jnrmac

Supposedly every goal is reviewed but not sure about points. And even if it was reviewed, what were they going to do? The ball had travelled past the wing in a flash. Would they stop the game and bring the ball back? unlikely. Like a lot of things AFL it is rules on the run. They make it up as they go along.

I'd say many here could see how the game would pan out after we were almost double their possession tally (220ish to 120ish I think in the 3rd qtr) and only 22 pts ahead. Not that you could predict the injury tally but hardly surprised that a lowly ranked team we hadn't put away would rally to take the lead in the closing stages. This is what calibrated expectations and why some weren't jumping through hoops over the win. Its all so predictable with this team. If there is a way to snatch defeat from victory they will try to find a way

Watched him closely today. Is a lead up fwd only. Too often tries to body his oppnent and he gets crushed. Badly out of form and confidence.

So the kick in strategy appeared to be kick it to pruess at every opportunity yet rarely did we have a crumber on the ground next to him. Carlton sharked the ball on a dozen occasions. Man we just play dumb football at times.

Should have been 10 goals up. The stats showed we absolutely dominated - doubling their possessions - yet were only 20 pts up. Watched Weed closely today. Absolutely useless when trying to body his opponent. He is a lead up fwd only. Carlton supporters are among the worst I have come across

They also came back later than we did due to making the GF

Who does Mitch white play for?

Chaos ball. What a joke.

Name 2 backmen he is better than..

OMac has been gifted games due to our lack of tall defenders. Simple Our backline has leaked like a sieve for years and we have been in the bottom 2 for defending one on ones. Hence our recruiting of Lever and May. OMac may make but i can't see it.

Not on skill or form he won't Your opinion on Oscar is so far from the real world it's irrelevant

See ya jonesy thx for your service. You're Done

What? No Oscar? @binman ?? LOL

They're too arrogant to do reviews

Why don't other indigenous players get booed? There is more than 100 of them playing and most of us marvel at their talents. as for calling someone a knuckle dragger I think this says more about you and your bs virtue signalling than anything written here about Goodes.

@binman 'OMac will never be dropped in his career' LOL

Garlett averaging 7 kicks over last 2 seasons. Averaged 1g3b this yr 1g 6b last yr. Delusional

Depth? Nah..you some attribute to be depth. Frost is depth. So is Kielty.

Same old problem with Oscar. Amazing it has taken people so long to see what has been glaringly obvious since day1. No intensity. Incapable of of winning one on ones.. constantly outbodied. Slow. No turning circle. Can't jump. Ineffective spoiler. No football brain. other than that he is reasonably tall. Is a neat kick and a good bloke. do we have mid season de list?

Figures. I wonder if some here still think he is AA material? Or will never be dropped again in his career. What a joke.

LOL. I have seen enough of Wags. He is not up to it no matter how hard he tries. 22 possessions. DE of 43%. So he gave it to the opposition more than 11 times. Your easily pleased. I think he's a coach killer and confidence destroyer for his team mates. You do realise that every time one of our players turns ot over like that it throws the game plan out the window. Every other player has to turn around and chase their opponent and we leak goals because players are out of position? They get tired more quickly and its a death spiral as tired players turn it over more often. But you are about possessions as a stat. As if that means anything. You should have spent more time watching GWS and how they deliver the ball to their team mates. You might learn something.

After Wagners 4th clanger in the first half I turned it off. He must have played brilliantly after that.

Who was playing on Himmelberg?

This is just wrong. We weren't slow against the Eagles. It's ball movement that count. The problem is when you turn it over and it flies back the other way which we are world champions at....

You have a reading or comprehension problem. We are missing sitters from everywhere. ie Even our set shots are atrocious.