching his bum while picking up the morning paper off the lawn. And they wonder why people get upset with the media!

Yes there are differences in the heat area however the WA sides cross the continent every other week. I hope the players are not using the trip to Darwin as an excuse for last weeks performance.

i liked it Thomo

a red hot effort would be a good start

Thanks Jack you have saved me think and typing time. 100% correct and covered my thoughts perfectly. Now all we need is the players to have a red hot go tomorrow.

Thats what I am saying with all the other problems I don't care about TS. I agree with you probably got bugger all to do with Tom. I am certainly not blaming him for starters he has hardly played this year. Just do not care anymore.

How long since we got beaten by 186 points. Seriously not in the last 3.8 years.

I have got to the stage that I do not care any longer. There are more important things to be fixed at The dees than TS.

Thank you it has not been a good week for either team.

Will never happen there is more chamnce of me getting a game.

I agree but he was never going to be left out this week. But next week is another story.

Perhaps it is redeem yourselves boys. I reckon anyone of that group who puts in a poor game this weekend will be watching for a couple of weeks.

Me

I suspect he is one of the players giving trouble. Has not resigned for 2012 and is looking like he does not care a lot lately. The last 5 weeks are put up or shut up time under Viney. He does not want the job next year and I think he saying well fellas show everyone what you have got. I doubt we will see the likes of Maric, Nicholson and Bennell again this year. The older players will be under full view.

agree all talk and little action. I like him but he has given little this year. He may be trade bait in 5 weeks time.

He is the captain that has given another week. But I agree if he was not the captain he would have been dropped weeks ago or should have been

Simple he is the captain.

Jurrah! seriously I was suggesting he was dropped for same reason as Sylvia

With injuries taken into account that is close to the best team we can put on the park at present. If they start this way they are all playing where they have traditionally played their best football. I think Viney has said this is your best/ Favorite spot Now produce! No excuses Just play your best and be hard at it..

Jurrah?

Yes I agree go for it Gary

I do not think that there is any chance of getting Malthouse, he won't leave the Pies in 2012 Clarkson, Hawks want him and why would he leave, he has a good team with a good chance at the flag in the next few years. Worsfold, as above Eade, why leave the Dogs for the problems of melbourne. If they offer him a deal he will stay. We then get into the likes of Williams and Laidley. Not hot on either but If I had to choose it would probably be Laidley, not sure Williams has all the snags needed to make a good barbie. Hell it does not look easy try to find someone with experience.

I have a different theory on Jeff and the MFC, I actually think he does it to stir us into action. Believe it or not i think he has a soft spot for the Dees. Some of what he said holds water e.g. what will Gary achieve it 3 months? I think he is trying to push Gary into a longer committment.

You have covered it beautifully

Good point Rogue. Sorry mate I am down this week. Would just like them all to worry about playing football I thought that was what they got paid to do. Or perhaps I am just over all the ego's at the Dees!