Je Roos Salem

Don't have an Iphone. So I voted No for everything. Their too expensive.

I remember Garry Lyon said that Melbourne won 4 games last year. Hahaha

He would probably be a better play with that Paul Chapman role. Sort of Half forward/ may push into midfield. He is usually a good kick but can sometimes stuff up some shots on the run. He kicked 1.3 last week, just keep that in mind. In his career he has kicked 27.23 in 67 games. Chapman had kicked 67.39 after 67 games.

He's already played 20 games so in one sense he has already "made it" in the AFL. But he was a laughing stock today, and has been in all his four games this year.

I see where you're coming from, but Dean Bailey himself should be ashamed, because he has confronted the media numerous times, saying we don't believe in tanking and we go out there to win every week. Then supporters like me who want to win, see that rubbish that Dean Bailey put on the field today.

To answer your question I'm 14 I've followed the Dees closely for my whole life. I don't know how old you are. It doesn't matter. We're all Demons supporters.

Well, yes I will be the first to praise Scully if he comes. oops I mean when he comes. What if he has had as minimal impact as Watts has had this year? Next year will you want our team to win regardless?

I'm not an idiot. I just don't know why you would want our players play. But not win. What if Jack Grimes or Ricky Petterd were having shots on goal on the siren?

I don't think this thread should have been made because half the people are just gonna do jokes. But I'm actually gonna take it seriously: 6. James McDonald 5. Ricky Petterd 4. Jack Grimes 3. Aaron Davey 2. Cameron Bruce 1. Jared Rivers

You came here to see younger players play? Well, younger players tank according to you.

Trying to build a team? It's not complicated. This is how footy goes: 18 players are on the field for each team, all in different positions. Each player works together to try and beat the opposition. The only way of building a team is by winning.

What gives you the right to say that? I'm a Melbourne supporter, I barrack for them to win. What's the point of turning up if you want your team to lose? Come on, someone tell me that.

Why would everyone want us to lose? We haven't won our 4 games yet.

No! I can't believe that anyone would have wanted that to go through. I was so angry and uspset after the game, it was crazy. The coaching staff should be ashamed of themeselves for all those stupid changes in positions. If that's gonna happen again I'm not gonna go to the footy. Worst game ever!!!!!

Casey lost by 4 points 15.10 100 to 14.12 96.

I'd say 38,785 Don't know how it could be under 30

Tanking DEFINITELY isn't the essence of a club's existence.

Why wasn't Sylvia picked? It's a disgrace. With Moloney out now surely Sylvia should be in the team!

Anyone realise that he'll play his 306th game, the same as Neita?

Miller and Newton back in!? Miller needs to play the game of his life or he is gone. Same goes for Newton Grimey out? Hope Mackenzie and Bail play, would love to see two debuttants. Can't believe Green is injured, where's the Scaphoid? Can't believe they'd play Miller before Robbo.

Yea, if we beat Geelong I'd be happy to keep winning for the rest of the season. We're starting to regain some form, so it's the worst time to tank. If we don't get Scully then so be it. We might, but we most likely will finish with more than four wins.

You want a champion of our club, who has been in outstanding form in the last few weeks, to retire?

Good on him! Well done, get the message out to Demon supporters.

I want them to win that one, cos I'm travelling to canberra to see it. And we have a bad interstate record.

Can we just have one thread about tanking and draft picks? FOR CRYING OUT LOUD!