beelzebub

He's succeeded...we all think he's an absolute ( insert word of choice )

Freo make Nuff Nuff look like accomplished tomb raiders !!

Farce and AFL....well known to each other

Melbourne isn't really looking to keep Hogan. We could just as easily suggested he just play out next year etc. But no he's on the trade table. Discussion about the "price" is part of the game, not so much a "fight" in the sense of "hands off our Jesse"

People actually watch it !!! wow

It's a bit like a bag of crisps...more air than potato...there IS actually only about 2 days of trade....just , it's spread over 10 !!

had looked at it a number of times ...that said i just didnt take note of the extended days to swap picks. Is that new for this year ?

i think its part of any may deal if happening... so until Neale;s done and Hogan done..may isnt done...and neither is KK...I think...lol

hence my thinking there's other things exchanged

ah ...see this is where I tread with caution..... Complete Sense....and the AFL ...are not exactly bedfellows !!

illuminating...wasn't aware of that....interesting

is it implicit that they CAN tackle the sec they over step ? Im not aware

true dat

but surely a play on must be called ? if a kicker was tackled before that..would it not be a free ? I just kinda see a murky area here

last i understood you werent in charge.. did i miss the memo

whats the problem? quite simple....we wouldn't have him for very long before it all goes deja vu

tic.. ... ... toc.. ...

well as 55 alludes ( i think ) as The KK deal isnt done yet then maybe its part of this particular equation ? by this the only part i can put a handle on are 5 out......May and KK in.... there may or may not be ( npi ) extras one way , both ways whatever.. to that scenario.

OK...so what does the square actually do now? On kick ins the kicker can run over the line and effectively play on. Unless the ump immediately calls that the defender at the 20m mark cant move forward otherwise I presume thats a free kick ? So what use is the square at all now...im unsure

was thinking that too.. some form of packaging ?

your loss

just throwing this up...as it is the want of trading.. Do we actually know, should we indeed proceed to garnering pick 5 that it's just a straight swap...5 for May ? I ask this because no where ( to my knowledge ) has the club actually said that. What it has said is we wont be able to do the trade for May. The many seem to just assume thats all there is to it.. Id be thinking theres some sort of packaging and change or something else. I dont think we pay 5 for May...but it's necessary in the deal.

May just needs a new home...one with prospects.....us

No...not until he does get traded

You are correct..my apologies Billy.. got confused with others ( non twins as well lol ) Still a no though. All for drafting talent. But it's on ready to go I'd spend that 5 on. Grant you you did suggest such, but May fills a big need.