Everything posted by whatwhat say what
-
The List Manager Tim Lamb
Sounds like there's no one not available... for the right price.
-
2025 Player Reviews: #12 Koltyn Tholstrup
another player who performs in a completely different role at vfl level compared to what is expected from him at afl level he looks like an inside midfielder to me, which is the role he plays at vfl level for mine, there are clear concerns over his speed and his skills his attitude and intent look excellent
-
Christian Petracca and Clayton Oliver in 2026
wow, that would be enormous it's why i think a player (e.g. pedlar, fioroni) plus a 2025 1st round and 2026 1st round is probably our best bet getting his entire contract off the books is a win in and of itself
-
Trade Targets
i don't think we need another 'proven ruck' we need a ruck who is capable of performing at afl level, has good form at lower level, and is under the age of 25 - that's max heath bringing in two big experiened key forwards is an impossibility - we'll get one, in brody mihocek we don't need a big experienced defender given that we're getting rid of our most experienced one - wade derksen will come in as a younger, inexperienced key defender, with harrison petty a possibility to return to defence as well killer mids don't grow on trees - looks like we might lose one (petracca) and re-balance our midfield with promising younger players instead
-
Farewell Judd McVee
they are really clutching for content aren't they?
-
AFL Trade Radio 2025
they can't any player being traded needs to agree to the trade; there's no trading 'without consent' in the afl it's very different to almost every other sport, primarily because we are a small fry competition and the salaries are tiny in comparison with other organisations at an international level
-
2025 Player Reviews: #31 Bayley Fritsch
went from being the deepest forward to playing a more roaming role in the back half of the year and he looked completely freed up and much more impactful as a result one of the few players who i have faith in in front of goal
-
2025 Player Reviews: #13 Clayton Oliver
i honestly thought he was going to go down in history as one of the greatest mfc players and absolutely our best midfielder of all time what's happened to him since 2022 is just terrible to have seen unfold
-
2025 Player Reviews: #16 Bailey Laurie
Classique good ordinary vfl player
-
Farewell Judd McVee
I really still think he’s going to be a terrific lockdown small defender for Flagmantle for the next decade Such a shame
-
AFL Trade Radio 2025
Crom wouldn’t do that I don’t think
-
Christian Petracca and Clayton Oliver in 2026
Tbh I think 1st and future 1st works if crom take on his entire contract
-
Christian Petracca and Clayton Oliver in 2026
says volumes that he's actually meeting with oppo clubs this year last year was scuttlebutt and rumour this year there's actual clear plans in place
-
The List Manager Tim Lamb
You wouldn’t have MFCSS without thinking this So I guess it means premiership in 2039 or so?
-
2025 Player Reviews: #20 Xavier Lindsay
Reminds me quite a bit of Steele Sidebottom Hopefully he can have as good a career
-
2025 Player Reviews: #21 Matthew Jefferson
Hope I’m wrong but for mine he’s a poor man’s Sam Weideman I would doubt he’ll be on an afl list in 2027
-
"I hope this doesn't sound like sour grapes" - Chris Scott
It won’t be Under carpet; swept
-
Farewell Judd McVee
there's no comparing mcvee to howes imo
-
2025 Player Reviews: #22 Blake Howes
with mcvee leaving, his supposed skills that look fine in the vfl will be desperately needed to translate to afl level i have my doubts...
-
Farewell Judd McVee
funny thing is... is he even in the best back 7 for flagmantle, which already looks seriously good? all these guys played 17 or more games in 2025 - clark, ryan, cox, chapman, worner, banfield, wagner, and pearce just misses out with 16 times hitting the field who does mcvee get in ahead of? wagner, who moves onto a defensive wing position?
-
Christian Petracca and Clayton Oliver in 2026
you'd think we might be lucky to weasel pick 29 out of them such a shame one of the few players who can hit a target by foot coming out of our back 50
-
Farewell Judd McVee
we seem to exist to give future flagmantle players a start in the afl
-
2025 Grand Final
is catman doing a 'bit' as a sovcit or is he bonkers?
-
2025 Grand Final
you know it won't happen he's one of the worst commentators going around - just a mouthbreather spewing inanities
-
2025 Grand Final
wait'll we miss out on a genuine superstar father-son cos we don't have enough points...